Abstract Gender gap in the workplace has always been a challenging topic of discussion. There are a handful of reasons as to why this is a challenging topic especially in the technology field. One of the main reasons is that this field is mainly a male dominated field. The gender pay difference began in the 1980’s and have persisted in both the lower and higher-level positions. The higher positions have typically been reserved for males to be in those roles. This study will examine the gender gap in the technology field through interviews with a handful of individuals who are in the current technology field. Britney Galik Major: Computer Information Systems, Minor: Business Advisor - Dr. Pratibha Menon Second Reader – Dr. Lisa Kovalchick HAB Member - Dr. Laura Tuennerman Librarian - Monica Ruane Rogers Keywords: gender gap, women, men, technology, technology field 1 Gender gap in the workplace has always been a challenging topic of discussion. The technology field is a male dominated field, and they hold a lot of the higher positions. There is also the gender pay differences between male and female workers. I have also conducted interviews with several individuals, both male and female, who are currently in the technology field. By the end of this research, I hope to have given better light on the gender gap in the technology industry and that more females go into the field and stay in the field. I have looked through many academic journals, periodicals, eBooks, and articles. Also answers from an interview conducted by me, asking questions about their schooling, jobs, and gender pay. There will be charts, graphs, and statistical data throughout this paper. The information that I have looked through has reasons why females are not going into the technology industry and reasons why females are not staying exceptionally long in the technology industry. There are many reasons that I have chosen this topic. I am currently a female student in Computer Information Systems. In my graduating class, there are only three girls out of the fifteen students. This is just for the face-to-face class; I do not know how many are in the global online class. This shows that few females even now are studying to be in the technology field. I also chose this topic because my mother is in the technology industry and in her department, she is one of the two females in the department. So, I take this topic very seriously because it is personal to me. The gender gap issue all starts with young girls, who are deciding what they want to do for their careers, this is starting in even elementary school all the way to high school. The number of girls going into the technology field for their major in college is 2 low, it is still very much a male dominated major. The reasons that girls are not going into the technology field is family influences and expectations, communities, role models, peer influences, media and popular culture, K-12 experiences, gender socialization, values, and perceptions, and influences of marketing. Family influences and expectations, communities, and role models are one of the reasons that girls do not go into the tech field. Family influences and expectations can be a big influence on a girl because she can see what her parents do for a living and decide based on that, or if the family is expecting the girl to go into a certain field from a young age. An early exposure to computers and computing at home but the kind of the computing experience is the key factor. The role of a larger community has a significant impact on early exposure to the computing activities and role models that girls need. Peer influences are always going to be a factor in when girls are choosing what they want to go to school for and what kind of jobs they want. There can be negative and positive effects of peer influences. Some positive effects can be recruiting groups of girls who already know each other in computing classes and young girls can consider there peers as guides if they do not have a role model or adult mentor. If other girls are producing an interest in computing, then other girls will get into computing. Some negative effects can be that girls find themselves in an all-male or mostly male environment and they have discomfort and stereotyping. Also, girls are not going to want to be in computing classes if they are the only girl. The media and popular culture, I think are the biggest influence on girls. Roles in the technology field are being portrayed as masculine and “geeky.” The media representations are still very much stereotyping but there has been some progress in other 3 occupations with representing without so much stereotyping. There are few movies and television shows that portray a strong female lead in a computing role. There are two women that are portrayed in television, and they are Penelope Garcia from Criminal Minds, and Abby Sciuto form NCIS. Penelope is quirky, loves video games and works in a dark office and Abby has a similar style as well. These two characters having similar characteristics is stereotyping and could be the reason girls do not want to pursue computing. The K-12 experience is important because that is what leads us to what we want as careers. Many schools lack computer courses, and this is affecting girls wanting to pursue a technology major. They do not want to be taking computer classes for the first time in college, especially in a male dominated class. The early exposure to computers can help overall because it can peak the interest of girls before college, and they may want to pursue a technology major once they get into college because they were able to take computer courses in high school or lower. Gender socialization, values, and perceptions are another reason girls are not choosing to go into the technology field. Girls have limited knowledge or an inaccurate perception about what computing careers involve. They perceive the career as having little to no interaction with other people and being obsessed with computers. Most girls do not even know what Computer Science majors learn or a low percent of them actually knew what Computer Science entailed. The technology field is still perceived as a masculine field. Also, the interest to go into computing varies among girls of different ethnicities and who are already interested in science. 