^ NA9127.B5R *00121968* UPREHENSIVE PLAN TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG PENNSYLVANIA 1974 CLIFTON E. RODGERS & ASSOCIATES PLANNING CONSULTANTS 'AndJ^sss library _ Bloomsbtirg TJ^ | j\jft NA9127.B5R ^,'1 *0012I968* ,0^ COMPREHEWSIl/E TOa/W OF FLAW 8L00MSBURG )974 The. pfi2.pcJw.tLon o^ tkU ^zpO'tA: iccia {^^iancti.d tivtoagk a Vlamtlng Giant (iKom tliz VzpcmXimnt 0^ CcmrmuXy Klf^aJjii, andoA. th& Pn.o'j^Zon6 oj^ Act ISA appMv?A July 7, oi, acimhuU1972, teJLQd by tiia BuJiQ.a.u. ol Pi'.fTJtnx'jrg Pe.nn6ijl~ ;, vania o CcmwumXij k^aUiA Vq:>aA.ti\tnt o^' B/.0(};V;S3URG VLkHHlUQ Ttarju.ng . COmiSSWU CoMultaix-ti C ANDRUSS LIBRARY BLOOMSBUm TOffJN COUNCIL 1974 ALLEM REULEV, PRESIPEMT (MA/OR) EmiARV KITCHEN, VICE PRESJVENT Vonald PuX6zl W^ZZiam Hanzy, Sn. GzoKQZ Hamlngwcuf LoJitdA G. Jone4 KviQzlo Schzno BLOO^iSBURG TOiilN OFFICIALS 7974 Vonatd A. Lm^^, Soticlton 8. VaUQ.1, Special SoticJJiOfi ChoAlu PauZ V. Jacobs, CoynuUxng So^cAoXaAy GeAatd E. Vzpo, Szc/iztanjj and Zoyiing 0^{iZczfi P. W. HaggeAty, Cltlz^ O)^ PotlcQ. Bnacz KoZtzfi, StJiza,t CommU,i,lonzfi GvwJLdLino. Kznn, Tarn Jfiza&ivnin. T. Bfiycz 3cmu, Taon Eng-cnzzfi Hcuuiy "Bad" klbznt&on, Code. E^onczmznt BLOOMSBUP.G PLANNING C0MMIS5I0W 1974 RALPH VILLON, CHAIRMAN VAVE CONNER, VICE CHAIRMAN MRS. t/IWNIE BENEEIELV, SECRETARV Jack BKobyn Boyd Buckingkam . O^^^lczn. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2011 with funding from Lyrasis IVIembers and Sloan Foundation http://www.archive.org/details/comprehensiveplaOOclif 1 BLOOMSBURG TOWN COUNCIL 1973 , C. MARTIW LtrrZ, PRESWEMT [mVOR] VONALV PURSEL, VICE PRESJVENT Wittiam HdYity, Sn.. Ge.oKQ(L Hzmlngwaif G. Jo mi iQ^toji EdMOAd A££en BLOOMSBURG ICitckzn. Rmlzy TOm OFFICIALS 1973 VonaZd A. ClxoAtoJ, B. Louxia, PujiAoJi, SoticitoK SpccA-ol Sotic/Xofi Jacobs, Cotuatting StcAztoAy Vqoo, SecAeto/it/ and Zoning O^-iczn. Pcait V. GeAotd E. P. W. HaggoMtij, Clilz{^ o{^ PolU.cz. Bnixcz KoZtzK, StAeeX CommU&iondfi W. Edoa/id Tli,h<Lfi, Town TazoSuAqji T. BfLg.cz Jam(i6 , Toion Eng-inccn. HaJiMj "Bad" Mbcntion, Code En{^oficQyn(mt BLOOmBURG PLAWWIWG COUMTSSJON 7973 BOW BUCKWGHm, CH AIRAIAM VAVE CONMER, VICE CHAIRMAN RALPH VILLON, SECRETARY Maa. VinyiLc Bcncft-icld Jack B/iobyn O^lccn. ACKNMLEVGEMEm OuA appfi2.cAxvtioYi u, &lnt2.n.diLi expA.z4,6iz.d to tho&z agzncA,ej> and ofiganizationi) ioko6z coopQ.ficut<,\}z z^onZs hav& made. thU> Ktpofvt po44-cb£.e. AdditlonaJUUj, many cJjtizziU, have. {,fiom tiinn to ttme. poojcd to ctcicoiA vafiloas (Xipecti o{, commtuiLttj dzvQ.Zopmejtt. Such tnpvut (s,fiom puhZ^c and pfvLvaXz 4ouAce6 h-iU bz.zn o{^ AjivaUiabtt hzZp ajt. comptzZing tixo, conczptuaiL plan {^ofi tlxz 8£.ooiuibcug o{i tomonAM. Mamj tlianfu oaz pfio{i{^QAtd to aJU.. WJjih bz6t tocAhe* {^OA continuzd •* pn.oi,pzfiU:ij tn an eue^ changing znvA^fionmznt. BtoomibuAg PZanning Commti,4>A.on " BZoombung Toon CounciZ * BZoom^buAg loMn O^Zdat& * CoZumbia VZanning CommLd-iZon ** CoZumbZa County RzdzvzZopmznt Authority ** CoZxmbia County HouiAJig kuthofi/Xy *• Columbia County School VL^tnlct ** Pznnybylvanla Vzpanimznt o{, CommunCty A^auUi ?znn6yl\jaivia VzpoAtmznt 0(5 EnviAonmzntaZ " ** Couyitij Rzl>ouJLCZ^ Pznn^ylvanla Vopantmznt o^ TAanipofitatLon S-inczAzZy, CLIFTOM E. ROVGEPS AWP ASSOCIATES Consultant PLANNING 5TAFF CONSULTANTS CLJFTON E. ROVGERS ANV ASSOCIATES Robznt W. Llngte., A&ioclcutz PLANNING ANV COORDINATION VmnLi, E. HanyUgan Vav-cd M. Wlttiam GRAPHICS Vanizt El&znha/it hlichaeZ L. Iivio SECRETARIAL ANV REPROVUCTJON BonyUz L. PcutfiicJ-a. Gfi066 A. Gay PaiM-cia A. Hzdman t TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE -{- INTRODUCTION CHAPTER ONE POPULATION ANALYSIS l-l Population Trends ..... Population Projections ncome Poverty Education I CHAPTER TWO , -2 -2 , -3 -4 ECONOMY 2-1 The Labor Force Emp oymen Manufacturing Bloomsburg State College Economic Influence Retail Trade 2-1 2-1 HOUSING ANALYSIS 3-1 I CHAPTER THREE Residential Policy Housing Conditions Type of Structure Vacancy Status Value of Housing Housing Demand and Supply Size of Housing Units .... Future Housing Needs , , , , CHAPTER FOUR CHAPTER FIVE 2-2 2-4 2-5 3-1 3-1 3-2 3-3 3-3 3-4 3-5 3-5 EXISTING LAND USE 4-1 Residential Commercial Industrial Public and Semi -Pub lie Open Space 4-2 4-3 4-3 4-3 4-3 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS 5-1 ntroduction osophy Community Development Objectives Methodo ogy Land Use Terminology Overview - Comprehensive Plan Proposals 5-1 5-1 I Ph i I I , 5-2 5-3 5-6 5-8 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) PAGE CHAPTER TEN CHAPTER ELEVEN PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM iO-l Introduction Definitions Scheduling of Public Improvement Projects Project Identification Project Cost Estimates Project Priorities Implementing Agencies Capital Improvement Budget Preparing the Capital Improvement Budget Municipal Finances Capital Improvement Program IO-l IO-l CONTINUING PLANNING ll-l 10-4 10-4 10-4 10-5 10-5 10-5 10-6 10-6 10-8 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FOLLOWS PAGE POPULATION TRENDS - 1950-1990 1-4 AGE SEX DISTRIBUTION - 1960-1970 1-4 STRUCTURAL CONDITIONS - 1973 3-2 DWELLING UNIT CONDITION IN BLOOMSBURG, I960 and 1973 3-6 EXISTING LAND USE MAP (BLOOMSBURG TOWN) 4-4 EXISTING LAND USE MAP (BLOOMSBURG AREA) 4-4 EXISTING LAND USE - 1973 (CHART) 4-5 COMPREHENS IVE PLAN PROPOSALS MAP 5-10 GENERALIZED LAND USE PLAN MAP 5-10 DEVELOPMENT ECONOM CS 6-6 I , 6-6 DEVELOPMENT ALTERNAT VES I BLOOMSBURG AREA REG ONAL ACCESS MAP I -. 7-6 INTRODUCTION 1 INTRODUCTION Comprehensive Planning is not new in Bloomsburg. The first comprehensive plan for Bloomsburg was published in 1947 to guide growth and development in the period of economic resurgence of the post World War II era. Comprehensive planning, by its very nature, must be responsive to everything new in order to be germane. Thus frequent minor amendments are necessary and major updating requiring a clear renunciation of goals and objectives is required. Hence, in 1955 a new plan responsive to the changing times was developed and published. This plan was "holding its own" until the disastrous flood in June of 1972. Since then rehabilitation of flood damaged communities and revita izatlon of the economic base became the major concerns of many municipalities, including Bloomsburg. Urban Renewal Projects, and related activities such as "workable program" requirements created the need to coordinate and consolidate the myriad of activities and programs in Bloomsburg. I In 1973, Comprehensive Planning was again re-activated to evaluate the post flood situation and to prepare an adjusted guide for the future of Bloomsburg. The preparation of this report represents a year of intensive planning activity on the part of the Planning Commission. In one sense, it represents completion of effort but is not an "end" or a point of relaxation. In the truer sense this report is just the beginning, the base or launching pad Into the future. Which way will Bloomsburg go from here? The Plan itself is not the answer, although recommendations and goals are identified the extent of achievement will be the direct result of the effort exerted by the total citizenry. practice, a Comprehensive Plan must be an "open file" rather than a published, printed and bound report. It must be regularly reviewed and evaluated as portions are implemented and as conditions change; then updated and revised appropriately - but always in keeping with long-range development goals and objectives of the community as a whole in light of limitations of resources, both natural and economic. In Programs are included herein for land use, circulation, community facilities, and public improvements, which are oriented to meet the needs of Bloomsburg. The recommendations reflect the findings of the background information pulled together and arranged to form a base upon which to build the future. Plans for the future are not rigid and inflexible; rather, they have a pliant resiliency built in that permits them to take a knockout punch and come back strong, and to adapt readily to both physical and technological change. Appreciation is expressed to the Pennsylvania Department of Community Affairs, Bureau of Planning for the advisory service provided to Bloomsburg; and for administering financial aid provided through the planning grant under the provisions of Act I8A of July 7, 1972. Appreciation is also expressed to all the individuals and organizations both public and private who freely gave of their time and talent in the preparation of this report. CLIFTON E. RODGERS AND ASSXIATES -I- CHAPTER ONE POPULATION ANALYSIS CHAPTER ONE POPULATION ANALYSIS An analysis of both past and anticipated trends In population for Bloomsburg Town is an essential prerequisite to planning for the most appropriate utilization of land in relation to community needs and objectives. In this sense, the size of the population to be served provides the basis for the development of plans for the most efficient and economic provision of community services and facilities as well as other categories of land use. The first portion of this chapter, therefore. Is an evaluation of past trends In population size and an identification of anticipated growth based on historical patterns and the relationship of the communities to the surrounding area. The second portion of the chapter will deal with the important social characteristics of population such as incomes, poverty levels, and education. POPULATION TRENDS The chart "Age - Sex Distribution 1960-1970, Town of Bloomsburg" is a population pyramid, used to show the distribution of the population by age group and sex for the two census years. One of the first things to note about this chart Is Its shape. The population pyramid for Bloomsburg Is not pyramidshaped at all. There Is a narrow base followed by a large concentration of people in the 5 to 24 age group. The remaining distribution Is fairly uniAnother form except the 65 years old and over, age category which is larger. noticeable characteristic Is that there was a population loss or only a very small gain In all the age groups from I960 to 1970 except for tv/o: the 5 to 14 and the 15 to 24 age groups which experienced a large population Increase. Comparing the left and right sides of the chart, one will also notice that there are more females than males in every age group. Table I- portrays statistically what the chart shows graphically. I Table 1-2 compares the percentage population distribution by age of Bloomsburg, Columbia County, and Pennsylvania. The most striking fact Is the concentration of population of Bloomsburg in the 15 to 24 age bracket. Over thirty percent (30^) of Bloomsburg's population is in this group, compared with 18.4? and 16.3? for Columbia County and Pennsylvania respectively. This concentration of population is due to the presence of Bloomsburg State College within the Town. Since the large percentage of these college students are 18 to 21 years old, they show up in the 15 to 24 age group. From I960 to 1970 Bloomsburg's population did increase by 997 people. However, this population increase was not due to natural increases nor due to permanent in-migration. Rather, this population growth was largely due to So as to the large increase in the enrollment at Bloomsburg State College. obtain a better perspective of the population situation. Tables 1-3, 1-4 and 1-5 are provided. Table 1-3 shows that Bloomsburg has grown at a faster l-l Table 1-4 shows rate than Columbia County or Pennsylvania by a large margin. 5-14, 15-24, 55-64, The and the 65 how Bloomsburg is growing by age groups. and over age groups gained 1,870 persons while the less than 5, 25-34, 35-44, and 45-54 age groups lost 873 people. Overall, there was an increase of 997 people. Again, it is necessary to point out the source of this population gain. Table 1-5 shows the increase in enrol Iment at Bloomsburg State Col lege over the last five years. From 1969 to 1973 the student enrol Iment went from 3,537 to 4,368, an increase of 831. In the previous nine years, I960 to 1969, the total student went from 1,737 to 3,537, an increase of 1,800. Therefore, over the last thirteen years Bloomsburg State College has gained 2,631 students. These college students are the major source of Bloomsburg's population increase. POPULATION PROJECTIONS The population projection is based on the answers to several questions. Will Bloomsburg State College experience the same large growth in the I970's that it did in the I960's? Will Bloomsburg's local economy prosper or decline in the I970*s? What kind of residential development will occur and at what density? Since 1972 the College enrollment has leveled off. It appears that the There also appears to be no large developments local economy has stabilized. being planned. Consequently, Bloomsburg's growth over the next ten to twenty years will be rather small. This population projection is based on no substantial growth of Bloomsburg State College or local industries. A sudden change in the State's policy concerning higher education could drastically alter future growth, but there is no way to foresee such an event. Therefore, it is projected that by 1980 Bloomsburg will have a population of around 12,000 and 12,500 people by 1990. Table 1-6 gives the past trends and future projections of population in Bloomsburg and several neighboring areas. According to these projections, Bloomsburg will become the major population center in Columbia County with around twenty percent (20^) of the County's population through 1990. The Townships around Bloomsburg will also continue to grow at a moderate rate. I NCOME The existence of such a proportionately large number of college students also has a great effect upon the statistical income distribution levels in Bloomsburg. Most col lege students are not earning a great deal of money since they are still going to school. They still largely depend on their parents for financial support. Yet some do appear in the income statistics. Fortunately, the students can be largely separated from the remainder of the population by using median incomes for families and unrelated individuals. The two measures do not completely segregate college students and non-students since there are married students, whose income levels would be reflected by median family income statistics, and there are unrelated individuals who are not students. However, the differentiation will give a rough approximation of the welfare levels of both groups. 1-2 Tables 1-7 and 1-8 provide the statistics with which to analyze the income situation in Bloomsburg. To begin the analysis, there will be examination of how the income levels have changed in Bloomsburg from I960 to 1970. There has been a dramatic shift in the distribution of families according to incomes. In I960, 73.0^ of the families earned less than $7,000 per year. By 1970 this percentage had been cut approximately in half to 36.7^. In contrast, in I960 only 9.1^ of the families earned $10,000 a year or more. By 1970 the figure had more than tripled to 33.1? of the families. Obviously, there was a dramatic shift upward in the family income distribution between I960 and 1970. These increases are also reflected in the comparisons of median family incomes of I960 and 1970. In I960 median family income in Bloomsburg was $5,367. By 1970 it had risen by more than $2,700 to $8,099. To put Bloomsburg's income level in the proper perspective, comparisons with County and State income levels are employed. It would appear that while incomes have risen sharply in Bloomsburg they have still not kept pace with Pennsylvania levels. While 49.0^ of Bloomsburg's families earn less than $8,000 per year, only 21.2% of Pennsylvania's families are in this income group. At the same time only 9.4? of Bloomsburg's families earn $15,000 or more per year while 18.3? of the State's families are in this income bracket. Bloomsburg has not kept pace with median family income levels of Pennsylvania. In I960 median family incomes in Bloomsburg and Pennsylvania were $5,376 and $5,719 respectiveBy 1970 this income gap had widened to more than $1,400 with an ly. $8,099 median family income in Bloomsburg and $9,559 median family income in Pennsylvania. Obviously Bloomsburg has not kept pace with the State. On the positive side, Bloomsburg does have a slight income advantage over the remainder of Columbia County. Table 1-9 makes the effect of the college students on income levels obvious. The median income of unrelated individuals in Bloomsburg is $922 per person per year, only 41? of the Pennsylvania figure of $2,235. The people of Bloansburg are not really that poor. Because they are attending College, the students can only work part time and during vacations. They still depend on their parents for the large portion of their support, however, their parents' support does not appear as income. Hence, their leThis discussion vel of welfare appears low although it really is not. the welfare level leads the way to an obvious question. What really is in Bloomsburg? The question leads to the next section of the chapter which deals with poverty. POVERTY The poverty problem in Bloomsburg and Pennsylvania is described in Table 1-9. A total of 1,489 people or 15.3? of Bloomsburg's population was below the poverty line in 1970, as defined by the official U.S. Census. The poverty statistics used in the U.S. Census and presented herein are based on a definition derived by the Social Security Administration in 1964 and subsequently modified by a Federal Interagency Committee in 1968. The definition provides a range of poverty income levels adjusted by such 1-3 factors as family size, sex of the family head, number of dependent children under 18 years old, and farm and non-farm residence. These proverty thresholds range from $1,487 for a female individual 65 years old and over living on a farm to $5,116 for a non-farm family with a male head and seven or There are several components to this poverty population. more persons. Five hundred or about one-third of the persons below the poverty line are persons 65 years of age or older. These persons must live off social security, their savings, public assistance, and/or friends and relatives. It is these elderly persons that comprise the biggest portion of the poverty population. The second group is the unemployed. It is estimated that they and their dependents comprise another third of the poor. Another group is those people who are working, but because of a variety of factors (no ski Is, lack of opportunity, illness, large families, etc.), do not earn enough to be above the poverty mark. I Comparing the figures for Bloomsburg and Pennsylvania, it becomes evident that there is a poverty problem in Bloomsburg. \5.5% of Bloomsburg is below the poverty line compared with 10.6^ of Pennsylvania. About one- third of the elderly are impoverished in Bloomsburg which compares with 24.1* in Pennsylvania. While Bloomsburg has relatively more people below the poverty line than Pennsylvania, it has a much higher percentage receiving public assistance. 223 of the 245 families (91^) below the poverty line are receiving public assistance. This is a much higher percentage than in the remainder of Pennsylvania where less than sixty percent (60?) of the poor families receive public assistance. EDUCATION Due to the existence of Bloomsburg State College in the Town and the educational level of the staff necessary to operate such an institution, the educational levels in Bloomsburg are above the County and State norms. 625? of the population 25 years and older in Bloomsburg are high school graduates as compared with 52.4? in Columbia County and 50.3? in Pennsylvania. The effect of the Col lege is even more pronounced when one looks at the percent of the population 25 and over who are college graduates. 12.6?, 6.1?, and 8.8? of those 25 and over are college graduates in Bloomsburg, Columbia County, and Pennsylvania respectively. 1-4 ; o <T> CD Z tn HI ^ O = <J « z < t- 2 ui £ < UJ -1 O is Irt • t** u *- » < Z — J o< > W1 o a u o I ^ < z z a c O i 3 a. z O liSi oO= < CD 91 I J ? 3 I o ID CD Q z: UJ or > 2 o oo h< <. 1 1^ en ZD s*" >• ^ CL SQNVSnOHi N! NOLLVlfidOd o O o CL !