2024 Doctoral Capstone Projects

School districts today are facing an increased need for mental health support for students. This mixed-methods study analyzed the perceptions of the school climate by both students and teachers in the fifth and sixth grades at Penns Valley Elementary and Intermediate School, using two trauma-informed interventions: therapy dogs and mentoring. The purpose of this study was to determine if therapy dogs and mentoring could positively affect school climate, thereby providing resources for mental health support. Four research questions guided the study. The first two questions focused on the relationship between mentoring and therapy dog interventions and student perceptions of school climate while the third and fourth research questions focused on teacher perceptions of school climate when therapy dog and mentoring interventions were implemented in the classroom. Attendance, threat assessment, risk assessment, office discipline referral, and student survey data were collected to analyze student perceptions of school climate through qualitative and quantitative measures. A survey of teachers participating in the mentoring or therapy dog intervention was used to collect qualitative data on teacher perceptions of school climate. The research study analysis showed a positive relationship between student and teacher perceptions of school climate when the trauma-informed interventions of mentoring and therapy dog were implemented.

With an ever-increasing mental health concerns and social-emotional needs of adolescents, it is more important than ever for schools to go beyond academics, and therefore, it is imperative to provide a universal social-emotional curriculum for students. Despite limited resources and the logistical challenges of scheduling additional content during the academic day, school districts must prioritize social-emotional learning in the same manner as core content as ELA and mathematics. Using a mixed-methods approach, this research study honed in on middle school teachers’ perception of SEL and its impact on student behavior. Qualitative data was collected from self-reflection pre- and post-surveys so that the researcher could better comprehend the depth of teacher’s understanding of SEL and its purpose. Quantitative data was gathered from the surveys to show to identify how effective staff felt an SEL curriculum is for students and to what degree they would be willing to implement an SEL curriculum during the instructional day. Additionally, student behavioral data, in the form of state reportable offenses, was collected before and after the implementation of the School-Connect SEL curriculum and then analyzed and compared to see if there was a causal relationship. Although there was no clear correlation between the SEL curriculum and a decrease in student behavior, there was, however, a positive change in teacher perception of SEL. At the inception of the SEL, general optimism existed as staff expressed a willingness to facilitate SEL lessons and saw value in the curriculum. The post-survey results saw that optimism evolve into enthusiasm to continue with the School-Connect SEL platform, as staff perceived SEL to be effective and were far more willing to facilitate the social-emotional learning lessons with their students. However, the research did not come without limitations, and therefore, further studies are recommended to better understand the impact of SEL on student behavior, and ultimately, student achievement.

National, state, and local research has emphasized the importance of student attendance and engagement and the impact of school culture within urban education. The Capstone project focused on identifying educational indicators' systemic and individual outcomes within two urban high school programs. The targeted focus areas included 9th and 10th grades for the key indicators of student attendance, school activities, and on-track career readiness. The School Improvement Staff Survey (Survey) was also offered to teachers in 9th and 10th grades to identify the relationship of staff working directly with students and the response to engaging students toward educational attainment. The purpose of the quantitative study was to investigate the relationships between educational indicators using the readily collected data sources and the results of the Survey. The analysis showed that the indicators of student engagement paired with the school climate Survey positively supported the student outcomes in the three educational indicators. The research reported results that, when coordinated, provide the foundation for sources of information to improve student engagement in the high school experience. The District’s focus on data-driven decision-making has the potential to show improved reporting and outcomes in student and staff engagement in the high school programs. Prioritizing this work within District-supported plans will further validate the measures paired with future interventions and support for students and staff in the high school programs, offering a promising outlook for the future.