4 One of my last reasons why girls do not choose to go into the technology field is the influence of marketing. Marketing is big, if you want someone to buy your product you are going to market towards that demographic. Personal computers are marketed towards men, and this could be shifting a girls view of the computers because they see it as men only in the ads or commercials. This needs to change to market towards both men and women because all genders can be in the technology fields. There are many reasons why women are not staying in the technology industry. There is ‘bro culture’ in the companies, and the women are not included in groups, and they are uncomfortable by it and ‘bro culture’ is where male employees are seen as the default and female as an aberration, which leads to misogynistic and discriminatory behavior against those that are not recognized as the same (Ayling, 2021). Because the technology industry is male dominated companies have this ‘bro culture’ and this is one of the reasons women are leaving the technology fields. In the lower levels it is still mostly males, with technical staff women represent 10% of the employees. Women also are underrepresented in leadership roles and/or on the board of directors for the company. There is research that only 37% of technology companies have at least one woman on their board of directors. Women need to have more education than their male counterparts to even be in the running for higher positions. So, if you are applying for a programmer position and most likely the man is going to get offered the job for a higher pay rate than if you were offered the job, no matter your schooling or experience. 52% percent of the women in the tech industry say that they receive a lower pay than their male counterparts for the same job. Sadly, over half the women surveyed, felt 5 that the biggest challenge for them in the tech industry was being taken seriously due to gender perceptions. Other challenges women in tech endure include the gender pay gap, the glass ceiling, the lack of female role models, and the list goes on (Sava, 2022). In 2019, women were offered 4.4% less salary than their male counterparts, but in 2020, it was 2.5% less salary. Even though the percentage went down from 2019 to 2020 there is still very much a gender pay gap. Even with this gap being smaller, women are still earning around $8,000 less than their male counterparts. When a woman is being offered the same job title the men were offered higher salaries than women at the same company 59% of the time. A study led by Accenture and Girls Who Code, showed that 50% of women leave their technology careers by the age of 35. Women are also leaving their tech jobs at a 45% higher rate than men. So, by the time I am 35 there is a chance that I may be leaving the technology field because of the reasons I have stated above, I hope that this does not happen to me. Women suffered more from the job loss during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Mothers that are in the tech industry are also opting out or scaling back their careers because of childcare and in person education, this was during the COVID-19 Pandemic. I conducted interviews with individuals who are currently in the technology field. There were three men and three women interviewed. I asked five questions and they are: 1. What degree(s) do you have? For each degree, is it an associate, bachelors, masters, doctorate? 2. When you were in school for your degree(s), what is your estimate of the ratio of men to women in your classes? 3. How long have you been in industry? What is/was your job title(s)? 4. Please estimate the ratio of men to women in your department. 5. Do you think there is a significant pay gap between you and your colleagues? 6 I am going to start with the men’s answers. The order of the questions are Kurt Johnson, Joseph Evanchak, and George Dukic. Here are Kurt’s answers: 1. Computer Engineering, B.S. (Incomplete) 2. ~90% Male, ~10% Female 3. 17 years. PC Technician/Department Manager, IT Site Technician, Help Desk Technician, IT Consultant, Systems Administrator. 4. 40% Female / 60% Male 5. Unknown. Here are Joseph’s answers: 1. Associates In Computer Science 2. Honestly cannot remember. 3. About 30 years. Currently Service Desk Technician II. Previously: Systems Administrator, Microsoft Systems Engineer, Systems Engineer II, Senior IT Systems Administrator, Senior Infrastructure Consultant, Information Technology Consultant, Information Systems Technician, Network/Telecommunications Technician. 4. Immediate Department: eleven men three women, Total Company: nineteen women sixty-seven men 5. I do not believe so. I feel that my colleagues are paid a fair wage for the role they are in, and for their experience they have. The last of the men’s answers are George’s answers: 1. I have an AS, Computer Science and a BS in Computer Science 2. My AS class ratio to male/female students would have been 90% male and 10% female. My BS was online but seems to be 75% male 25% female class ratio. 3. I started in high school with AutoCAD mapping for a nondestructive testing company in 1988. Later in 1995 I graduated with my AS and my first job was Systems Manager for AJ Silberman Wholesale Company for 2.5 years. I then resigned to take a new position at Mon Yough Community Services as System Analyst developing CMCH system and IT dept. I later competed for the IT Directors position when my boss the IT Director resigned at age 27. I worked at MYCS for 7 years. I resigned MYCS to work at CRCSI as Director of IT for the past 18 years. 4. We have 7 three men and three women currently. 5. I would think each level of responsibility who have a different pay scale for the position to compare. I think in today's world, women are making 85% of men statistically which is an improvement from the past years. I would think in the near future women will earn equal pay and then surpass men in professional careers. The technical industry overall is split. I know working in nonprofit sector, as I do. Nonprofit careers earn 25% less than what Director of IT pay scale is in for-profit business. Now here are the women’s answers. The order of the questions are Carol Kirsch, Christina Moser, and Dr. Gina Boff. Here are Carol’s answers: 1. B.S. in Business Administration 2. Not sure, that was a long time ago 3. 