«, UJ O (T UJ — j: Z O 30 (/> U) Z U. UJ O X UI o 3 z Iu. a: Ui ^'^ Q (/> o i 0< 3 O " a: o. o < UJ iti =) 3 ni3 Ui o IT 3 o o (A z o CO 3 Q. o Q UJ (T o a 3 X CD .J o "" UJ < 1<n o go: o q: < CO < 1/5 , 0- O S ID ss >CD «^ ^ <o a 3 _i O z O 1 o O Q- ^^ >- I- o UJ en o OS 1 I TABLE IPOPULATION DISTRIBUTION BY AGE AND SEX IN BLOOMSBURG 1960-1970 I960 Aqe Less than 5 5-14 - Male Female Total Male Female 881 457 763 700 1,596 338 754 362 842 3,576 1,058 993 1,123 1,730 1,311 585 656 464 509 424 732 1,137 568 705 770 584 802 1,219 1,387 525 476 482 544 498 1,846 533 517 641 675 889 10,655 4,933 5,722 11,652 5,347 6,305 1,495 15 - 24 25 35 45 55 65 2,054 1,150 1,290 34 44 54 64 1,426 1,048 & Over TOTAL 1970 Total 917 582 Includes Bloomsburg State College Students. SOURCE: U.S. Census of Population Bureau of the Census U.S. Department of Commerce. TABLE 1-2 POPULATION DISTRIBUTION BY AGE GROUPS ( In Percent) 1970 Co umb a Town Of Bloomsburg Under 7.9 10.5 11.9 100.0 100.0 100.0 15-24 30.6 - 9.1 TOTAL Pennsylvania 11.6 12.9 10.3 10.8 6.0 13.7 34 44 54 64 and Over i 7.6 17.8 18.4 10.5 10.7 12.7 10.7 11.6 5 5-14 25 35 45 55 65 1 County 8.5 9.7 1-5 19.1 16.3 II. TABLE 1-3 POPULATIONS OF BLOOMSBURG AND COLUMBIA COUNTY I960 and 1970 Town Co umb a County Bloomsburg* I960 10,655 53,489 19.9 1970 11,652 55,114 21.1 BIcxxnsburg I I *Shown as a percent of County POPULATION INCREASES FOR BLOOMSBURG, COLUMBIA COUNTY AND PENNSYLVANIA I960 and 1970 Percent Increase Population ncrease I Bloomsburg 997 9.4 1,625 3.0 474,498 4.2 Columbia County Pennsylvania TABLE 1-4 POPULATION CHANGES BY AGE GROUPS IN BLOOMSBURG I960 to 1970 I960 1970 5-14 881 1,495 700 1,596 15-24 2,054 3,576 - 1,150 1,290 1,426 1,048 1,058 Less than 5 25 35 45 55 65 34 44 54 64 and Over TOTAL 993 1,311 1,123 1,219 1,387 10,655 ,652 1-6 Popu lation Ch ange . 181 + 101 + 1,522 92 297 - 303 + + 171 76 997 Percent Change - 20.5 + 6.8 + 74.1 8.0 - 23.0 - 21.2 + 16.3 + 5.8 + 9.4 CM CO CTv O _ (0 +- CT> CO CO VO — in Pi * CN — I U3 r- 0) * r^ ro to o o vO c in m fO 00 t- c 0) •V in >o 00 Tt ON 00 in — % (N o« — — c —s r<-i IN ON CO ON 00 in c 00 +- C\] « h- 0) CO UD K1 * (7> O ON _ o •«s- in ro T o Kl (N ^ CM •«f <N rsi _ (0 _ 00 in * s r- o (SI o CO CO i iO in v\ K\ in t -a- n a- ^ o 'S- (N CM NO vO O CTv CN o ^ —^ c^ Cft NO "* CO >» ^ CM — O r~ On ON C3N o> >T ON ON •^ a\ CO On ID ID lU O Ul s CSJ CM CM _l UJ -J H 2Oo 2 lu o UJ S D _1 UJ — in _i 1- to ro <: UJ r^ —o d: H d: o\ to z UUJ UJ -1 ooo 03 UJ d: <S 3 UJ o\ OQ O Kl ID +- o h- 1 1 ^iD ro ON o rON c 0) E 00 ON K-1 CT> '^T (JN CM ON in C7> r- » — 1 Vi3 =J8°Emm ID K\ ON o o ^-^ c >t <u in (O o o ^ r^ r~ in ON CJN _ lO m <» (M ON lO r(JN s -_ 10 +- o — c^ VD c^ cr 0) s c 0) r~ rco in CM r~~ 00 NO >* c^ o <* XQ r~ o ON 00 5 K1 — o in O ^ NO r00 A rro NO n 1^ — r~ lo m^ o K> 1. ON CO 00 q; 8 •^ -^ in CO ^ NO 0) +- 1 — o 1- c UJ o O) oo 0) +ID »lO c g VI c in 0) +- 3 o ID J3 3 ID V) c 3 5 t o •- ID u U 8 cs m 0) in o cn o c lU or 1 Qo in 73 XI c 4- U o© -(- O) Ol ID 15 1- 1 c 2O E H 1 ID +- 1- 3 U. 1-7 • -J < \- o H- n* Z3 O to . en > ) o o VO to o o in o o o o o VO CM o o CN — — o O O in CO in — VO "a- CM in VO O O O o CN CM cc o U- to < z cc o< H 2: oO UJ — -> Q 2 a: :3 <n ui O O O o IJJ _J Q z: < O O •a- CTv c Q) « ra> ^ •* in r-- CO ^ K-> ^ CM •* r- CM CNJ — «k i^ CM "~* K^ l- r^ o\ •^ — — U 3 •^ in in ^ <^ +- -H C C 2: (D 1^8 _i Q •z. in CO CO _j Z5 CD 4- Q- ro CM in VO VD cr\ in in vO ^ VD in CM •^ r^ in «» «^ — in cr\ VO <^ — 00 in CM ro in bO •^ ^r\ "^ D_ ro tn ro 4co en (/) 2 — c jC m Q < 2 1- z <c UJ © 4- ro ro O O CO cc =3 CO ^^=) — 0 c VO Q1 o o 2: +o\ CO 3 C in <D c «k _ ++- 3 in c >- "* — CM 1- s- CO • tn r^ 0^ 4- c 10 c g o L. O CD c O O o to U *E CD — . O J^ o 4C O E 3 o o 4- CO LU O ce o to tro ... •4- E 3 ..— • c: — ~ r0^ H ro — ^ u 8-2 . in in < c in CD ^ ro CD CJ) D) ro ro U .— — I — Q) c c c c c c L cn L Ql Q- 0) in 0^ en c © 3 x: s1- 3 1 vt O) 3 • •* tn in c: Q) +- CJ x: •<3«k c 5^0. £1 CO Q) CO >in >J3 X) • in VO i^ c ro ^> TJ "=! K^ in x: +- ro •^ 4- O. D- CN ro — — to «- cowO ID o>'^r~rovor^coco'3-a»cvj woe— '3- CT> >» c r~ 0) — o O — CM ro Oi ir\ «a- On CN '3- ^ — ro — -"a- CM •^ O o ro Q. •f- (D >J^ +- e c 3 Z3 -~ o o O o o tlSl o r~ in 0) «— •_ •^\or~K>r-c^(NCMOir\ommK>cM — CM'3-invDCT\OOOOOf^CT»vO £- —O o O ooo -^ — hO — "sT r~- in in o o vo (D G\ U- <D a c (D o o o r^ 1 OO^^O^OfAinCM — o> ^o — 'd-t^'^vO'^rsjinrMcTi m'g-v}-mvO'>g-'vrcrv'^vor-- O O o r1 c C7^ "d- + + inmooO"^OLnvococor~ •^ cr\cor^vocO'3-omrMKO r^'^ + + + + + + — I I I I I — — CMCM (D i-O x: O — + + + + I cr o cvio vou^ Csl XI a^ fl) in I 1 I I I I I in 10 fl) (A LU t~I :•> •~~ O O CJ — < I < U- ac O O ^— •— 6«. E: (0 CTN CTv UJ _j CD >-J t- inooooocMrn — cocMinoo"* — K\ln«Dtnc^^-CMO^-c^J — r-cMO O O O in in vo in hO ro — — "^ o "^ r^ CM o o cn iZ3 M- O tn B O O :^ -- — cy> CD u <D X3 F 3 2 o in CD •— — • oin — — oinvDcsivOM-'^rohO'^ ^cofOvo^^'^c^f^r^ — ^^ — com CM — t^CMCNhOm — t- CM (0 Ll in 0) H- .— O— K^cMcriinc7\inr~-hOcooo — vo^ CMO tOinCOCMK^vDCMvDvO';l-vO CTv O O CTv CM '^ r^ \o '^ cj\ -vf r- CM — o H- O ^ 7^ — L (D J3 E 3 Z 10 0) — — st'srincsirsicomcorNjcjN crv«;3-'vi--^com";tr~-comvo CNir^m'^d-f^ — cmcm rsi t^ in — 1ro CM Ll_ 0^ 0^ Qn On On 0\ CTn Ox On On On On On O O O OONCTnonOnCTnCTnOnCTnCTNonONCTnon OCTnC7nOnC7NCJnCTnC7NOnC7nC7nOnO*C7n in CD E O O c >— —>- O- —^•^^•.•^•.•i*^**k^iKt_ o — CMrn'*in\or~-cooN — •^'S-ctn cm ^ s: fcefa<»<y=>t/»«>^fe<»t«>fa^t<»fa<^<.Ofc^t/»*>^ c 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 _J*^t/»fa«»*p«)b9V=»t^b^t/»fc^b^b^«=<^t/0 t- (/) (D Q) in — CMrO'^ini^r-cooNOCsiinino <N in 1-9 »* — «><» fc<» */» t^ 1 1 jr 1— -J < H O <^ ';f ro oooooooooooooo ^n^i^«,«K».«^*k«h«t*«« > •> M- c O JCOOOOOOOOOOOOOO -f-OOOOOOOOOOOOOO On CJN On CTn C3N ON C^ ON CJN •>r-- ro ^ e lJ_ Q) lA ui Q) _j 1 <D 1_ o CM s: L O oo o oo o o o o» o« o» o« "^ 00 in in — (N fc^ fe^ fe^ fe^ o o TABLE 1-8 MEDIAN INCOMES I960 and I960 Median Family Income 1970 Bloomsburg Town Pen nsy Ivania 5,376 4,855 5,719 804 896 1,467 3,453 4,130 5,031 8,099 7,958 9,558 922 1,410 2,235 2,775 6,237 7,954 Median Income of Unrelated Individuals Median Income of Families and Unrelated Individuals Columbia County 1970 Median Family Income Median Income of Unrelated Individuals Median Income of Families and Unrelated Individuals l-IO I TABLE 1-9 POVERTY IN BLOOMSBURG AND PENNSYLVANIA 1970 Number of Persons in Families Below the Poverty Level 748 Number of Unrelated Individuals Below the Poverty Level 741 Number of Persons Below the Poverty Level 1,489 Number of Persons 65 and Over Below the Poverty Level 500 Number of Families on Public Assistance 223 Total Percent of Population Below Poverty Leve Percent of Families Below Poverty Level Percent of Elderly Below Poverty Level Percent of Families Receiving Pub ic Assistance I 11 Bloomsburg Pennsylvania 15.3 10.6 9.0 7.9 33.6 24.1 8.2 4.6 — (0 •^ c ro —> >. in ^>B ro -- 00 r~ in <) 1- • (vj 4- • • in "* r-~ vo in ^ o o — r~ m to • • • r>- rsi -^ K^ c o c • • ro • o in 00 • 00 Q) *9.l 0- X) 0) 4- © a. E O 1 C — O O (D O X> <+- a> o ^ •^ CD in O — CO in — vo vo o — tn T^ o vo ^ CM in vo CM vo CM oo o o o .c H o r— ro +- o fe«. o • « o 'd• • o —o ^ • r- 'i- \o o • • • 00 c^ vo vo vo — t- 1- 00 (!) "^r — O m in in 00 tn in a\ hO 00 CM in ro 4- o — t- — CTs '* r^ in tn in "sj- m CM 10 vo o o — —3 V8. >- o f- O E < r- 3 tU O 0^ ^ -> tD — >en o < UJ J3 ON 't E O en L. (D (D o — CT> rn o — — in o o •^ CM — m CM CM cr\ vo CM CM hO o^ r^ r~ vo CM CM vo CM >* m — t-~ in m r- — TJ C (0 0) x> o in CM r- m Csl C3^ ro sj- o 00 vo o '=t CM en L. © >- in CM en o +- en ro c O D3 u o w ro tf> L. (D a. £8o CO ro c: Q) ffi c o E I — x: hO r~- 00 in LO j: en Q) X UJ 1-12 1 — © 'd- m CD — — oo 1 -^ ro i- CD ffi © X- 1_ 4- +- Q. D. o CD — ro Z3 a s u o 8 U -^ vo £ © « oo <o *^ in +- in en C © o 1© c © o 1© CHAPTER TWO ECONOMY CHAPTER TWO ECONOMY The Tc^n of Bloomsburg has long been a leading center of economic activity In Columbia County. Its mixture of manufacturing industries, retail and service establishments and higher education facilities has made Bloomsburg a viable community. Recently, there has been a slowdown in the economic growth in the Town. Like so many other downtown areas Bloomsburg's economy has suffered due to the dispersion of retail activities and industries from the Town to the suburban shopping centers and industrial parks outside of the urban core. Nevertheless, Bloomsburg remains as a major shopping center in the region and with the continued presence of Bloomsburg State College and manufacturing industries its function as a retail and service center will continue. In addition to generating commercial activity, the College itself is a major employer. On should also not forget the core of Bloomsburg's economy, manufacturing. The presence of twenty-five firms employing over three thousand people insures Bloomsburg's economic existence. THE LABOR FORCE Central to any economic analysis of a community is the characteristics of its labor force. Tables 2-1 and 2-2 illustrate the character of Bloomsburg's labor force. 35.1^ of Bloomsburg's labor force is in the 45 to 64 age group. This concentration becomes more significant when compared to Pennsylvania's labor force. Only 21.6^ of Pennsylvania's labor force is between 45 to 64 years old. This difference of over \5% shows that BloomsThis fact burg has a higher concentration of older workers than the state. could be a serious handicap to Bloomsburg in trying to attract new industries. Table 2-2 explains the various reasons why over 4,000 of Bloomsburg's people are not in the labor force. There are three basic groups of people not in the labor force. They are: (I) 1,798 students enrolled in high school and at Bloomsburg State Col lege; (2) over a thousand women who are housewives; and (3) over a thousand retired persons in the Town. EMPLOYMENT Table 2-3 describes the employment situation in Bloomsburg and how it has 960 's employment in Bloomsburg grew changed from I960 to 1970. In the However, by 535, from 4,366 to 4,902, representing a 12.3% increase. these employment increases were not spread evenly throughout the various sectors of the economy. From I960 to 1970 there were six areas in which exceptional growth occurred while there were six employment areas that experienced rather large decreases in employment opportunities. The six 1 2-1 "growth" sectors were: (I) Other retailing gained 83 jobs, an increase of 15.3?; (2) Hospital and medical services added 137 employees, a 69.2? increase; (3) Public education, which includes Bloomsburg State College, had an increase of 323 employees or 100.65?; (4) The professional and related services sector increased by 84 jobs or 53.8?; (5) Public administration added 65 workers, an increase of 69.!?; and (6) The manufacturing sector had an increase of 79 jobs or 4.8?. Together these six economic sectors accounted for 771 new jobs in the ten years from I960 to 1970. There was also some negative trends In the employment with six areas showThey were: (I) the textile and apparel ing major declines In employment. industry lost 138 jobs, a decrease of I.I?; (2) wholesale trade decreased by 44.4? or 67 jobs; (3) food and dairy stores experienced a loss of 34 jobs or 26.2?; (4) there was a loss of 62 jobs or 33.0? in employment in eating and drinking places; (5) finance. Insurance, and real estate declined by 92 employees, representing a 56.1? decrease; and (6) transportation related industries lost 67 jobs, a decrease of 33.7?. Collectively, these industries lost 460 jobs in the decade. I Manufacturing remains as the largest sector of the Bloomsburg economy. With over 35? of the total employment its importance to Bloomsburg cannot be ignored. Although manufacturing dominates the economic picture, the importance of other sectors also cannot be ignored. Retail trade accounts for 17.4? of the employment. The third largest employment area is public education, including Bloomsburg State College as well as the public school system. The Importance of this employment area Is further demonstrated by the fact that it is the fastest growing economic activity in Bloomsburg, doubling Its employment over the last ten years. Public education now employs 13.0? of the working labor force. Together these three areas (manufacturing, retail trade, and public education) account for about two-thirds of the employment in Bloomsburg. To serve as a basis of comparison. Table 2-3 also gives employment figures for Columbia County and Pennsylvania. The employment concentrations in manufacturing and retail trade are present in both Columbia County and Pennsylvania. There is a difference when public education employment figures are- compared. Public education accounts for 6.3? of the employment in Columbia County and only 4.8? in Pennsylvania. These figures point out Bloomsburg's role as a major educational center in Pennsylvania. MANUFACTURING Since manufacturing is such an important component of the local economy, closer examination is necessary. Table 2-4 gives a picture of manufacturing sector in Bloomsburg and Columbia County and how it has changed from 1962 to 1972. Overall, both Bloomsburg and Columbia County have increased their manufacturing activities. From 1962 to 1972 Bloomsburg has added seven firms while Columbia County has added fourteen. In terms of manufacturing employment Bloomsburg added 563 jobs between 1962 and 1967 but lost 200 jobs between 1967 and 1972. Columbia County has had a steady increase, gaining 1,555 in the period 1962-1972. Even 2-2 though Bloomsburg has lost some jobs in the last five year period, it still is a large manufacturing center, containing 29.3? of Columbia County's manufacturing employment. The table also shows that the wages in Bloomsburg and Columbia County are compatible, that is, while Bloomsburg has 29.3? of the County's manufacturing employment, it also receives 29.3? of the County's wages. At this point it becomes necessary to introduce and explain several technical terms. "Value of production" means the monetary worth of all the goods produced by manufacturing firms in that area in that year. For example, in 1972 the twenty-five manufacturing firms in Bloomsburg produced, or had a value of production of, $79,459,000 worth of finished products. Another term is "value added by manufacturer" which is the difference betv/een the cost of all the raw materials and the value of production. Simply, it is the monetary value added to raw materials by the production process. A third term is "capital expenditures" which is defined as the amount of money invested by firms to maintain or expand their capacity to produce. So as to make these terms more meaningful in their reference to Bloomsburg and Columbia County, they were reduced to relative terms. Wages and salaries were modified to a per worker per year figure, value added by manufacture was changed to value added per employee, and capital expenditures were changed to capital expenditures/establishment. In this way, comparisons can be made. As Table 2-4 shows the wages per employee in Bloomsburg and Columbia County' are approximately equal. Comparing the figures between the County and Town for value added/employee in 1972 raises an interesting question. Why the $1,729 difference between the two? The answer is to be found in value added/employee figures and the industrial mix of the tv/o areas. Seven of Bloomsburg's twenty-five manufacturing firms produce textile mill products while only fifteen of Columbia County's 123 firms produce textiles. It is the concentration of the textile industry that explains the difference in value added because the textile industry tends to have a lower value added The capital expenditures per establishfigure than most other industries. ment figures give some indication of the future of manufacturing because it is these large investments that indicate whether or not a firm is going to cease, maintain or increase production. Since the average capital expenditures per establishment in Bloomsburg are more than $165,000 per year, there would seem to be an indication that the Bloomsburg firms intend to maintain or increase production over the next five to ten years. Table 2-5 shows the leading manufacturing industries in Bloomsburg and Columbia County in 1972. 92.3? of Bloomsburg's manufacturing employment is accounted for by fifteen firms. These firms also represent 64.7? of total employment and are the cornerstone of Bloomsburg's economy. Of these fifteen firms the seven that produce textile mill products are of particular importance since they account for 52.7? of the total employment in the Town. This concentration of employment in one product or group of reOne is forced to ask the question. lated products is important to note. What would be the effect upon Bloomsburg if there was a serious decline or depression in the textile products industry? A layoff of a thousand 2-3 or more persons could be possible. A broadening of the industrial base, that is, the addition of new industries other than textiles should be encouraged. This encouragement should not be at the expense of existing textile industry for textiles will continue to be the core of Bloomsburg's employment. Instead, new industries s hould be of the type that would cushion the effect of cyclical changes in the textile industry. Perhaps Bloomsburg could be very successful in obtaining industries that are attracted by the presence of colleges. Such manufacturing firms could include publishing companies, data processing, electronics, scientific equipment firms, etc. Table 2-6 gives the employment picture of Columbia County from June, 1972 to April, 1973. This table was included because it contains the most recent data available of the employment picture in the Berwick-Blooms burg labor market area. Several things should be noted. First, between June, 1972 and August, 1972 there was very little change in the employment picture which indicates that adverse effects to the local economy by Hurricane Agnes in June of 1972 were negligible. Unemployment over the period has been somewhat high, fluctuating from six to seven percent. Also noteworthy is that manufacturing continues to dominate the employment picture with about Al% to A9% of the total employment. BLOOMSBURG STATE COLLEGE ECONOMIC INFLUENCE It would be impossible to measure the full economic value of Bloomsburg State College to the Town, No survey could measure the added earning power of residents of the community, which has come as a result of the education that Bloomsburg State Col lege has offered since its founding in 1839. More important still, the spiritual, moral and intellectual benefits to the community and to individuals can never be evaluated by any quantitative analysis. The following analysis, therefore, is only a rough attempt at measuring the economic impact of Bloomsburg State College on the Town of Bloomsburg. The prime economic movers in a community are the basic industries; those activities which are based primarily on the sale of goods and services outside the local area, or which are supported by non-local revenue sources. It is these basic activities that provide the money to pay for; an area's imports and also serve as a base upon which local "service" acUnlike service activities, the capacity for growth tivities can be built.' of basic industry is not restricted by local demand or income levels. Furthermore, its expansion also generates a concomitant secondary growth in the service industries. In short, basic industries should be regarded as the foundation of a community's economy. Bloomsburg State College is a basic industry exporting its product, higher education, throughout the country. Walter Isard, Methods of Regional Analysis (Cambridge, Mass.; The M.I.T. Press, I960), page 190. 2-4 The problems of measuring the economic impact of the College can be classified under two general categories. First, how much money flows into the Town as a result of the College? Secondly, how much does the College and its students spend in the Town for services, supplies, and materials necessary for their operation and maintenance? Obviously, not all of the purchases are made within the Town for in the surrounding area competitive establishments draw a proportionate part of the retail dollar. With over 4,600 full and part-time students at Bloomsburg State College, it is the Consultant's estimate that over $10 million Is brought into the Town through tuition, student housing, deposits and fees, books and other Another $2 million Is brought educational materials, and living costs. in by students attending the smaller summer session at the College. The impact of the salaries of the professors and non-professional employees accounts for another $7 million. A conservative estimate of the economic impact of Bloomsburg State College on the Town of Bloomsburg is $19 mi Iion per year. I obvious that the loss of Bloomsburg State College would be a serious blow to Bloomsburg's local economy. Bloomsburg State College is one of the Town's leading economic enterprises, and one of the goals of the Town's Comprehensive Plan should be to ensure the continued growth of Bloomsburg State Col lege. It is RETAIL TRADE Table 2-7 shov.'s the importance of retail trade in the Town of Bloansburg. In 1967 Bloomsburg had 207 retail establishments with sales of almost $32 million, a payroll of more than $3 million, and an employment of 1,080. Bloomsburg had more than forty percent of the County's sales and Al.5% of the payroll In the County in 1957. With the rise of suburban shopping centers since 1967, Bloomsburg's percentage share of Columbia has undoubtedly decreased. trade Industry to However, the importance of the retai Bloomsburg is still very large and will continue to be so. I 2-5 TABLE 2-1 BLOOMS BURG LABOR FORCE (Persons 16 Years Old & Over by Age and Sex) 1970 Pennsylvania BloomsbiJrg Of Total Of % Total 2.2 9.7 3.3 5.6 % Male Aqe 16 18 - Total 17 52 61 113 19 265 277 - 24 34 44 64 227 252 218 504 466 946 769 492 529 360 770 777 1,715 & Over 151 100 251 4.9 23.7 25.7 21.6 5.2 2,816 2,191 5,007 100.0 100.0 20-21 22 25 35 45 65 Female TOTAL 142 266 311 10.4) 7.2) 15.2 15.3 35.1 14.9 TABLE 2-2 BLOOMSBURG LABOR FORCE STATUS, SELECTED CHARACTERISTICS AND SEX (Persons 16 Years Old and Over) 1970 In I n Male Female Total 2,769 42 2,133 4,902 58 100 904 156 894 1,158 1,798 1,312 10 10 347 779 1,126 Armed Forces Labor Force Emp loyed Unemp loyed Not n Labor Force Less than 65 nmate Enrol led In School Other I I 65 and Older I nmate Enrol led in School Other 2-6 e I 1 1 TABLE 2-3 BLOOMSBURG EMPLOYMENT BY INDUSTRY PERSONS 16 AND OVER 1960-1970 I960 Col umb a Bloomsburg County Of Total Industry Total Agriculture, Forests, Fishing Mining & Construction Manufacturing Transportation Wholesale Food & Dairy Stores Eating & Drinking Places Other Retai Finance, Insurance, Rea Estate Services Entertainment & Recreation Hospitals & Medical Education - Pub ic Education - Private Professional & Related Services Public Administration I I TOTAL Male 61 52 148 1,650 199 144 151 130 188 544 Fema 1 9 4 Total Of % Total DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA 2.6 6.6 37.4 8.2 2.9 2.8 154 118 89 56 346 i 41 3.4 37.8 4.4 3.5 3.0 132 198 12.4 DNA DNA DNA DNA 2.6 8.9 3.8 6.5 DNA DNA DNA DNA 3.5 7.3 DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA DNA 0.9 2.9 3.4 DNA DNA DNA DNA 4.0 4.4 567 45 53 1,083 1.4 Pennsylvania Of Total % 164 97 67 283 163 120 4.3 38 22 16 198 321 51 161 147 140 41 12 29 0.9 4.5 7.4 0.9 156 100 94 90 56 4 3.6 2.2 4,366 2,758 1,608 100.0 1.6 100.0 1970 Agriculture, Forests, Fishing Mining & Construction Manufacturing Transportation Wholesale Food & Dairy Stores Eating & Drinking Places Other Retai Finance, Insurance, Rea Estate Services Entertainment & Recreation Hospi ta Is & Medical Education - Pub Ic Education - Private Professional & Related Services Public Administration 1 1 TOTAL 81 185 1,729 132 84 96 76 165 1,098 79 69 52 5 1.7 20 3.8 35.2 3.8 631 53 15 1.7 44 2.0 805 1,213 10,575 816 490 497 3.6 5.4 47.1 3.6 2.2 2.2 1.8 6.3 3.3 6.3 3.6 2.6 126 91 35 2.6 441 2.0 2.7 627 337 290 12.8 2,073 9.1 10.0 2.4 4.4 4.0 6.4 72 249 1 42 30 1.5 537 19 130 5.2 973 29 1.2 6.8 0.5 4.8 6.3 1.2 0.6 5.5 4.8 2.5 58 335 644 95 255 29 240 389 13.0 30 19 II 0.6 120 1,092 1,448 276 240 84 156 159 106 53 4.9 3.2 596 585 2.6 2.6 3.9 4.7 4,847 2,716 2,131 100.0 22,537 100.0 100.0 2-7 TABLE 2-4 MANUFACTURING PROFILE OF BLOOMSBURG AND COLUMBIA COUNTY 1962, 1967, 1972 1962 Bloomsburg 18 109 16.5 3,075 $12,405,000 $51,392,000 $20,256,000 $651,000 10,179 $42,152,000 $172,197,000 $68,831,000 $3,490,000 30.2 29.4 29.8 29.4 $4,034 $6,587 $4,141 $6,762 $36,167 $32,018 i 1 Number of Establishments Number of Employees Wages and Salaries Value of Production Value Added by Manufacturing Capital Expenditures Bloomsburg As A Percent Of Col umbia County Co umb a County Mean Wage/Year Value Added/Employee Capital Expenditures/ EstabI ishment 18.7 1967 Number of Establishments Number of Employees Wages and Salaries Value of Production Value by Manufacturing Capital Expenditures 17 17.9 11,241 32.4 32.8 35.3 21 1 3,638 $17,697,000 $73,361,000 $32,255,000 $2,172,000 $54,019,000 $207,655,000 $97,387,000 $6,568,000 $4,864 $8,866 $4,806 $8,664 $103,429 $56,137 25 123 11,734 Mean Wage/Year Value Added/Employee Capital Expenditures/ EstabI ishment 33.1 33.1 1972 Number of Establishments Number of Employees Wages and Salaries Value of Production Value Added by Manufacturing Capital Expenditures Mean Wage/Year Value Added/Employee Capital Expenditures/ EstabI ishment SOURCE: 3,438 $22,898,000 $79,459,000 $33,208,000 $4,139,000 $6,660 $9,659 $165,560 $78,251,000 $294,642,000 $133,628,000 $15,402,000 20.3 29.3 29.3 27.0 24.9 26.9 $6,669 1,388 $1 $125,220 Pennsylvania Statistical Abstract; Bureau of Statistics, Research and Planning; 1963, 1969, 1973. 2-8 I TABLE 2-5 LEADING MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES IN BL00^4SBURG AND COLUMBIA COUNTY 1971 TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG f> Industry le Mill Products Fabricated Metals Food & Kindred Products Apparel Text? TOTAL Number Of Estab shments I Number Of Emp loyees i Of Manufacturing Employment Of % Total Emp loyment 75.1 10.2 52.7 2.8 _2 102 4.0 3.0 15 3,170 92.3 64.7 7 2 4 2,581 350 137 7.1 2.1 COLUMBIA COUNTY Texti le Mill Products Food & Kindred Products 15 3,271 27.9 14,5 19 Appare Fabricated Metals Transportation Equipment Tobacco Lumber and V/ood 23 1,851 1,849 15.8 15.8 11.5 TOTAL 8 724 567 6.6 6.2 4.8 8.2 8.2 6.0 3.5 3.2 2.5 85 10.391 88.6 46.1 1,349 780 18 1 1 2-9 TABLE 2-6 RECENT EMPLOYMENT TRENDS IN COLUMBIA COUNTY 1972 and 1973 June August 1972 1972 Apri 1973 1 Labor Force 25,300 25,700 25,500 Employment 23,700 23,900 23,800 1,600 6,3 1,800 7.0 1,700 6.7 11,500 11,400 11,100 Non-Manufacturing Employment 9,000 9,000 9,700 Other Non-Agricultural Employment 2,100 2,100 2,000 Agricultural Employment 1,100 1,400 1,000 Unemployment % Unemployed Manufacturing Employment SOURCE: Labor Market Letter for Columbia County Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry Bureau of Employment Security September, 1972; January, 1973; June, 1973. TABLE 2-7 RETAIL TRADE IN BLOO^^BURG AND COLUMBIA COUNTY 1967 Bloomsburg Number of Establishments Sales for the Year Payrol for the Year Paid Employees 1 207 $31,968,000 $3,423,000 1,080 2-10 Columbia County 672 $78,552,000 $7,204,000 2,278 Bloomsburg As A Percent Of Columbia County 30.8 40.7 47.5 47.4 CHAPTER THREE HOUSING ANALYSIS CHAPTER THREE HOUSING ANALYSIS Everyone needs a place to live. The largest single investment made by a The housing analysis then becomes a crifamily or individual is a home. V/ith a sound housing analysis tical portion of the background analysis. of past and current conditions and estimates of future housing supply and demand, housing policies, plans, and programs can be established so as to meet future needs and correct present inequities in the housing situation. RESIDENTIAL POLICY The purchase of a home is the symbol of an all-out effort of the family to achieve shelter, tangible security, comfort, and convenience. The community social structure, therefore, becomes rooted in the home. Thus, it is necessary that the living areas be an integral part of the entire community and, at the same time, be separated from nuisance items such as noise and traffic so prevalent in commercial and industrial areas. It becomes necessary then to recognize that the choice of a dwelling unit by each and every family or person, is an exercise of the freedom inherent in the Nation. Thus, the concept of a residential area must incorporate all types of dwelling units beginning with single-family homes and progressing through duplexes, garden apartments, townhouses, walk-up apartments, and high-rise/high-density facilities. These must be integrated in an overall plan to provide continuous space for convenient outdoor living, and a separation, as may be necessary, without resorting to heavy restrictive controls in preference to the ability to live together in a compatible environment. HOUSING CONDITIONS In September of 1973, a detailed field inventory was undertaken, in junction with available urban renewal information, to determine the tent and location of structural conditions in the Town. The survey of exterior conditions only and structures were classified into the lowing categories: conexwas fol- Good - Requiring no repairs Fair - Deteriorated, but salvageable, repair feasible Poor - Di lapidated, non-salvageable, replacement required. I A map entitled "Structural Conditions - 1973" contained herein illustrates the relative location and condition of structures throughout the Town. Relatively, overall dwelling unit conditions have worsened in Bloomsburg. The percentage of dwelling units considered good has decreased from 71.2^ In I960 to 69.4^ in 1973. The percentage of units in fair condition has decreased by 2.10^, from 21. 9!^ in I960 to 19.8^ in 1973. Dwelling units 3-1 judged to be in poor condition increased from 6.9/5 to 10.8^. It is important to note that the placing of structures in good, fair, or poor categories through external survey is somewhat subjective and can vary from survey to survey, and from time to time. Table 3-1 and the pie chart, "Dwelling Unit Condition" illustrate the dwelling unit conditions of I960 and 1973. Another component of housing conditions is plumbing, as shown in Table 3-2. In 1970, 91 ,9% of all the housing units had all p lumbing f aci ities. Only 76 dwelling units lacked some or all plumbing facilities. Although 2.\% is a very small amount, efforts should be made to correct the lack of plumbing in these few structures. One thing that Table 3-2 does not show is the condition of the plumbing. Further investigation will be necessary to search out those units where the plumbing is substandard. I Another measure that might give additional insight into housing conditions in Bloomsburg is the age of structures, as shown in Table 3-3. Before beginning the analysis, a note of caution should be introduced. Having an older housing stock does not necessarily imply substandard housing. Old houses tend to be made of very solid materials and with the proper upkeep can remain sound for a very long time. However, older homes do tend to require higher upkeep costs, higher heating costs^ and more repair and upgrading of the plumbing, heating and electrical systems, etc. Such problems can be especially acute in a college town such as Bloomsburg where many of the older single-family residences have been converted to multi-unit residences. Without proper alterations and additions, such conversions can easily overload electrical, heating, and other such systems. 81.9^ of the structures in the Town of Bloomsburg were built before 1940. In Pennsylvania only 58.8^ of the homes were built before 1940, while in Columbia County the figure is 70. 3^. Although the percentage for Bloomsburg seems high, one must remember that it is an urban center and received most of its development before the remainder of the County and most of the State. Table 3-3 also points out another possible problem: Only 219 structures, 6% of the total number of structures, have been built since I960. This amount would seem to indicate that Bloomsburg is not replacing its housing stock at a sufficient pace. TYPE OF STRUCTURE "Dwelling Units Per Structure," Table 3-4, gives a picture of the distribution of structures according to the number of dv/elling units. Because Bloomsburg is a totally urban area, there is a larger percentage of multifamily dwellings in the Town than is found in Columbia County and Pennsylvania. At the same time there are not as many multi-family dv/ellings as one might expect. Only 23? of the dwelling units are in structures containing three or more units. The largest concentration of housing, 47.8^, is in single-family dwellings, with duplexes accounting for the next largest portion, at 28.2^. Only 10.4!^ of the housing is in apartment houses Obviously Bloomsburg's housing is dominated by of five or more units. single-family homes, duplexes, and multi-family conversions. Another interesting note is the lack of mobilehomes. Only 61 units, .1%, of the housing units are mobi lehomes. \ 3-2 STRUCTURAL CONDITIONS TOWN BLOOMSBUI OF COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA GOOD FAIR POOR -SURVEY BY CONSULTANT AND SURVEY URBAN RENEWAL BY MULLIN ASSOC, INC AND LONERGAN 1973 197 SCALE 500 STRUCTURAL CONDITIONS TOWN BLOOMSBURG OF COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA 1973 VACANCY STATUS (See Table 3-5) As of 1970, 96.1^ of Bloomsburg's housing was occupied, a somewhat higher Of the 3.9^ of the houspercentage than Columbia County or Pennsylvania. The other ing that was vacant, 2.2? was for sale or for rent. .1% was abandoned, vacant but not for sale nor rent, etc. A vacancy rate of 2.2* is exactly the same as the state average. \ Table 3-6 relates to the turnover rate of housing units by distributing the number of dwelling units according to the year that the occupants moved. The distributions for the three areas, Bloomsburg, Columbia County, and Pennsylvania, are approximately the same. About one- third of the owner-occupied dwelling units have been occupied by the same About 25^ of the units have been occupied residents since before 1950. The remaining 40% - 45% have been occupied since I960. during the I950's. The three areas follow the same general pattern in regard to renter-occupied units. About \0% of the units were occupied before 1950, another \0% were occupied in the I950's, \5% were moved into from I960 to 1965, and about 65^ have been occupied since 1965. VALUE OF HOUSING The percentage distribution of owner-occupied housing according to value in Bloomsburg and Pennsylvania are very similar but differ sanewhat from Columbia County. Approximately one-third of Pennsylvania's and Bloomsburg's owner-occupied housing is valued at less than $10,000. About 40^ The remaining 25^ is valued is valued at between $10,000 and $20,000. The corresponding figures for the County are: at more than $20,000. Less than 510,000 - 45^; $10,000 to $20,000 - 40f;; and more than $20,000 There is only a slight difference of $800 between the median value 15^. The median of owner-occupied housing between Bloomsburg and Pennsylvania. value In Bloomsburg Is $12,900 and $13,700 in Pennsylvania. These figures are shown in more detail in Table 3-7. Table 3-8 shows the distribution of dwelling units by monthly rents in Bloomsburg, Columbia County, and Pennsylvania. The largest grouping of Only 29.2? Bloomsburg's units, 42.7?, rent for less than $60 per month. Most of Pennsylvania's of Pennsylvania's units rent for this amount. The merental units, 61.8?, are priced between $60 and $99 per month. dian rent is $63 for Bloomsburg, $56 for Columbia County, and $73 for Pennsylvania, Bloomsburg's median rent is lower than the median rent for Pennsylvania because a large proportion of the Town's rental demand comes from college students who tend to desire smaller, less expensive housing units. In comparison, most of Pennsylvania's rental demand comes from families that require larger, more expensive units. Bloomsburg's rental units bring higher rents than Columbia County rental units because of the concentration of rental demand in the Town and the public services offered in the Town that are not available in the rural County. 3-3 HOUSING DEMAND AND SUPPLY There are several questions to consider in the examination of housing demand and supply. Are there enough units available at a price that the Is the distribution of the housing stock according people can afford? to size in equi ibri um with the size of families or persons per unit? What wi be the future housing demand, and how wi the present housing stock have to be changed to meet that need? I I I I I Table 3-9 shows the relationships between family incomes, the distribution of housing at various costs, and the distribution of families and population according to income. The table is based on the assumption that the maximum amount a family can afford for a home purchase is 2.5 times their annual family income. This is only a very general rule-of-thumb formula. The amount any individual family would spend could vary greatly, depending on the number of children, any special expenses of that family, the region of the country, the real estate market, and a long list of other variables. Therefore, Table 3-9 should be looked on as only a rough, generalized guide and should not be applied to particular cases. According to Table 3-9, 15.5^ of the families in Bloomsburg earn less than $4,000 per year. Using the assumption that they can afford a home valued up to 2.5 times their annual income, their housing supply must be made available at less than $10,000. 33.3^ of Bloomsburg's housing is in this price range. With 36.1^ of the population in this group, it would appear that the housing supply approximately meets demand. 