22 years- Currently, Administrative Services Manager, Previously, I’ve been Service Desk Manager, Customer Service Representative (Help Desk Technician), Operations Coordinator, Student Accounting 4. The department I am in currently covers all areas of company operations – 5 people, 60% women, Overall, in our company, there are seventy-four technical staff and eleven are women (15%) 5. No. Here are Christina’s answers: 1. Bachelor of Science Computer Science Minor Information Technology 2. 10:3 3. 10 years – Systems Analyst, 9 years – Sr. Systems Analyst/EHR Administrator 4. 4:3 5. I do not think there is much difference in pay between myself and my colleagues. I actually think being a female in this department I make more than all my colleagues due to my seniority in the department. The only other person that would make more than me would be my male supervisor. The last of the women’s answers are Gina’s answers: 1. Bachelor of Science – Business Administration with a Concentration in Business Information Systems, Master 8 of Science – Communications and Computer Information Systems, Doctor of Science – Communications and Computer Information Systems 2. Undergrad: 50% women (this is right before the time when women started to emerge in STEM areas, so I experienced a good deal of females in my courses. And the majority of my courses were business and accounting.), Grad School: 30% women, Doctorate: 20% women 3. I was in industry for 16 years. Too many titles to list or remember… Various levels of Operations Technician then Programmer-Analyst positions. My last three positions were Project Manager, Applications Data Base Analyst, Senior Business Analyst. I have been in academia for 20 years. My titles have been Associate Professor, Assistant Professor, and now Professor. 4. In the new Penn West department, there are five women in a department of eighteen. 5. Yes; But it is not gender based. It is due to increasing deterioration of contracts. Before I conducted this interview, I though majority of the women were going to say yes there is a gender pay gap, they all said that is it not necessarily based on gender, it is more so on rankings. Everyone that I interviewed has a different position within their companies, so I was not interviewing people from all of the same level. I learned that the gender pay gap is based on the company and how they pay their employees. A lot of the people that I interviewed also said that their classes in school were mostly male, and I was not surprised by that answer. All of the interviewees went to school at a different time, so technology majors are going to always be male dominated. In conclusion, There needs to be representation for younger girls to want to go into the technology field. Women should be paid the same as men, without having to have extra schooling. Mothers should be able to have paid leave without having to worry 9 about their jobs. When hiring women, they need to be offered a fair salary compared to their male counterparts no matter the position or level of education. 10 Resources Aragon, C. K., & Ashbaugh, D. L. (2015). For All Their Advances, Tech Companies Have Yet to Solve the Gender Gap. Woman Advocate, 21(1), 18–21. Ashcraft, C., Eger, E. K., & Friend, M. (2012). Girls in it: The facts. National Center for Women & Information Technology. Ayling, J. (2021, June 9). Bro Culture in the Workspace: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. PeopleGoal. Retrieved April 30, 2022, from https://www.peoplegoal.com/blog/bro-culture-in-the-workspace Chaudhry, H., Wall, A. E., & Wall, J. L. (2019). Exploring the Gender Gap in Tech Companies: Why Aren’t There More Women? Competition Forum, 17(2), 275– 280. Harmon, K. A., & Walden, E. A. (2021). Comparing Three Theories of the Gender Gap in Information Technology Careers: The Role of Salience Differences. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 22(4), 1099–1145. https://doi.org/10.17705/1jais.00690 Jung, L., Clark, U., Patterson, L., & Pence, T. (2017). Closing the Gender Gap in the Technology Major. Information Systems Education Journal, 15(1), 26–41. Lannen, M. (2021, January 14). Why aren't there more women in tech? (and why it needs to change). Burlington Code Academy. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://burlingtoncodeacademy.com/why-arent-there-more-women-in-tech-and-why-itneeds-to- 11 change/#:~:text=Work%20culture%20and%20gender%20discrimination,equality%20in %20the%20tech%20industry. Maynard, P. (2021, March 2). Council post: Are we really closing the gender gap in Tech? Forbes. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbusinesscouncil/2021/03/03/are-we-really-closingthe-gender-gap-in-tech/?sh=310a3ee05d71 Roby, K., Staff, T. R., Wolber, A., Whitney, L., Pernet, C., Alexander, M., & Combs, V. (2021, October 19). The gender pay gap is getting worse in the tech industry, study shows. TechRepublic. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://www.techrepublic.com/article/the-gender-pay-gap-is-getting-worse-in-the-techindustry-study-shows/ Sava, J. A. (2022, March 17). Gender wage gap in Tech Industry 2020. Statista. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://www.statista.com/statistics/1254602/tech-genderwage-gap-for-same-job/ Sava, J. A. (2022, March 30). Biggest challenges for women in tech 2019. Statista. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://www.statista.com/statistics/1269858/worldwide-women-in-techchallenges/#:~:text=Sadly%2C%20over%20half%20the%20women,and%20the%20list% 20goes%20on. 12 Sax, L. J., Lehman, K. J., Jacobs, J. A., Kanny, M. A., Lim, G., Monje-Paulson, L., & Zimmerman, H. B. (2017). Anatomy of an Enduring Gender Gap: The Evolution of Women’s Participation in Computer Science. Journal of Higher Education, 88(2), 258– 293. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2016.1257306 Serenko, A., & Turel, O. (2021). Why Are Women Underrepresented in the American IT Industry? The Role of Explicit and Implicit Gender Identities. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 22(1), 41–66. https://doi.org/10.17705/1jais.00653 Stieg, C. (2022, March 10). Yes, there's a gender pay gap in tech - here's what you need to know. Codecademy News. Retrieved April 19, 2022, from https://www.codecademy.com/resources/blog/gender-pay-gap-in-tech/