26.0^ of the population earns between $4,000 and $7,999 per year. This group, assuming that they bought in their price range, could afford 43.4^ of the housing. Is this group over supplied? The answer is no because these figures represent maximum housing costs. It would seem very reasonable for some families to choose not to pull their belts so tight as to spend a maximum amount of their income on housing. Therefore, some of those families earning more than $8,000 per year will be looking for homes below the $20,000 cost level. From looking at Table 3-9 and the previous paragraph, one might easily reach the conclusion that housing prices are within reach of family incomes. It might be very true that a family couid afford a house for less than $10,000 but in what kind of condition would it be? From Table 3-1, 10.8? of the housing is considered poor. Though the supply of housing is adequate for the number of lower income families, the supply of adequate standard housing might not be. Table 1-9 stated that 33.6^ of the elderly were below the poverty level. Is there low-cost housing available for the elderly? The answers to these questions will require further investigation and study. Table 3-10 provides the same type of analysis for rental units as Table 3-9 does for owner-occupied housing. Again, the rental figures are maximums. The basic assumption is that a family should spend no more than 25^ of their monthly income on rent if utilities are included; or 20^ if utilities are not included. This analysis uses the 20/^ approach. As with the value of owner-occupied housing, the distribution of rental units according to rent is less than the maximum. Again, it seems reasonable to 3-4 assume that famlMes and individuals do not wish to so restrict their budOne will also note that there gets so as to spend a maximum for housing. A probable explanation are no units provided at $250 per month or more. is that persons at the necessary income level ($1,200 per month or more) tend to buy homes rather than rent. The same kind of questions can be raised about the supply of rental units Though from a quantity standas in the case of owner-occupied housing. point the supply and demand of rental units appears to be in equilibrium with the cost, what about the quality of these units? Are a significant amount of the low-rent units substandard? Is the housing for the elderly adequate? SIZE OF HOUSING UNITS Another aspect of housing supply and demand is the size of dwelling units. Table 3-11 provides a breakdown of housing by the number of bedrooms per dwelling unit. One of the first things to be noted is the prevalence of 43.7^ of Bloomsburg's dwelling units are renrental units in Bloornsburg. tals as opposed to 31.2^ for Pennsylvania and only 26.9^ for Columbia CounBloomsburg's rental units are almost equally divided among one, two, ty. and three bedroom units while Pennsylvania's rental units are predominately one and two bedroom units and Columbia County's tend to be two and three bedroom units. The dispersion of rentals in the Town of Bloornsburg tends Among to indicate a wider market than in Columbia County or Pennsylvania. owner-occupied dwelling, the largest supply is three bedroom units in Bloornsburg, Columbia County, and Pennsylvania. Is the distribution of units according to size in balance with the size of From the households? Table 3-12 helps provide some insight to the answer. table, one can see that average number of persons per unit and average famAverage ly size is smaller in Bloornsburg than in the County or the State. Such averages family size is 3.11, and average household size is 2.70. In would be indicative of a strong demand for two and three bedroom units. Bloomsburg the supply reflects this demand with over 70^ of the dwelling units being of the two or three bedroom type. i FUTURE HOUSING NEEDS What about the future housing needs of Bloomsburg? Tables 3-12 and 3-13 give an approximate idea of future housing demands based on the population projection, the percent housing supply and demand, and trends in average During the past two decades average household family and household size. Bloomsburg and Columbia size has been decreasing throughout the State, From 1950 to 1970 average family size in County fit within this pattern. If this trend to smaller Bloomsburg has decreased from 4.00 to 3. families should continue, the need for larger dwelling units will likewise diminish. The breaking up of households into smaller units will mean a larger number of households and an increased demand for conversion apartments and smaller units. I 3-5 I . Table 3-13 gives approximate future housing needs in the Town of Bloomsburg These are only very approximate because average housefor 1980 and 1990. hold size can easily fluctuate and as pointed out previously the number of it is estimated that college students per structure is extremely flexible, Bloomsburg will need 125 to 300 new housing units before 1980 in order to meet the demand. By 1990 new demand will necessitate an additional 250 to 520 new units. As noted on Table 3-13 this analysis did not attempt to estimate the number of units needed to replace those housing units removed by code enforcement or by urban renewal. According to the most recent survey of housing condiThe decision tions, 10.8^ of the housing in Bloomsburg is considered poor. as to whether these units will require rehabilitation or replacement is beyond the scope of this study and necessitates a structure by structure decision by housing authorities, local planning commissions, and other government agencies. NOTE ; Figures used which reflect the total dwelling units in the Town of Bloomsburg vary somewhat depending on the source of information and the criteria used in classification and evaluation and comparison techniques employed The U.S. Census of Housing, from which in the process of documentation. a substantial portion of housing information was extracted, reflects as many as four (4) different totals for a particular classification or grouping of dwelling units. This is due, in part, to a wide range of variables such as random sampling techniques, computer allocation rates for non-response, and inconsistency and human error in field compilation of data. in mind that although there are minor discrepancies in reported totals, this is the best information available on the subject and comparative analyses based on this information is quite valid. Bear A word about inflation; the effects of inflation on housing costs were not addressed in the Comprehensive Plan. This omission was not an oversight, but intentional because of several factors. One, there is no data available that would be applicable to Bloomsburg. Two, because of the Agnes Flood of 1972 and Government response in terms of flood plain regulations and insurance programs, some properties have actually declined in value and; three, price increases have not been uniform across the board because of factors such as local housing demand, type of housing, size, condition, and other characteristics of the housing supply. 3-6 3f o< > > *rt i/1 *- Z — ro 1^ O) < X i ° z C "O c O LU W1B<M => CO z S " >- m - >- ^ o ^ ^ w < -JZ < < 5 o uj cr 2 UJ UJ z q: o tf) </> CD O CD ?;.oc zn CO < m ^ ^ Q -I otJ tr ID- UJ o OQ < * i a: a: O O o -J CQ 2 o o CL tl. o o iD CO CO O s — I ^s Q O © ^© u CO I o CO CT> O tlJ o o CO W —J ^, I 1 TABLE 3-1 DWELLING UNIT CONDITIONS IN BLOOMSBURG I960 and 1973 1973 I960 Number Percent Number Percent Good 2,639 71.2 2,383 69.4 Fai r 813 21.9 680 19.8 Poor 255 6.9 371 10.8 3,707 100.0 3,434 100.0 TOTAL SOURCE: I960 U. S. Census of Population. 1973 Survey by Consultant, supplemented by the Columbia County Redevelopment Authority in the Urban Renewal Area. TABLE 3-2 PLUMBING CONDITIONS IN BLOOMSBURG 1970 Lacking Piped Hot Water Only Lacking Other Plumbing 3,585 14 62 Units 3,446 13 60 Owner-Occupied Housing Units 1,876 8 12 Renter-Occupied Housing Units 1,570 5 48 With Al Plumbing Faci ities Total Occupied and Vacant Housing Units Total Occupied Housing Total Negro-Occupied Housing Units II Vacant 85 3-7 2 1 1 TABLE 3-3 YEAR STRUCTURE BUILT Bloomsburg Owe ing Units I 1969 - March Co umb a County (.%) Pennsy van! I I Percent 1 1 35 1.0 2.2 1.9 1968 118 3.2 4.9 6.3 I960 - 1964 66 1.8 4.7 7.2 1950 - 1959 237 6.5 11.2 16.5 1940 - 205 5.6 6.7 9.3 1939 or Earl ler 2,998 81.9 70.3 58.8 TOTAL 3,659 100.0 100.0 100.0 1965 - 1970 1949 TABLE 3-4 DWELLING UNITS PER STRUCTURE 1970 Bloomsbu rg Number Pe rcent Type of Structure Columbia County (%) Pennsylvania (?) Single Family Detached 1,675 45.8 73.9 53.6 Single Family Attached 72 2.0 12.2 19.0 1,034 28.2 5.2 9.6 Three and Four Dwelling Units 436 11.9 Five or More Dwe Units 38! 10.4 0.2 9.7 61 1.7 5.4 2.3 3,659 100.0 100.0 100.0 Two Dwel Ing Units I Mobi le Home TOTAL 1 5.8 ing 3-8 TABLE 3-5 OCCUPANCY AND VACANCY STATUS FOR YEAR-ROUND HOUSING UNITS 1970 Bloomsburq Number Percent Occupied 3,519 Vacant For Rent For Sale Co umb a County (.%) Pennsylvania 95.8 95.5 1 96.1 2.2 86 i (?) 2.2 1.6 67 1.7 1.0 1.6 19 0.5 0.6 0.6 Other Vacant 66 2.6 2.3 Co umb a County (%) Pennsyl vania 100.0 100.0 1.7 TABLE 3-6 YEAR MOVED INTO UNIT BY NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS 1970 Bloomsburg Number Percent NER-OCCUPIED 1969 - March 1968 1967 1965-1966- 1,896 1970 1960-1964 1950-1959 1949 or Earl er 6.3 NO 5.8 7.3 6.6 16.4 24.3 33.3 310 461 632 RENTER-OCCUPIED 1969 - March 1968 1967 100. 120 138 125 1965-1966 1960-1964 1950-1959 1949 or Earl ier i 7.9 5.7 7.0 5.5 13.5 13.8 16.1 17.0 22.1 27.6 34.7 29.1 100.0 1,623 1970 1 100.0 100.0 514 213 31.7 31.5 30.8 13.1 10.7 14.4 181 11.2 142 8.7 22.2 22.3 248 15.3 10.4 15.2 9.9 14.5 10.2 9.6 10.6 7.8 169 156 3-9 TABLE 3--7 VALUE OF OWNER-OCCUPIED HOUSING 1970 Bloomsburg Percent Number Less Than $5,000 $ 5,000 - 7,499 Co umb a County (?) 93 6.8 156 11.3) 13.0 ) 7,500 - 9,999 208 15.1) $10,000 - 12,499 208 15.1) $ i 1 ) $12,500 - 14,999 153 II. 1) $15,000 - 17,499 129 9.4) ) Pennsylvania (?) 6.8 11.4 32.8 13.2 13.7 25.2 11.2 10.5 14.1 $17,500 - 19,999 109 $20,000 - 24,999 158 11.5 7.5 10,8 $25,000 - 34,999 107 7.8 5.3 8.5 $35,000 - 49,999 34 2.5 1.5 3.6 $50,000 & Over 20 1.5 0.6 1.7 1,375 100.0 100.0 100.0 $11,100 $13,700 TOTAL MEDIAN VALUE NOTE : $12,900 Does not include occupied single-family houses on 10 acres or more nor residences with businesses on the property. Does not include mobilehomes . SOURCE: 8.6 7.9) U. S. Census of Population and Housing Bureau of the Census U. S. Department of Commerce. 3-10 TABLE 3-8 MONTHLY CONTRACT RENT 1970 Bloomsburg Percent Co umb a County (,%) Pennsy vania 95.3 90.2 98.6 HutTiber PAYING CASH RENT Less Than $40 $40 - $59 $60 - $79 $80 - $99 $100 - $149 $150 & Over WITHOUT PAYMENT OF CASH RENT TOTAL SOURCE: ,536 9.4 33.3 31.3 9.6 151 535 504 155 173 10.7 1.0 18 4.7 75 100. 1,611 MEDIAN RENT NOTE: 1 1 $63 1 i 18.8 5.1 36.5 23.5 5.5 5.3 0.6 24.1 46.2 15.6 6.3 1.3 9.8 1.4 100.0 100.0 $56 $73 Does not include single-family houses on ten or more acres. S. Census of Population and Housing Bureau of the Census U. S. Department of Commerce U. 3-1 I TABLE 3-9 HOUSING DEMAND AND SUPPLY IN BLOOMSBURG 1970 Va ue 1 Fami ly Incomes % Of Housing Units % Of Popul at ion 15.5 36.1 Less Than $10,000 33.3 1 Less Than $4,000 Of Housing Units % Of Famf tes $ 4,000 - 7,999 33.5 26.0 $10,000 - $19,999 43.4 $ 8,000 - 14,999 41.6 30.9 $20,000 - $34,999 19.3 9.4 7.0 100.0 100.0 $15,000 or More TOTAL NOTE: $35,000 or More 4.0 100.0 Assumes that the maximum a family should spend on a home is 2.5 times their annual family income. It would probably be more accurate to apply this formula to net family income versus gross family income. TABLE 3-10 RENTAL DEMAND AND SUPPLY IN BLOOMSBURG 1970 Monthly ncome % Of Unre lated Individuals 15.5 % Of Fami 1 Less Than $300 1 ies Population Monthly Rent % Of Rental Units 90.2 36.1 Less Than $60 42.7 % Of $ 300 - 699 33.5 6.2 26.0 $ 99 40.0 $ 700 - 1200 41.6 2.9 30.9 $100 - 249 11.7 9.4 0.7 7.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 $1200 or More TOTAL 60 - $250 or More 95.3 NO CASH RENT 4.7 100.0 NOTE: Assumes that the maximum a family should spend on rent is 20;? of their monthly income or 25^ of their monthly income if the rent includes This analysis uses the 20^ figure. utilities. 3-12 I 1 TABLE 3-1 NUMBER OF BEDROOMS IN ALL OWNER OCCUPIED AND RENTER OCCUPIED DWELLING UNITS I 1970 Pe rcent Co umb a County (%) Penn sy vania Jumber I 3,558 100.0 100.0 100.0 Bl NUMBER OF DWELLING UNITS None One Two Three Four or More 24 0.7 651 18.3 832 1,664 387 23.4 46.7 NUMBER OF OWNER OCCUPIED DWELLING UNITS None One Two Three Four Five or More 1 i 0.4 8.9 27.5 45.9 17.3 10.9 2,004 1.6 13.3 27.1 41.9 16.1 0.3 2.5 0.1 3.5 394 1,114 332 40 31.3 9.3 3.9 17.2 36.2 12.8 2.9 ll.l l.i 43.7 1,554 0.7 15.5 36.5 II. 3.0 26.9 0.3 5.6 9.6 24 527 438 550 14.8 12.3 15.5 11.2 15 0.4 0.2 3-13 68.8 73.1 56 3 124 NUMBER OF RENTER OCCUPIED DWELLING UNITS None One Two Three Four or More oomsburq 31.2 1.4 10. 11.3 3.0 5.4 TABLE 3-12 PERSONS PER OCCUPIED DWELLING UNIT AND AVERAGE FAMILY SIZE 1950 - 1970 1950 I960 1970 2.70 (3.11) 3.18 2.99 (4.00) (3.87) COLUMBIA COUNTY (Average Family Size) 3.41 3.17 PENNSYLVANIA (Average Family Size) 3.49 BLOOMSBURG (Average Family Size) 3.14 (3.77) 3.18 (3.92) 3.31 TABLE 3-13 APPROXIMATE FUTURE HOUSING NEEDS IN BLOOMSBURG. 1980 & 1990 Number Of New Units Needed 1980 Number Of Housing Units ( 1970-1980) Number Of New Units Needed 1990 Number Of Housing Units ( 1970-1990) Efficiency and One Bedroom 675 - 725 20 - 50 700 - 750 50 - 75 Two Bedrooms 850 - 900 30 - 70 875 - 950 50 - 120 1,700 - 1,800 50 - 140 25 - 60 Three Bedrooms Four or More Bed rooms TOTAL NOTE: 400 - 450 3,750 - 3,875 125 - 300 1,750 - 1,900 425 - 475 4,000 - 4,075 100 - 240 50 - 85 250 - 520 The number of new units needed for 1980 and 1990 relates only to those This table does not include necessary to house population increases. those units necessary to replace dilapidated units. 3-14 CHAPTER FOUR EXISTING LAND USE CHAPTER FOUR EXISTING LAND USE This Chapter is intended to provide an overview of the location and extent of the concentration of specific land uses throughout the Town. The various uses of land have been, for the purpose of this report, grouped into the fol lowing categories: residential, conYnercial, industrial, (institutional) public and semi-public, rights-of-way, public recreation, agriculture and vacant, woodland and streams. Concurrently with the structural condition survey in September of 1973, supplemented by available urban renewal information, a field survey was conducted in order to identify and locate uses in the above mentioned categories, and the results are illustrated on the accompanying map entitled "Existing Land Use". Further documentation of the data obtained is set forth in Table 4-1 which indicates the number of acres and percentage relationships of the land uses with comparisons of previous years and surveys. A pie chart illustration entitled "Existing Land Use - 1973" presents the relationship between the uses in terms of gross land area, and the net or developed land area. Existing land use, adjacent to the Town, in parts of Montour, Hemlock, Mount Pleasant and Scott Townships was also surveyed and delineated on the map "Existing Land Use - Bloomsburg Area", to provide a regional illustration of existing development trends. However, all existing land use averages and percentage comparisons are specifically oriented to the Town of Bloomsburg. The classification of land as to its use is highly subjective. That is, in many cases it is up to the interpretation of the person doing the land use survey as to what classification under which a particular parcel of land is placed. There are several examples of this difference in interpretation in Bloomsburg when one compares the 1964, 1970, and 1973 land use surveys. For example, the amount of institutional and semi-public land has decreased from 15.4^ to 9.1%, Much of this was a real decrease as the decrease of the Bloomsburg Municipal Airport by 100 acres for example. However, other portions of this decrease can be explained by a reclassification of the land as in the case of the Bloomsburg Hospital property. Only 8.8 acres of the Hospital property v/ere classified as institutional and semi-public in 1973. The remainder was reclassified as open space, for even though it is o wned by an institution its use is as open space. Therefore, when one is comparing these land use figures, keep their subjective nature in mind. The land use survey is one of the most important aspects of the Comprehensive Plan. Land use analysis identifies existing use patterns, particularly explains traffic patterns, identifies areas according to their needs for community services and facilities, and serves as a basis for the land use 4-1 The present pattern of plan, zoning ordinance, and future traffic plan. land use also provides information that will be incorporated into population projections and economic analysis. RESIDENTIAL Residential uses still occupy the greatest portion of the Town's developed There are approximately 512 acres of residential land in the land area. Town now as compared with 492 acres in 1970 and 482 acres in 1964. Most of the residential development is concentrated on a broad hillside between First Street and the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad. Other concentrations of residences occur just north of the Town Park; in the vicinity of the College; strips of residential development northward along Route 42; and eastward along Old Berwick Road, Seventh Street, and Light Street Road. The sparse residential development along the periphery of the developed area of the Town blends into the countryside and becomes farmland to the north and west of the center of Town. Much of the residential development is characterized by a widespread mixture of single-family, two-family, and multiple-family housing types, particularly in the older sections. In I960, approximately 10% of the residences were single-family homes, 29^ were multi-family homes, and \% were mobi lehomes. By 1970, approximately 5\% were single-family residences, The 19^ change 48^ v/ere multi-family residences, and 1^ were mobi lehomes. in the relationship betv/een single-family and multi-family residences can be largely explained by the expansion of student housing, through the conversion of homes to multiple dwellings. A well-defined single-family residential area has developed south of the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad and north of the Town Park and in the vicinity of the College and the Hospital. Much of the original residential development of the Town is characterized by small lots and the lack of front, side, and rear yards that is typical of early development patterns. The Town's growth has always been restricted by periodic flooding and has been forced to concentrate in a compact area on a ridge of relatively level high ground. Residential development has been influenced considerably by the widespread use of the gridiron street pattern. New streets were plotted in a grid that extended outward from existing development, sometimes without regard for irregular topography. Overcrowded neighborhoods with high population densities were created that The lack of garage or failed to provide adequate privacy or living space. driveway space intensifies the problem of on-street parking and adds to congestion. Two-family and multiple-family residences are widely scattered throughout the Town without any definable pattern. Since few were constructed for this type of occupancy originally, most are the result of a long and continuous process of converting single-family residences to multiple use. Numerous small apartments and housing units are located in the large old homes and mansions that have been converted to multiple-family use. Some of this space is occupied by college students living off-campus. A sizable number of units are located in and around the Central Business District and south of the Col lege. 4-2 C0f4^ERCIAL Commercial uses occupy approximately 208 acres or seven percent (7%) of the Town's total area. The Central Business District along Main Street This small compact area is a major shopping center in Columbia County. contains the major proportion of the Town's retail stores, specialty shops, restaurants, professional offices, banks, theaters, and services. This district is essentially a "one-street" shopping center that extends back to the rear a ley behind Main Street. A number of commercial uses are also located along East Street and U.S. Route II. A secondary shopping center is developing around the Market-East Ninth Streets intersection. I Nurseries and greenhouses occupy a traditional place in Bloomsburg's economy and account for about 63 acres of land. The largest is the Dill ion Nurthe sery located on flat lands along Route II in both Bloomsburg and Scott Tov/nship. Others are to be found along River Road, Old Country Road, and at the end of Franklin Avenue. Nurseries develop large parcels of land, greenhouses, and planting areas and are strategic properties in a community because they are easily adaptable to more intensive use. INDUSTRIAL Industrial and manufacturing uses occupy 134 acres or 4.5% of the Town's area. These uses are concentrated along Railroad Street, U.S. Route II, and Ferry Road. Most of the land utilized for industrial uses are occuThese pied by the Magee Carpet Company and several textile manufacturers. provide the bulk of the Town's manufacturing employment opportunities. PUBLIC AND SEMI -PUBLIC Bloomsburg is very fortunate in that such a high percentage of its land is used for public, semi-public, and institutional purposes. Bloomsburg State College occupies 125.6 acres (4.2^) of the Town, 124.1 acres are in the Bloomsburg Fair Grounds (4.2fj), and public recreation land (parks, Other playgrounds, etc.) account for 144.78 acres or 4.9% of the Town. State, acreages under this category would include Town, County, and Federal property, churches, schools, the Municipal Airport, the Bloomsburg In total, Hospital, the water company, and the sewage treatment plant. 10.7^ of the gross area of the Town of Bloomsburg is used for institutional, public, and semi-public uses. OPEN SPACE Approximately 49.2^ of the Town is still open, i.e., land used for public However, it recreation, agriculture and vacant, woodland, and streams. is important to note that only 144.78 acres (4.9%) are in public ownership. The large majority of the open land is still in private hands and A as such a proper amount of open space for the future is not assured. program of land acquisition for recreation and open space should be instituted so that development will not absorb all of the land. Any acquisition program must be based on a detailed study of needs, land availability and 4-3 It is next to impossible to set a goal, such as financial capabilities. 10 or 20 acres per year for acquisition; but, in lieu thereof. Town Counci and Planning Commission should maintain a constant av/areness of the need for this type of land and act promptly when opportunities for acquisition come to ight. I 4-4 EXISTING LAND US TOWN OF BLOOMSBUI COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA SCiLE lOO Residential Commercial i School + Hospital • Court House * Town Hall po Post Office industrial Nursery a Greenhouse 5xE>!l WOODED J O Farm Group iiiai Municipal Parking Recreation • SOURCE; ' --.03 I Public a Semi- Public agricultural a Open area Jail Fire Station 1973-SURVEr SY URBAN RENEWAL S AND LONERGAN AS INDUS EXISTING BLOOMSBURG LAND AREA U COLU EXISTING BLOOMSBURG LAND AREA USE COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA r»- cr> in (N o in o\ in r- o — r^ r^ ^ ^o a> 00 CM o in 0\ cr. r- vo ':)• r~^ 00 tn o^ K> CNI — o o o — CO •^ m «* — o N^ in CN — oo ^o o —o hO CO — Ov CN — in CM vo 00 (Nj 00 rr^ r- vD r• • • CM • •>* in 00 o in O O O O 'ft o o r- — CTi VO CN • • vO VD VO CN '3- to UJ CO 4J o < I !jJ o r- 55 o> CTi CN CN • • • in -^t •* VO VO 00 o St CO vO vO o o rz a) (J u <j) CL a to s: c o o — CO m— »en — o o VO in ^ VO • • ^o ^^ • in CO — "=}• VO C7N -H • rn r^ c> VO • — * rn • * — • VO r- CO CN c o o o o • (/) in cr CI) () ia) u. o o o o O m • • VO O • en • c ro c c c ro CL > m c o XI 0) X D1 t- 'e CO < UJ cr < Q Ul CL o _l UJ > UJ a ro c o V3 +- >-•-. -2 cr v_^ ro •— 1 >- TD o _ (D O — — ro ... c "o a) ICD 4- ^ •o —o ro ro -(- i_ W 3 c o O — +- L. •— +- .c 10 cn .^ in c «^ cr o; cr o < UJ o < Q_ CO h 4-5 D- XI (0 <x3 d) Z3 U © u U Q) D — U >— o ^~ 73 3 CL 1CJ) < c: (D X) O E ro (D i- +CO < t- o H E 3 o (/) E O o XI m _J 'd- VO —— (Tv • 4- c ro 4- o X 4- JQ o; 4- •o XI :z U) ro O > < m q: o I c (D c O O ro oil c 3 o (D >- 3 in c O o 0) X 4- >XI >^ >- (D <D CO CN mCO > U 3 > l3 f o < z: 3 Z o u >- m Q liJ > > K 3 O UJ Z </) Q. O -J LU > UJ Q UJ O oc o = E « 5 O < "J < 5^ t > 5 = = O 5 z °- <" liJ CO 3 2 w > O 2 O £9? - a. 3 <I a ro < I LlI LjJ < 3 ^Q O < > Q. (/) o o u. o UJ o o o C/) 3 j— CO ' ^ CD g| X O3' LlJ b=" o CHAPTtfR FIVE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS; THEY HAVE NO MAGIC TO STIR MEN'S BLOOD REALIZED. AND PROBABLY THEMSELVES WILL NOT BE MAKE BIG PLANS; AIM WORK, REMEMBERING THAT A NOBLE, HIGH IN HOPE AND LOGICAL DIAGRAM ONCE RECORDED, WILL BE A LIVING THING, ASSERTING ITSELF WITH EVER GROWING INSISTENCY. LET YOUR WATCHV/ORD BE ORDER AND YOUR BEACON BEAUTY. Van^e,Z H. BufLnam 1910 CHAPTER FIVE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS INTRODUCTION The Comprehensive Planning Proposals phase of the Bloomsburg planning program involves the formulation of recommendations in respect to the three basic elements of community development: Land Use, Circulation and Community Facilities/Services. The following chapters document the planning process and resulting recommendations. However, in order to facilitate an understanding of the recormiendations, their presentation is preceeded by an explanation of prevailing philosophy, objectives and procedures which led to their formulation. PHILOSOPHY As early as 1945, the officials of the Town of Bloomsburg recognized the necessity of planning for the future development of the Town. Since the time the first Comprehensive Plan was published, there has been continuing effort to insure sound development guidelines in the light of ever changing factors that affect community development. The over-riding philosophy of community development has remained, for the most part, unchanged through the years. This position was stated in the introduction to the Comprehensive Plan Proposals of the 1965 report as follows: "The Comprehensive Development Plan for Bloomsburg Is intended to serve as a general guide for growth during the next fifteen to twenty years and to assist the Planning Commission and the Governing Body in reaching policy decisions and formulating local legislation on matters concerned with the proper development of the community. The proposals of the plan should be regarded as sufficiently flexible to allow for the unforeseen changes that always occur and to assure a maximum range of choices concerning the future course of the community's development. The plan itself does not represent the ultimate stage of development but rather a transition to something beyond, in the distant future. Its proposals should therefore be reviewed and revised periodically to meet the new needs that arise from the continuously changing physical, social and economic structure of the Community. On the other hand, the objectives and policies upon which the plan is based should be considered as more permanent, and representative of the general philosophy that underlies the thinking of the Planning Commission and its consultants towards the future growth of the community. Any revisions of the plan should therefore be made within the limits of this philosophy. 5-1 The proposals of the plan are based upon the primary objectives of preserving and protecting the good things that exist, and providing the facilities and improvements that are needed to make the Town a better place in which to live, work and play. The plan recognizes the limitations of existing conditions, but yet tries to better them by suggesting future improvements and refinements to increase their utility and attractiveness. At the same time, the plan recognizes that growth of varying kinds and intensities is inevitable and suggests that such growth, if properly guided, could produce a beneficial effect upon the community rather than a detrimental one." Even though the planning process has become increasingly more complicated since 1965, due in part to changing legislation, the effects of the 1972 flood and the advent of urban renewal programs within the Town, the basic approach of forward thinking, sound policies, and interagency co-ordination is very much in evidence. The planning proposals have been structured to accomplish the community development objectives as set forth in this report. Since the objectives provide the basis for proposals, familiarity with them is essential before proceeding to review the proposals contained herein. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES The following sets forth a list of community development objectives deemed essential, and in the best long term interests in the sound future growth and development of the Town of Bioomsburg. " The conservation of existing sound community development. " That land predominated by steep slopes and/or wooded growth be maintained in a natural state. " That new development should occur at locations which can economically be served by public utilities, community facilities and services. " That new development relates to existing physical features including topography and soil conditions with special consideration to storm water drainage and flood hazards. That housing development adequately meets the wide range of needs, preferences and income levels of the Town's present and future residents. " To provide the local population with a full range of goods and services through improvement of existing business establishments and development of a limited number of shopping facilities at appropriate locations. " To provide areas for new industrial activity and expansion areas for existing industrial uses in order to maintain and expand local employment opportunities as well as to broaden the tax base. 5-2 ° To develop a street and highway system that will provide efficient traffic circulation through and around the community, as well as to all parts of the community with a minimum of conflict and congestion. " That community utilities, including sanitary sewer system, water system and storm water drainage system, be expanded and improved to provide the necessary level of service throughout the Town in the most economical and expedient manner possible. " That a coordinated approach to community facility services be maintained and upgraded as necessary to meet the diversified needs of the community, particularly the medical, fire protection and police protection segments of a total public service package. " To institute a recreational program based on the needs of the Town, tailored to fit smoothly in an overall development scheme. ° To achieve a high level of cooperation and coordination on an intercommunity basis as well as with other community related and/or governmental organizations which are working for the benefit of the community. " To effectively administer development controls, for the long term interests and goals of the Town to achieve orderly, sound community growth. METHODOLOGY The following describes. In outline form, the major consideration and procedures utilized in the evolution of the Comprehensive Planning Proposals. While the process has been categorized for discussion purposes, all of the elements are highly interdependent and were taken into consideration as a whole during plan fomiulation. EXISTING LAND USE Community development, in most cases, is a process of adding on to that which exists. Furthermore, the character of existing development also influences and must be considered in respect to the form of adjacent new development. In effect, development that has already taken place is a rather rigid, pre-existing foundation upon which the structure of future development must build and obviously, with few exceptions, that nev/ buildTherefore, the manner in ing takes place on land presently undeveloped. which land is presently being utilized was plotted to establish the current pattern of urbanization and open space. EXISTING TRANSPOr^TAT ON I NET\'JORK The location and form of the existing transportation network, particularly the highway and rail segments, as well as anticipated changes thereto, were considered since development is so highly dependent upon access access to jobs, markets, products and services, raw material sources, homes, etc. 5-3 . COMMUNITY UTILITY SERVICES Sewer service, storm water drainage and water service are basic services which must be provided throughout the Town to support existing development and encourage new development. DRAINAGE The adequacy of natural drainageways and man-made water channels are of significant importance in terms of new development. Areas of surface water run-off (rain that doesn't soak into the ground) in volumes exceeding the capacity of either natural or manmade drainageways to carry the water away should be avoided. The converse of this situation is when water has no place to drain and forms a marshy area which is also undesirable for development. These situations may be remedied through several engineering techniques. Remedies for these situations should be implemented as soon as possible if they present obstacles to appropriate new development as well as better protection of existing development. SLOPES Areas predominated by slopes of 20^ (rising or falling twenty feet in one hundred feet of horizontal distance) or greater were identified for conservation. Ideally such areas should remain undeveloped. However, to attempt to prohibit all development in such would be impractical and unreasonable. Some limitations are, nevertheless, necessary. To permit developers to indiscriminately cut roads into such areas, dig basements and strip the land would result in development consistently plagued by surface water run-off problems, erosion, streets difficult to maneuver on and next to impossible to plow in the winter. Slopes in. the 155^ to 20$ range can be developed lightly if carefully planned and executed. Generally, slopes greater than 20^ should be maintained in a natural state FLOOD CONTROL The subject of flood control has plagued communities, including Bloomsburg for many years but confusion in approach and legal ramifications have come "home to roost" as a result of the 1972 flood which inundated a significant portion of Bloomsburg. An excerpt from the 1955 Comprehensive Plan regarding flood control measures will illustrate this point. "Establish the policy through subdivision and zoning regulations that all future development take place at base elevations that are safely above the high levels recorded in previous floods." The Federal Insurance Administration, within the Department of Housing and Urban Development, has issued guidelines and requirements for effective flood plain management, presented in a legal framework to enable communities like Bloomsburg to implement a flood control policy based on ground elevations which must be above the elevation of the 100 year flood. 5-4 DEVELOPMENT TRENDS Development trends including living preferences, partly indicated by the analysis of existing land use and recent construction activity, were explored to identify those areas which are or are expected to be, under pressure for development. Not to take into consideration market demand would risk the production of an unworkable plan or a plan too broad to provide sufficient guidance to achieve orderly and sound community development. The presence of zoning regulations, which have been in effect for several years, exerts an influence as the legal guidelines for development. This in itself creates certain development patterns which must be given serious consideration in respect to random or unnecessary zoning changes which may be contemplated. REDEVELOPMENT ACT I V I TY The full legal and administrative impact of flood related problems has taken on the identity of Urban Renewal as a tool to repair flood damaged communities. Full cooperation, not only in philosophy and goals, but in an integrated approach to implementation measures will be in the best long term interests of Bloomsburg. PROSPECTS FOR FUTURE GROWTH Judgements were made as to how much development the Town could logically expect to realize in respect to physical capabilities and pressure for development. Such judgements are obviously hypothetical and of a broad rather than definitive nature. Particularly those dealing with quantity and time. Regardless of what may seem to be pure "guesswork", decisions are more of an "educated projection" based on all the information available at a particular point in time. This inherent flexibility is a basic strength in the planning process in terms of everchanging variables which may render previous decisions inappropriate in view of new information. With the exception of the Turkey Hill Area, space for development in Bloomsburg is severely limited in terms of sizable vacant land areas suitable for development. However, such areas may become available through some unforeIn seen disaster, urban renewal or wholesale acquisition by a developer. the event of such a situation, there may be interest in what is termed a "Planned Ressidential Development". A "P.R.D." is a residential development consisting of a number and variety of dwelling units designed and executed as a single entity, providing common open space and sometimes including a limited amount of non-residential use - primarily to serve the residents thereof. This alternate development concept is applicable in all cluding commercial and industrial planned developments. land use areas in- ADJOINING AREAS The character of land areas abutting the Town, Scott, Hemlock and Montour Townships in particular, as well as development trends and planning therein, were considered to assure inter-regional community development continuity and compatabi ty. I i 5-5 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION Last on the list but certainly not least important is a form of social action termed "citizen participation". All too often decisions are made without proper input by those people directly affected by a particular decision. Citizen participation in all levels of governmental decision making is a very viable and desirable form of data input. The individuality of each person and the collective desires of groups of citizens is a basic premise to the existing form of government in this Country. limitations, opportunities and suppositions, together with the community development objectives, were brought to bear collectively to formulate the Comprehensive Planning Proposals presented herein. All of the foregoing concerns, considerations, LAND USE TERMINOLOGY The description of municipal comprehensive planning proposals include references to various categories of land use. In order to clarify the intent of the proposals, a description of the basic characteristics of each term is provided below. RURAL This term refers to the area which is not recommended or expected to experience development to any extent. SUBURBAN RESIDENTIAL This classification is geared to those areas with minimum existing development which, through proper design and regulation, could develop into a light to medium density residential area. As previously mentioned, design is a key factor to development, i.e., recognition of the necessity that any development must be tailored to the physical capabilities of the land to support development. URBAN RESIDENTIAL This use category is reflected primarily in those Town areas already substantially developed and areas immediately adjacent to existing development that would be the logical expansion area for this type of residential use. Urban residential may contain single family homes, apartments, low income housing and elderly housing, in varying densities. The density would depend on proximity to the College or the Downtown Business Area which traditionally contains a high ratio of the number of people per acre of land. COMMERCIAL As with the urban residential classification, the term commercial is an all inclusive denotation for different types of commercial uses which serve different functions and purposes throughout the Town. These purposes include downtown and neighborhood commercial uses as well as highway oriented commercial uses of land. 5-6 INDUSTRIAL Present development has already utilized most of the good industrial sites A wide spectrum of industrial type uses, including throughout the Town. textile mills, manufacturing, processing concerns and storage facilities characterize the industrial pattern in the Town of Bloomsburg. MAJOR PUBLIC AREAS These uses are community facilities basically oriented to municipal administrative and service centers, fire companies, educational facilities, medical care center, post office and library. Public and semi-public uses incidental to the development plan (such as churches and fraternal orders) were not included in the delineation of public land use areas. CONSERVATION Areas designated as conservation consist of those areas predominated by slopes of 20f; or greater, natural drainageways (see "stream preservation"), wetlands and a substantial portion of what is defined as flood prone areas. These areas must be maintained primarily in a natural state to minimize erosion, to retard surface water run-off, to maintain groundwater levels in lower areas and to sustain wooded areas to maintain the oxygen cycle. A limited amount of seasonal, permanent residential and outdoor recreational development is appropriate to these areas, except where slopes are severe and provided the natural drainageways are not encroached (See "Recreation"). upon. FLOOD PLAIN Included as an integral part of the "conservation" classification are the areas subject to flooding with major emphasis on the impact of the June 1972 flood in respect to development limitations. STREAM PRESERVATION This is a delineation of existing natural drainageways as they flow through development areas to emphasize potential problem areas in terms of development encroachment. RECREATION Land in this category includes existing and recommended outdoor recreational areas. (These areas have been included in the "Conservation" use category in the accompanying tabulations.) RIGHT-OF-WAY Includes the estimated land area occupied by or set aside for rights-ofway of streets, roads, highways and railroads as well as that required to serve the additional development delineated on the accompanying "Comprehensive Plan Proposals Map". 5-7 CIRCULATION Refers to pattern of vehicular movements through the Town in relation to See section entitled "Major Thoroughfares function and level of service. Plan" for a detailed description of the classification system employed in Bloomsburg. OVERVIEW - COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS A very unique feature of the Town of Bloomsburg, beside the fact that Bloomsburg is the only chartered "Town" in the Commonwealth of PennsylNatural features comvania, is the potential for a complete community. bined with development trends, both past and future, create a situation which offers a full range of development opportunities. Some examples of this diversity are as follows: " A vital " High density student dwelling facilities and suburban type single fami ly homes. " 40' " Three room apartments and late col onia -Victorian mansions. downtown business district and neighborhood grocery stores. X 180' lots in the older sections of Town and farms with substantial acreage on the outskirts of Town. I " Rolling plateau farm land and flat river terrace land. " Nationally recognized textile industry and home occupations. " range of facilities available to area residents. Some of which elementary (lower), middle and upper public schools and a college, a choice of churches and fraternal organizations available to fill the various religious and social needs of the community, recreational facilities including passive activities and indoor games, facilities for numerous outdoor sports, a Town Park, river frontage for fishing and boating activities and natural wooded areas for aesthetic appreciation are present throughout the Town. " A fu are: I I A composite of easy access to the interstate highway system (Interstate Route 80), a municipal airport, mainline railroad connections as well as an intra-city bus line connection increase the ease of access both in and out of Bloomsburg for a majority of transportation modes. This accessibility, and commercial turn, increases desirability for future industrial investments - new jobs and a healthy economy. in As bright as the situation is, it would be remiss not to also recognize the deficiencies and problems which face the Town. Insufficient standard housing, congested streets and intersections and periodic flooding are several examples. The purpose of this report is the identification of some logical guidelines, which, together with implementation measures, would offset development malpractices of the past and work toward acceptable future development patterns. 5-8 A summary of past and proposed changes in the Town's land use pattern indicates the changes in philosophy and goals of the Town in response to changing Proposed land comparisons for 1948, 1965 and 1974 are situations and needs. found in Table 5-1. (Some land uses have been grouped to facilitate comparisons) TABLE 5-1 LAND USE COMPARISONS BY % OF TOTAL AREA Residential CoTime re a i 1 Industrial Publ ic & Semi -Pub Right-of-Way Agriculture 1948 1965 1974 9.0 3.0 14.0 20.1 3.2 13.9 1.6 1 ic* 21.6 7,8 57.0 4.0 3.6 24.6 8.8 45.0 46.5 13.1 3.2 *lncludes conservation and recreation. The most significant change is the decrease in the area allocated to agriculture. This is due to several reasons. Much of the land that was classified agriculture in 1948 and 1964 is included in the conservation category which is part of the public and semi-public use indicated for 1974. Areas of low density residential were also included in the agriculture category in 1948 and 1965, whereas this type of use is shown as residential in the 1974 figures. Increased industrial use adjacent to railroad rights-of-way and industrial use proposed in vicinity of the airport account for the substantial inflation of the 1974 industrial figure. The grouping of certain land uses plus a different methodology of classification account for the differences in land use figures. It is important to keep in mind the land use terminology set forth previously in this Chapter Following is a detailed to evaluate the 1974 plan in proper perspective. breakdown of land use relationships as they apply to the 1974 Comprehensive Plan Proposals. 5-9 TABLE 5-2 AREA CALCULATIONS 1974 LAND USE PLAN TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG ACRES USE % OF TOTAL 93.9 3..2 Suburban Residential Urban Residential Commercial Industrial Major Publ ic Right-of-Way Conservation 184.6 6..2 414.9 94.7 412.0 367.2 391.2 1,017.8 13,,9 34,.2 TOTAL 2,976.3 100.0 Rural 3.,2 13,.9 12,.3 13.,1 The following three chapters deal specifically with land use, major thoroughfares and community facilities in detail sufficient to formulate specific proposals for overall community development. The following discussions and proposals are illustrated on the map entitled "Comprehensive Plan Proposals" for the Town of Bloomsburg. A map entitled "Generalized Land Use Plan - Bloomsburg Area" is also included. Legal and political jurisdiction of the Town of Bloomsburg are limited to its own municipal boundaries. However, in order to illustrate the continuity and compatabi ty of land use proposals in Bloomsburg with surrounding Townships and to assure inter-regional community development an extended regional concept was deemed appropriate. This in no way precludes the option of adjoining municipalities to undertake local level planning activities and design a concept suitable to their individual needs. Adoption of this plan by Bloomsburg in no way assumes concurrence of proposals as they relate to adjacent areas. Rather, this regional concept is a suggestion, by Bloomsburg, of what rray be conducive to an overall development pattern as Bloomsburg exerts its influence on the region and vice-versa. This scherre is presented in the spirit of neighbors working together for mutual benefit. I i 5-10 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS TOWN OF BLOOMSBUI COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA LAND USE CIRCULATION RURAL INTERSTATE SUBURBAN RESIDENTIAL PRIMARY 8' CIR] i URBAN RESIDENTIAL SECONDARY/LC COMMERCIAL ONE o INDUSTRIAL CONSERVATION fi^^i^M MAJOR ACCESS FACILITIES i TOWN ir COURT O PROPOSED Jk. SEWAGE HALL HOUSE MAINTENANCE TREATMENT PROPOSED . AREAS HIKING 8 PLANT BICYCLE RECREATION ttr SENIOR u^ MIDDLE i ELEMENTARY -f LIBRARY 9 U.S. • FIRE * HOSPITAL HIGH POST COUNTY SCHOOL SCHOOL SCHOOL OFFICE COMPANY JAIL BLDG. TRAIL TR ^ EW-MODIFIED MUNICIPAL PUBLIC COMMUNITY WAY R IMPR! COMPREHENSIVE PLAN PROPOSALS TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA LAND I I USE CIRCULATION RURAL INTERSTATE SUBURBAN URBAN ^^^^M RESIDENTIAL ONE INDUSTRIAL NEW- MODIFIED CONSERVATION MUNICIPAL MAJOR AREAS PUBLIC TOWN COURT O PROPOSED JK SEWAGE HALL HOUSE MAINTENANCE PLANT HIKING BICYCLE a RECREATION SENIOR HIGH MIDDLE ELEMENTARY f LIBRARY U S. POST SCHOOL OFFICE COMPANY HOSPITAL COUNTY SCHOOL SCHOOL i FIRE BLDG TREATMENT PROPOSED JAIL WAY ACCESS FACILITIES 4 « 80 (Shortwoy) CIRCULATION SECONDARY /LOCAL RESIDENTIAL it EfiT PRIMARY COMMERCIAL COMMUNITY . M^g-cr'"" TRAIL CIRCULATION TRAFFIC INTERSECTION PARKING IMPROVEMENT I RESIDENTI/I f^^^^^y^ GENERALIZED LAND BLOOMSBURG AREA MAJOR PUB USE PL COLU ] RURAL I RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL V//A INDUSTRIAL MAJOR PUBLIC AREAS GENERALIZED LAND BLOOMSBURG AREA USE CONSERVATION PLAN COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA ^mammmmmmttmmmimai^mmmm CHAPTER SIX LAND USE PLAN 1 CHAPTER SIX LAND USE PLAN INTRODUCTION The Land Use Plan, included as a part of the Comprehensive Plan Proposals, shows a generalized picture of the recomnaended development for the Town during the planning period (1974-1995). it is concerned with the most favorable development of land by public and private means and the establishment of a pattern of uses that reflects desirable goals for development. The Plan allocates a variety of land uses to those locations best suited for each particular use. Part of the Plan is established by existing development and is primarily concerned with the qualitative improvement of the environment; the other part is concerned with the most efficient use of undeveloped land and provisions for new uses and facilities. RESIDENTIAL LAND USE Pressure for future residential development is expected to require a sizeable portion of the Town's undeveloped land reserve. Residential areas, as shown on the Comprehensive Plan Proposals Map are in basic accord with the 1955 Plan v.'ith some modification. The delineation is influenced by existing patterns, availability of community services and facilities with maximum emphasis on open space area to be preserved. The highest residential densities have been contained in those areas where extensive development exists and conforms to accepted planning concepts, plus those areas that will logically provide for extension of this development pattern. One of the basic concepts of this Plan, as in 1965, is to encourage low density development on a considerable portion of the Town's remaining vacant land in order to prevent repetition of past tendencies toward overcrowding and to promote a greater amount of open space to be perpetuated. Residential development pressure will be a result of the increasing desire for a better day to day living environment coupled with the housing needs of a growing population. The single-family house will remain the major housing resource although multiple housing units will be in great demand for a large number of young married couples and those individuals that maintain separate households. in 1965, the major goals of residential development will be to gradually remove obsolete and substandard residential structures throughout the Town, meet the growing need for multiple unit housing around the college and downtown business district, restriction of small scattered lots through the lesser developed areas of the Town and to" promote proper development schemes that will use this type of land to a maximum degree of efficiency to minimize haphazard development. As 6-1 Basic to any residential use concept is the desirability to locate all residents in those areas that provide a desirable living environment as opposed to those areas in close proximity to industrial uses with the accompanying noise, dirt and congestion. Rural Approximately 94 acres of land have been allocated to this type of use in the northern portion of the Town through which Interstate 80 passes. This area Is proposed to maintain the existing undeveloped open nature of this section of Town. Development pressures in this area are at a minimum due to the presence of land more suitable for residential use in other portions of Town. Suburban Residential Areas north and south of Arbutus Park Road, including part of what Is referred to as Turkey Hill, are proposed for this type of \ofi to medium density residential use in the amount of 185 acres. Development in this area should not be random, small, scattered lots, but rather well designed subdl' visions suited to the topography and maintaining an open/spacious environment. Availability of public sewer and water will be of prime concern in terms of type and density of use in these areas. Urban Residential Of the 415 acres of land proposed for this type of residential use, only 103 acres at the present time are open or vacant in the form of small scattered parcels (See Existing Land Use Map). In other words, the potential development activity in this area is restricted to those areas or lots not presently developed, or to those which may become available through urban renewal or other clearance actions. A significant exception to this statement is the area north of the lower campus. The urban residential uses, as stated previously, will reflect a maximum use, without overcrowding and congestion of the platted areas of the Town. A wide range of residential uses from single-family homes to high density residential structures will be evident in this area. As is shown on the Comprehensive Plan Proposals Map, this use is contained primarily in the densely developed Old Town section of Bloomsburg. Location of multiple family, high density uses to fill the housing needs low Income families, elderly persons, single persons and college students should be based on "walking distance" to commercial and cultural facilities and other necessary community services. Development Intensity, in theory, is related to its distance from the retail core of a community. That is to say, the further away from downtown facilities, the less intensive the use should be. See following illustration: of 6-2 DEVELOPMENT INTENSITY Of course, this illustration is over simplified, but the basic premise is valid in terms of land use planning. COMMERCIAL LAND USE The total of 95 acres of commercial use illustrated in the area summary table is somewhat misleading. This is a total acreage figure for several types of commercial uses proposed at different locations throughout the Town. The following discussion breaks down the total into more appropriate designations, functions and locations. The Plan proposes to maintain and upgrade the existing downtown area as the Town's primary shopping center. The Plan continues to stress the need to increase the utility and attractiveness of the downtown by, (I) making better use of what is already there; (2) gradual improvement to existing retail and professional facilities; (3) elimination and/or relocation of incompatible uses; (4) provision of adequate parking areas; (5) ease of vehicular and pedestrian access with particular emphasis placed on the ultimate separation of vehicular and pedestrian circulation; and (6) encouragement of new business activities to locate within a ccmpact commercial area. These are the primary factors which will enhance and maintain Bloomsburg's position as a vital retail center in Columbia County. To discourage the spread of strip commercial use, provisions are made in the Town for a neighborhood commercial area adjacent to the Downtown to Strip commercial deprovide a transition into the residential section. velopment is inefficient and weakens the existing shopping center. Business thrives on concentration and competition rather than dispersion. Several other small retail convenience centers are proposed to serve the needs of the local neighborhood for such services as grocery stores, drug stores, barber shops, and similar facilities within easy walking distance of most residents. 6-3 The commercial area proposed along Route II will continue to provide areas for highway oriented facilities which require a large land area Facilities such as driveand are not compatible to a central location. in restaurants, motels, theaters, shopping centers, warehouses, distribution centers, automotive sales and services illustrate uses appropriate to thi s area. The opening of 1-80, the Keystone Shortway, increased Bloomsburg's accessibility to a large number of travelers. Although the Buckhorn Interchange Area to the west and Light Street Interchange area to the east have responded to demand for transient services, Bloomsburg must also respond and become attractive to the tourist trade. Accommodations such as lodging, restaurants and specialty shops should be established where practical and economically feasible. The adherence to sound land use policies and design standards will increase the attractiveness of a facilities thereby assuring the Town its share of the overall benefits from this significant form of economic input. I I INDUSTRIAL LAND USE The lack of vacant land tree from flooding, level and well drained, serviced by water and sewer facilities and adjoining major lines of transportation, both highway and railroad, has been a problem in Bloomsburg for many years and has subsequently limited new industrial development. Existing development, for the most part, has utilized the majority of suitable sites within the Town, forcing recent industrial growth to occur in surrounding areas. area, presently vacant, proposed for industrial use is adjacent to the Magee holdings and the Bloomsburg Fair Grounds. This would be an area of prime interest for industrial development. Access and put flooding problems would have to be overcome to this area into productive use. A substantial Industrial areas indicated along the Erie, Lackawanna Railroad as it passes through Town in an east-west direction, are substantially develThe oped with little potential other than expansion of existing concerns. only exception to this pattern is a tract located on the eastern border of Use of Town bounded by Maple Street, East Ninth Street, and Kinney Run. this land would necessitate removal of existing residential and commercial structures, the majority of which are substandard, in order to provide a site of sufficient acreage to be reasonably attractive to potential developers. Periodic flooding is a restrictive factor in this as well as most This is not to say development is entirely prohibited, sites in the Town. but rather, certain design precautions must be instituted to either raise the ground elevation, or incorporate flood proofing measures or both. Between Old Berwick Road and the Airport, in the southeast quadrant of Town, is a site which would lend itself well to industrial development. Although, through As stated previously, flooding is a major drawback. proper design, the threat of flood damage could be overcome. 6-4 A significantly potential Industrial site (not to be overlooked in long-term planning) is the area comprising the holdings of the Fairground Association. If, for some unforeseen reason, the fairground activity would be terminated, this 124,1 acre tract of land offers the basic physical features which are most desirable for industrial use, i.e., flat, reasonably well drained, sewer and water service, sufficient size and accessibility. In most other cases, considerable improvement will be required to create usable industrial sites, such as extensive acquisition and clearance, substantial regrading as well as construction of access streets and utilities. Strict controls are needed to encourage attractive development and prevent continued overcrowding, mixed land uses, obsolete structures and general clutter that characterizes much of the Town's past development. Coordinated development and cooperation between Bloomsburg and Scott Township will be required to assure the best use of land, not only industrial but all types of development, and provide maximum gains to both communities. CONSERVATION The largest single land use classification in the Town Is the area included in the conservation category. Approximately 1,018 acres, or 34.2^ of the total land area of the Town is recommended for conservation. The function of this delineation is to highlight those areas that should be approached Steep slopes, wooded areas, with caution in considering any new development. marshy lowlands, flood plains, and natural drainageways are included as situations or conditions not conducive to development, and thus should be maintained in a natural state. Bloomsburg is bounded on the south by the North Branch of the Susquehanna River and on the west and north by Fishing Creek. Land areas adjacent to these Inland waters constitute a large portion of the area earmarked for Steep conservation, based on their subjectivity to periodic flooding. slopes on the transitional hillside from the lower portion of Town to the northern plateau area referred to as Turkey Hill are also designated for preservation. These areas retard surface water runoff, create a natural buffer between the more intensely developed section of Town and the residential reserve on the hill and offer potential sites for minimum, informal recreational development. Steep hillsides, north of Arbutus Park Road, which drop off to a lower valley area through which Fishing Creek On the east border of Town and 1-80 pass, are indicated for conservation. adjacent to the lower campus and East Fifth Street is a naturally wooded ravine which should be maintained, for the most part, in its existing condition. An ecological or nature study area would be an appropriate function of this area. We cannot continue to pursue a course of sprawling urbanization and random development predicated upon the premise that every piece of ground is "fair gams" for development - limited only by man's ingenuity and fiOn the other nancial resources for transforming it into a building site. hand, the planning process must recognize that it cannot preempt an individual 's right to a reasonable economic return for his land, "reasonable" being of others being to that extent which does not jeopardize the we present and future. Without due consideration and provision for permanent open space, development cannot survive. I 6-5 I MAJOR PUBLIC AREAS Areas shown in this classification in conjunction with community facilities and utilities are specifically addressed In the chapter entitled "Community Facilities and Utilities Plan." SUMMARY The Existing Land Use Chapter of this report Indicates 50.8^ of the total The projected development ratio is apTown area Is presently developed. proximately 62.6^ of the total. The major purpose of this report Is twofold. One, to guide potential development of the difference between these two figures (12.8^ or 381 acres) as collective pressures come to bear on the Town to provide for future needs; and two, establish policies to gradually ease problems arising from premature judgements of the past in those areas presently developed in an equitable manner. The following illustrations entitled "Development Economics" and "Development Alternatives" are presented for consideration in terms of general development guidelines on which to base future decisions. They are Intended to be "rule of thumb" reference when the economics of development are weighed in the final analysis of desirable goals and objectives of overall community development. 6-6 DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS SINGLE FAMILY S 1200.oo COVERAGE 16 V. TAX YIELD DENSITY 10U/AC MUNICIPAL COST VALUE UO.ODO.oo SUKPUIS lOSO.oo J 150.GO lOWKHOUSE COVERAGE IBVo TAX YIELD DENSITY 30U/AC MUNICIPAL COST VALUE m $75,000.00 * 2250.CO SURPLaS 1650.00 600.00 « GARDEH APARTMENT COVERAGE 16 DENSITY VALUE 6DU/AC Vo TAX YIELD 532(.0.K! MUNICIPAL COST JlOB.000.oo 1700.DO SURPLUS JlSiO.Do TTrmm INDUSTRIAL COVERAGE VALUE 157. U0,000.oo TAX YIELD J 1200.00 MUNICIPAL COST SURPLUS ^liY I 60.00 JlUO.oo Ll source: landscape architecture- JAN. 1974 DEVELOPMENT ALTERNATIVES %d SURFACE WATER m BOGS FOnEST GRASSLANDS OR SINGLE FAMILY SUBDIVISION OPEN SPACE COMMUNITY WETLANDS Ctt''J>ARISON A. UIID STATISTICS 1. 167.9 AC. Total Site Area 3. Surface Vater J5.ll AC. 3. Ket Lanes 10,5 AC. US. 9 AC. 1. U5.-bui>jiable Lakd 5. Builqable B. W.a Uns 122.0 AC. USES S.F.O, 1 AC. 2. 1/2 AC. LOTS 3. TotWKOUSES t. c "t. Garden Apartments 5. Totals PROJECT SaTORItS 1. S2 106 total 152 GROSS DE«S[TY m IMPERVIOUS COVER 27100 ffV.'ii'S LAAES OPEN SPACE LAND 1 SiHG'.E Family SusoivisioN 2, O.S.C. 106 LOTS 1. 106 0.63 lu/ac 15.71 35.1 AC 7.3 AC 25.5: 2n 1.61 du/ac 15.91 35.11 AC 62.1 AC 58.11 Open Space C0»J'.JN1TY STATISTICAL COMPARISONS source: landscape architecture- jan. 1974 CHAPTER SEVEN CIRCULATION PLAN CHAPTER SEVEN CIRCULATION PLAN INTRODUCTION The primary thing that a highway does is change the relative location of places v/ithin the region it passes through. The changes in relative location then affects the urban centers and the activities associated with them. The following chart will illustrate the interrelationships of transportation and activities:* Route Patterns f« of Highways Geographic Arrangement of Production and Consumption Activities ^ Use Patterns of Highways Consumption and Production Activities As a result of the changes in the relative location, some sites open up to investment opportunities while others become economically obsolete. One of the purposes of Interstate 80 is to bring Bloomsburg closer to other urban centers. Being more accessible to other regions, the Bloomsburg Area will become more economically viable. HIGHWAY COSTS In order to get more accessibility through a new highway, a community might have to pay some of the price. Some of these costs are: Some will be hurt only temporarily during highway construction. Other businesses might be impaired permanently due to changes in relative location. 1. A new highway could hurt some businesses. 2. A new highway could take valuable 3. The existence of a highway could cause some traffic congestion and/or environmental deterioration. land out of production. Spatial Organiza*Abler, Ronald; Adams, John S; and Gould, Peter. Inc.) tion (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey; Prentice-Hall, 1971, pg. 293. 7-1 4. Highway construction could disrupt neighborhood relationships. 5. A new highway could cause greater local government costs due to increased demand for police and fire protection, sewer and water services, and other utilities and services. 6. Local 7. A new highway could have negative communications and traffic might be disrupted by a new highway. inputs on relative accessibility of some sites. HIGHWAY BENEFITS At the same time, a new highway could have tremendous beneficial effects upon the region. Some possible benefits are: 1. The term economic large economic growth. growth includes the introduction of new business and industry, the expansion of existing economic establishments, and new employment ishments. A new highway could cause I 2. Providing the area's population with increased accessibility to other regions, thus increasing economic and social opportunities, and competitive marketing. 3. A new highway could reduce travel time between key nodes and markets. Sound planning by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and the Community should be directed at minimizing costs and maximizing benefits. WHAT THE COMMUNITY SHOULD DO Building a highway does not necessarily guarantee economic and social growth. To ascertain the impact of highways, two basic questions must be answered. 1. 2. What effect has the Highway Program had on the Region to date? Is it doing what it was designed to do? If the answers to these questions are negative from the Community's viewUnless point, perhaps it is because the Community is not doing its job. be to a community does the necessary things, all the highway will do wi serve as a by-pass around the community. The community should: I I 1. Provide for community facilities, utilities, and other public services in advance of demand. 2. Ensure the aesthetics of the area. 7-2 : 3. Implement land use controls, especially at interchanges, to ensure proper development while at the same time protecting open space and prohibiting development in those areas that are unsuited for development; i.e., slope areas, flood plains, etc. 4. Create an Industrial Development Agency with authority to acquire large tracts of land and develop tracts as industrial parks. 5. Participate in mu ti -community planning and development program. I There are three basic measures of the potential impact of a highway on a reg on i 1. The reduction in travel time from the region to regional and national trade centers. 2. The increase of national and regional trade centers that can be reached within 2.5, 4, and 6.5 hours of travel time. 3. The increase in the index of potential economic interaction with regional centers. REGIONAL HIGHWAYS Bloomsburg is strategically located with regard to an excellent highway system which places the Town within a day's Journey or overnight trip to major ciiies in the east and midwest. Bloomsburg is located along the Pa. Rt. 42; Pa. Rt. 487; U. S. Rt. II; and Interstate following routes: 80. Pennsylvania Rt. 42, a north-south highway, interchanges with U. S. Rt. II at the west end of Town and continues south across the Susquehanna River at Catawissa en route to Central Pa. Rt. 487, also a north-south higha. way, passes through Town via Lightstreet Road, East Street (running concurrently with U. S. II), Poplar Street, and Ferry Road across the Susquehanna River and into Catawissa. U. S. Rt. II, a major north-south highway extending from Canada to Mexico, runs through Town via the Danville Road, interstate Main Street, East Street, Sixth Street and the Berwick Highway. 80, or the Keystone Shortway as it is referred to in Pennsylvania, is an east-west cross country thoroughfare. Access to 1-80 from Bloomsburg is via Pa. 487 (Lightstreet Road) to the east and via Pa. 42 to Buckhorn and the west. Relationships of highways in the Bloomsburg Area are illustrated on the map entitled "Bloomsburg Area Regional Access." I i PLAN OVERVIEW The Circulation Plan, proposes a program of street improvements of both physical and regulatory nature, to provide easy and continuous lines of travel for present and anticipated traffic through and around the Town. Most of these improvements can be carried out within the framework of the present street pattern by correcting existing alignment defects, extending 7-3 and/or improving existing streets, implementing traffic flow regulatory It is recommended that measures and a limited amount of new construction. these improvements be implemented as soon as ecomomically possible rather than waiting for the existing corridor to fall even further short of demands. One of the Town's major traffic problems is created by the lack of a well defined street system or corridor to channelize the traffic to a few streets designated for this specific purpose. The present "gridiron" pattern encourages, more than discourages traffic to use nearly every street for travel through the different sections of the community. Streets must be designated to carry certain types and volumes of traffic and must be designed and constructed to desirable minimum standards for this specific purpose. Major and secondary streets must be the primary movers of traffic through the Town; and accordingly will require the effective use of traffic lights, stop signs and other regulatory measures to control and minimize conflicting traffic and reduce innumerable potential hazards. At the same time, local streets will be spared the heavy traffic load and will function basically as a means of connecting individual land parcels with the highway network. HIGHWAY AND STREET CLASSIFICATION As Illustrated on the "Comprehensive Plan Proposals" Map, the highways and streets are classified according to the type and volume of traffic that is expected to be carried and the capability of each street to move traffic around and through the Town. In terstate - Limited access highways that move large volumes of high speed Interstate 80, of course, traffic betv/een communities, regions and states. Passing through the northern section of illustrates this type of highway. Town, access is provided to the east by an interchange with Pa. 847 (Lightstreet Road) and to the west at Buckhorn by an interchange with Pa. 42. The opening of the Keystone Shortway has reduced the volume of "through At the same time it has traffic" which previously burdened Town streets. opened up new territory for development in terms of highway oriented commercial uses. Primary Circulation - Refers to those streets that carry a major portion of traffic through Bloomsburg, provide major access to the downtown and nearby communities. Secondary Circulat ion - Streets of this classification distribute traffic throughout various sections of Town and serve as feeders for primary roads. Local Circulation - The remainder of streets which provide access to abut- ting properties. The following proposals are recommended to improve the overall circulation pattern in Bloomsburg: " Widen Railroad Street from Sixth Street to Fishing Creek to include the vacated Railroad right-of-way. 7-4 Improve Railroad Street, In conjunction with widening program, to support heavy industrial traffic. Particularly the section from Sixth Street to Ith Street and then west on Nth Street for approximately 800 feet. I o Correct alignment defects on River Road. This would eliminate several hazardous curves and facilitate development of a recreation area at the covered bridge site. Re-alignment of the intersection with Main Street, directly across from the old Pa. 42 bridge is also recommended. " Establish one-way traffic: east on Sixth Street from Railroad Street to East Street. west on Fifth Street from East Street to Railroad Street. " Encourage the use of Fifth Street and its extension through Scott Township to be the primary controlled access to the Lightstreet Interchange. Topographic conditions have restricted development along this route, thus minimizing congestion and maximizing ease of access. A "widen and improve" program would make this road ideal for the purpose. "^ As Arbutus Park Road assumes an increasing ly more important role in the circulation plan, (access to the upper campus and development potential), re-alignment of two hazardous "switch-back" curves will be necessary. '' Construct the extension of East Tenth Street from Ferry Road to Old Bereick Road at the intersection of Park Street to provide for local access to U. S. Rt. II and the Lightstreet interchange via Fifth Street extended, without going through the already over-burdened intersection of East and Sixth Streets. " Provide a one-way circulation loop which would include Main Street, from the Town Hall up to Penn Street, Penn Street to Lightstreet Road and one way on Lightstreet Road back to the Town Hall. This would eliminate several conflicting traffic movements at the intersection of Main Street, East Street, and Lightstreet Road. Two-way traffic would be maintained on Lightstreet Road from the Penn Street intersection to the 1-80 interchange. " Intersection improvements are needed to improve sight distances, reduce congestion and expedite the flow of traffic through channelization and/or signal controls at the following intersections: River Road and Main Street Railroad Street and Main Street East Street, Lightstreet Road and Main Street Penn Street and Main Street Penn Street and Lightstreet Road Fifth Street and East Street Sixth Street and East Street Fifth Street and Railroad Street East Tenth Street and Ferry Road East Tenth Street and Old Berwick Road Arbutus Park Road and Millville Road 7-5 Replace Ferry Road River Bridge Maintain Lightstreet Road as a resi dential ly oriented corridor by prohibiting strip commercial development. A recommendation to this effect should be forwarded to the Scott Township Planning Commission, the Township Officials, and PennDOT. o Municipal Parking - A study of parking supply and demand to make recommendations for more efficient use of existing surface parking facilities and provisions for additional facilities in appropriate areas as identified by the supply and demand study. SUMMARY Although Bloomsburg's accessibility is excellent from a regional point of view, there are transportation problems from a Town perspective. Large scale industrial and commercial uses in and near the Town generate a large volume of truck traffic. The College and the downtown area are also significant traffic generators not to mention the area residents which commute to and from work each day. Bloomsburg must recognize its position in light of a development/traffic ratio and strive to satisfy the demands and pressures for adequate, smooth flowing traffic patterns through institution of sound traffic management principles. 7-6 ~new Aioanye ^gaensbufg -r ^ ^TLiberty / .' —^ V Soaring ££a.n(lh^_^^^.\ S- 5f J49 ^' y^A L3 V.SIeatn Ville*',. '^ • '-V / ^ivv Lttgan Mouie^^^ TroLt Run 1 1 ^ "A 031] -.•."-.'--.A-.'' . =»*':'.*.--••. :• • :; . \ _ \^ )altqi^ i*""—"Vrrn ^sTiuikhannock "^ 2, , Gl^nburn^ , ^§321- wf / .„,l/Wallwil»' ^Factoryvi / E3lonville[3Q9 trfF^ikVpN^_^ . Ovetlon X .-^-^ -^ ' - ^^ 3%^"^f^-^-;;^ - . ?^ /: ^ ' '. Russell <* V "~^ "J ^/,3 >-^ JV ^Mildre d m// (y / MiUCity> I jvu g / ,^ , Bernice\Lopez^^^ X^J Scr^htor -arflnesA- ^f\ "^ r-^ %/ Powyij^ \ .^w. \ Slalion fiT Hepbuihville :* 93] West ^5R^ su e|juieeiieii T HazlS\o^-^\' ' M. ZI -, _ ^Oneida Kelayres Shepplon . ^ ' :S>rfi5°. 26^f|a,,S<' Ne sq u eh onjng^J-i^ \ \ r§24l [339l ^> Weatherly vLanS' Delano '-.^fSl'^'y^ , Lehigh Honifii -,^ ,- Summit , dale MiddleburgI / Hill Br, Bahom r..;,.. --/ "V X-'^" All Pi^aianl -^^ vlrevrort^ _ M —-^ . .^MounljinJ ^ .^J*-'^ ^ -^ Pilm.Tn »S^^^\J5'''^"TFountam 'v^^" ^Lavelle/ Spring! LAKE J Brpckton^"^/ ^ .:-5 ) > Pottsville//lW New ,la'.^ OH New TfiptlL Ringgold ,, »^.. r3i 'V. RouKh and Ready tlil^'^^^'Bj^JieK Llewellyn • Cressona\ k ^J/L--' Pillow^- viiic _^^^_Xf443r'-.Schuylkill '^-^^ iTremonl ^Haven Ravine >: l,ake ' Xbut ^"CliaM P^rt eerrysbufgl. l-'Reinerton- iT^Deer ' .' ...../:.-^ _. 13^: ^'*yE!izabethville rsburg yr^.--^''''''^ / V P • H I MEMORIAL ^ t RODGERS and "^ VlrginvilleX^ ^ J-^^Bethel %- -1=^ 1 — \f(V^'o«n ^ /f Cenlerport_^ 1 ^ I /"* Aetna J_/^ ^^ ^ V -ii^ fvtohrsvillel 2 Leesport Rebrersburg frtt. ' "«" 'yTTt^v. V £tmisstDwfi -.-r . \/ / ©(562} "^><i->-u^ ," Bernvilje, Host \ []83]Tu9kefttt fi LOOMSBURG AREA EGIONAL ACCESS iFTON , iSharliSvTlt^ ^ WP?'*'.^^'^ Station Rock Fredericks :4>>t/ ' ^ne Crove.g3K^89bh* SLykens ASSOCIATES Planning Con.uHantl GAME FOREST SCALE HARRISBURG = 9 LAND LAND MILES PENNSYLVANIA CHAPTER EIGHT COMMUNITY FACILITIES AND UTILITIES PLAN ^ CHAPTER EIGHT COMMUNITY FACILITIES AND UTILITIES PLAN I NTRODUCT ON I Community facilities are largely responsible for establishing living standards and developing an image that an area would project to those outside. Therefore, it becomes necessary to establish guidelines for community facilities that are designed to improve the socio-economic environment of a region. Some guidelines for the Town include: 1. Adequate public buildings to serve as the center for governmental, social, and cultural services to residents and non-residents of the Town. 2. Educational facilities designed to meet increasing needs with continuing emphasis on the Vo-Tech aspects of education. 3. Protection to the ecological and environmental resources of the Town in order to achieve improved water quality and an increased quantity to provide for safe potable domestic supplies, industrial use, fire protection and recreational outlets. 4. Adequate facilities for the protection of community health including hospitals and medical clinics. In order to achieve this, major programs must be designed to overcome deficiencies in sewage disposal and solid waste management as primary steps to providing clean water, ai r and land. 5. Identification of open space including areas for recreation, scenic views, and preservation of flora and fauna. The achievement of community facilities involves the cooperative study of the needs and wants of people. It also involves group decisions, by these same people, as to what constitutes programs and facilities necessary to meet their needs. It also becomes necessary to work out a collective execution of these plans in order that it can provide for the common good; and because it is not a one shot process, a constant evaluation of the A emergence of needs must be made and the program updated accordingly. is follows: as brief overall statement for community facilities Government Centers - There is an Increasing need for services at all levels and the increasing population acy of this need. Minimum needs v/ould include space ings, public meetings, planning commission meetings, cies and a center for public protection purposes. 8-1 expanded governmental emphasizes the immedifor government meetother municipal agen- Social Center - These are often provided as a part of government centers and private enterprise in cooperation with churches, schools, public and semi-public clubs and fraternal organizations and some aspects of educational and recreational programs. Cultural Centers - The socio-economic level of a community is oftentimes measures by cultural aspects Including libraries, historical centers, performance centers oriented to art, music and crafts, museums and centers for music appreciation, ballet and other theatrical expressions. Educational Centers - There is no issue more vital to the community today than the provision of adequate educational services. Children must be prepared during school years to cope with fast moving commercial and industrial programs. In order to assure Its citizens the best in education, the school district must constantly adapt to changing standards. School buildings must be attractive, well suited to the student and provide for a comprehensive modern curriculum; sites must be spacious and convenient to the students within the district. Uncontrollable forces, however, thwart the immediate satisfaction of educational aims. Some of these Include shifting population, obsolescence of structure, rising costs and ever- increasing requirements for curriculum. Perhaps education should cease to be a cost to society and become an Investment in people. In this manner, expansion of the educational plan would assume the same aspects as expansion of industry and expansion of commercial facilities. With these thoughts in mind, how does Bloomsburg stand, and what must be done to maintain an adequate level of service? The following narrative addresses more specific elements of community facilities as they exist today and what course of action may be necessary to correct any defiLocation of facilities is shown on the "Comprehensive Plan ciencies. Proposals" Map. MUNICIPAL BUILDINGS Proposals to replace the existing Town Hall are nothing new. The need for a building to adequately house municipal functions has been evident for many years.- The present Town Hail is obsolete, deficient In facilities and unfortunately located at a dangerous street intersection. Recommendations concerning the municipal building are contained in the space analysis report for municipal and community facilities prepared in 1972-73 for the Bloomsburg Town Planning Commission. To summarize, the recommendations are as follows: 1. Demolish the present Town Hall Building and use the site for improvement of the hazardous intersection and open space and parking facilities for the ambulance center. 2. Demolish the "5th pal and community Provided that the for the estimated service areas. Street" school building and construct a new municifacilities complex at the "5th Street" School Site. new structure is two-story, the site is adequate building area and required off-street parking and 8-2 3. Construct new Fire Company facilities on the open area at the sfte of the Municipal Street Maintenance complex at Catherine Street. Financial limitations and new responsibilities have slightly changed these basic recommendations. As an interim measure, the Town Hall is slated for Interior renovation and expansion to include space occupied by the Friendship Fire Company (Fire Co. relocation discussed later in this chapter). The style of architecture and historic value of the existing Town Hall has generated much support for preserving this building regardless of Its future function. Caution should be exercized in terms of the financial expenditure to remodel the existing Town Hall. Weigh carefully the short-range function and cost benefit in relation to long-term plan implementation. Improvement of the 5th Street School Site for general recreation purposes would be a positive step toward maximum utilization of an existing facility, SCHOOLS The public school system, as it relates to Bloomsburg, is administered by the Blooinsburg School District Authority. A long-range development plan, as formulated and adopted by the School District, is the authoritative document which guides future development objectives in the realm of public schools. The Town Planning Commission and School District officials should maintain a close liaison to insure compatabi Ity of plans and objectives. I It is not within the scope of this report to make an analysis of the educational system but rather to re-emphasize the responsibility of each individual not only through taxation, to provide all children with a good education to enable them to function in the ever-changing and increasingly complex society into which they will enter. POLICE PROTECTION The Police Department consists of nine full-time police officers and two full-time meter enforcement officers. Department rank consists of one Chief of Police, one Assistant Chief of Police, tv/o Sergeants and one Corporal. There are four patrolmen in the Department. No specialized units exist such as criminal investigation, or youth aid. There are also no civilian personnel employed in the police depari"ment at the date of this report. The police office is located at the rear of the municipal Throughout most of the offices and is open normally eight hours a day. twenty-four hour day, dispatching of patrol cars and phone service is handled by a private company which also provides radio and answering services to the fire companies, ambulance association and area businesses. The police department utilizes three municipally owned, radio equipped patrol vehicles, and one "back-up" vehicle which is not radio equipped. The scheduling of the number of on-duty police officers for a 24-hour period is as fol lows: 8-3 8:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m. 4:00 p.m. - 12:00 a.m. 12:00 a.m. - 8:00 a.m. 8:00 p.m. - 4:00 a.m. - Three Three Three One (Overlapping Shift) In 1973 a survey of the Bloomsburg Police Department was completed by the Municipal Consulting Services Division, Bureau of Local Government Services, Department of Community Affairs. A total of 19 recommendations were presented as a result of this survey. These recommendations deal primarily with the need for increased manpower, increasing of administrative efficiency, policy establishment for duty assignments, training requirements, (This promotions and salaries. A new police building was recommended. proposal concurs with aforementioned space analysis to provide adequate police facilities in conjunction with new municipal building.) As a result of this survey, excluding internal procedure implementation, two patrolmen are to be hired plus two full-time civilian clerks to keep the station open 24 hours a day. In accord with standards for evaluation of police ness, the Bloomsburg Police Department provides a vice to the Town. The Police Department is to be gressive approach to self-evaluation and improved the Community. protection and effectivesufficient level of sercommended for its proand up-graded service to FIRE PROTECTION Fire protection in Bloomsburg is provided by four volunteer fire companies. Rescue Hose and Ladder Company, Liberty Fire Company, Friendship Fire Co. No. I, and Winona Fire Company (See Comprehensive Plan Proposals Map for location.) Volunteer response averages 100 - 150 persons and 200-235 persons for major fires to man the following equipment: Ford Bean Pumper - 750 G.P.M. (Winona) Hahn - 1,000 G.P.M. (Rescue) Ford Bean - Booster (Friendship) G.M.C. Bean Pumper - 750 G.P.M. (Liberty) Ford Ladder (Liberty) G.M.C. Bean Pumper - 750 G.P.M. (Winona) American LaFrance - 500 G.P.M. (Rescue) American LaFrance - 750 G.P.M. (Friendship) 1941 Buffalo - 500 G.P.M. (Rescue) 1939 Ford - 350 G.P.M. (Friendship) 1934 Buffalo - 500 G.P.M. (Winona) International Trailer - Tanker (Town) 1974 1970 1969 1966 1964 1956 1952 1949 Available equipment must be kept in good operating order and replaced as necessary. The average life span of a fire fighting vehicle is 30 years. The proposed addition of a new fire truck in 1975 will enhance an already excellent equipment inventory currently available in Bloomsburg. Depending on the intensity of land use, the American Insurance Association recommends the following service radii for fire stations: 8-4 High Value Area (Downtown Commercial & Industry) 0.75 mile service radlf Low Value Area 1.50 mile service radii (Medium to High Density Residential) Sparsely Developed Rural Areas 3.00 mile service radii Note should be made that there are, in reality, two interrelated sets of standards to determine adequacy of fire protection: (I) related to distance as set forth; and (2) related to population. The number of pumper trucks for areas under 50,000 population is determined by this formula: .85 + .12 trucks per 1,000 population. Assuming 12,000 persons in Bloomsburg and immediate environs, there would be a minimum of 2.3 pumper trucks required, rounded to the next higher number requires three to meet the standard. A serious problem facing firemen in Bloomsburg is the presence of the Erie-Lackawanna Railroad which traverses the Town in an east-west direction. The railroad line itesif is not the problem, but rather, the potential for a long freight train going through Town could effectively isolate the southern third of Town from fire fighting vehicles by blocking the Street crossings. Solution of this problem is forthcoming when Friendship Fire Co., moves from the Town Hall location to its new location on East 7th Street, a block east of Market Street. (Note: This site is different than the recommendation contained in the space analysis report.) Generally speaking, the fire protection coverage for Bloomsburg, pending relocation mentioned above, is adequate. This assumes a continued adequate water supply to all fire hydrants. MUNICIPAL AIRPORT The Bloomsburg Airport, located In the southeast corner of Town on 58.0 acres of land, consists of a 2,800 foot paved runway and related hanger maintenance buildings. Consideration should be given to expansion of the runway to 3,400 feet for safety purposes and to accommodate larger aircraft. Relationships of flood plain and flight path development controls have in-, vestlgated In depth to determine the feasibility of this proposal. Generally, expansion on the eastern end of the runway would be the only alternaThere are potential benefits to be derived from the expansion in tive. terms of development controls of flood plain areas in Scott Township as well as a basis for increasing the area to be included in the Town Park between Catherine Street and Ferry Road. Presently, aircraft activity Is minimal and the future of the airport is subject to question. It is foreseeable that this function could be terminated due to varied economic pressures which may be exerted. Hopefully this will not be the case as an airport can be a vital asset to a community. However, possible re-use of this area must be addressed in the event that the airport function ceases. Flood plain regulations will be a major determining factor in any re-use decision which may be made. Possibilities to be considered might be industrial, municipal functions, recreation or a compatible combination of all three. 8-5 BLOOMSBURG FAIR GROUNDS Privately administered, this 124.1 acre tract houses the annual Bloomsburg Fair a local tradition that draws people from all over the State. Continuation of this event is encouraged as a significant input for the economy of the Town. Hov;ever, if this function should, for some unforeseen reason, terminate its existance, this land would become of primary interest for industrial development (See Chapter Six). BLOOMSBURG PUBLIC LIBRARY Supported by donations, both private and municipal, the public library serves a vital cultural need in a community. According to minimum standards established by the American Library Association, public libraries should contain at least two volumes per person of population served, 25 to 100 periodicals, one staff member for each 3,500 persons served and should be located so as to be accessible within 20 minutes by autcxnobi le. COUNTY COURT HOUS!: AND JAIL The Columbia County Court House and Jail are located in Bloomsburg. While they are not municipal facilities, they are community (County) facilities They generate a high level of personal and are most welcome in the Town. The Town and professional services, as well as increased retail trade. Planning Commission should offer its services to the County Commissioners in planning for space and municipal services to the County. Communication and cooperation between County and municipal governments and agencies is highly encouraged for mutual benefits to be derived, not only on a governmental basis, but for the benefit of all citizens. HEALTH CARE Bloomsburg Hospital, equipped with 150 patient beds and 30 nursery units, provides area residents with a wide-range of medical services which include: maternity, surgery, intensive care, out-patient, emergency, physiotherapy, and X-ray services. Presently, the hospital is operating at average capacity with plans to expand to provide laboratory and business office facilities. Expanded hospital facilities, augmented by local practitioners, presents an adequate level of health care facilities in the Bloomsburg Area. SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL The Columbia County Solid Waste Authority regulates the collection and disposal of refuse for the entire County, including Bloomsburg, through contract agreements with 10 private collectors. A sanitary landfill at the County Farm Site in Mt. Pleasant Township north of Town will provide area for proper disposal of wastes. 8-6 WATER SERVICE The estimated 1990 population in Bloomsburg will intensify the demand upon the existing water supply, storage and distribution system. The present consumption of over three million gallons per day is expected to increase as the result of population increases in the service area, the increased use of water per capita and the addition of new industrial uses that require water. Sufficient water must be available for the anticipated demand as well as for substantial storage reserve to meet fire demands, special industrial needs and general emergency conditions. New trunk lines, pumping stations and storage reservoirs will be required in order to guarantee an uninterrupted flow of water to the community. The future growth of the Bloomsburg Area is dependent upon an adequate supply of water for both domestic and industrial uses. Extensions of water service have been restricted to the level terrace In the southern section of the Town and in Scott Township. Low lying land and steep hills inhibit the extension of water service in the northern section of Bloomsburg and throughout most of Scott Township. The lack of a supporting population currently inhibits the extension of water service into those sections of the Town and Scott Township where new growth is anticipated. Close cooperation between the Bloomsburg Water Company* and the officials of Bloomsburg and Scott Township will be required in order to plan for the orderly extension of water service Into those sections where it is needed most. The extension of service to the upper campus site on Turkey Hill affords an excellent opportunity for servicing the Light Street Road Area and the northern section of the Town. Expanded service Into undeveloped New deareas should be considered as a means of encouraging new growth. velopment is not likely to occur in areas where water service is not availab le. SEWER SERVICE Although Bloomsburg 's sewer system appears to be adequate for Immediate needs, anticipated increases In population and Industrial development will undoubtedly require substantial improvements in existing facilities Extensions of existing lines to permit operation at maximum efficiency. will be required as well as replacements, new interceptor lines, expanded treatment capacity and completion of secondary treatment facilities (currently In progress). The extension of sewer lines Is restricted on the flood plain by low lying wet lands and on the hillsides by steep and irregular topography. Pumping facilities and collector lines will be needed to encourage new development. *Note: Negotiations presently underway for purchase of the Bloomsburg Water Company by the County. 8-7 Close cooperation between the Municipal Authority, Bloomsburg and Scott Tov/nship will be required to encourage the installation of new facilities, The future growth and the extension of existing lines into new sections. of both the Town and Scott Township is already restricted by the lack of adequate sewage collection and treatment facilities. Continued reliance upon individual disposal facilities will prove detrimental to the health and welfare of both communities. Both communities should explore the possibilities of cooperative effort to reduce the high costs of an Improved col lection and treatment system. Consideration should be given to the many different sources of financial assistance from the County, State and Federal Governments. DRAINAGE The provision of adequate storm drainage is an important factor in protecting the public health and property in a community. Inadequate drainage facilities permit the formation of mosquito breeding grounds in stagnant pools and extensive run-off on steep slopes. Flooding of streams which traverse developed areas not only causes property damage but creates health problems. Whenever possible, it is preferable to preserve natural open channels for drainage of storm water because of the great expense involved in constructing large underground storm sewers. Protection of existing streambeds and natural drainage areas should be encouraged through subdivision regulations and a comprehensive drainage ordinance. Underground storm sewer lines are required in the built-up sections of Town. The storm sewer improvement program in Town is limited and has done little to reduce or resolve the problems associated with storm water runoff. Snyder's Run, which flows above ground for a short distance north of Light Street Road and is carried through Town in a rapidly deteriorating brick arch storm water conduit, has continually created problems for business and residents along Its course in terms of basement flooding and associated property damage. The relocation and/or replacement of Snyders Run culvert as well as solutions for other storm water problems will be presented in a comprehensive storm water drainage plan to be prepared for the Town. 8-8 CHAPTER NINE RECREATION PLAN CHAPTER NINE RECREATION PLAN INTRODUCTION The trend toward increased leisure time, instead of being a much desired and needed break from the work-a-day world, has almost reached the proportion of becoming a serious social problem in terms of too much free time. Of course, this is not everyone's situation, but a growing segment of the general populace of all age groups is facing this problem. Should free time be expended at random with no real satisfaction, or should leisure time pursuits be guided in the form of recreation opportunities designed to enable individuals to find outlets for self-expression and thereby develop their inherent potential and achieve real satisfaction for their efforts? This question must be faced in terms of what recreation facilities are available today, what will be needed in the future, what are the goals and objectives of a recreation program, and where does the responsibility lie for providing such a program. It is not the purpose of this report to make a detailed analysis and present hard and fast answers to these questions, but rather to point to a potential problem and offer the opportunity to establish a base from which logical and meaningful decision can be initiated. At the same time, any decision on this subject must reflect consideration of a wide spectrum of input and variables inherent in such a process. To provide a better understanding of the various types of recreation facilities, the traditional types are discussed as follows: TOT- LOT This area is usually small, about 5,000 square feet or a little less in The service size, and is intended for use by pre-school age children. radius is 1/8 mile. It is usually provided where private yard space is Area not available, and is especially important in high density areas. features include simple, safe and attractive apparatus (for example: swings, slides, benches, open space for running, and paved walks or paths for wheeled toys) NEIGHBORHOOD PLAYGROUND The size This is the principal outdoor play area of the neighborhood. usually ranges from three to five acres; and the playground often comprises a part of an elementary school yard. Service radius is 1/4 mile. AlThe facility usually includes a play area for the pre-school child. so included is a play area for school-age children, the heaviest users. The area is a place where teenagers and adults can enjoy games and sports and where the entire neighborhood can gather for festivals, special events. 9-1 Typical facilities Include play apparatus, a games and other actlvitfes. multi-purpose grass area, courts for games, a shaded area for quiet activities, a v/ading pool, and shelter buildings v/ith sanitary facilities. In order to minimize the stereo-typing of playgrounds, the use of landscape plantings and Innovative play apparatus is desirable. PLAYFIELD The playfleld provides facilities for diversified recreational activity for teenagers and adults, although a section is commonly developed as a playground. A part is usually set aside for athletic or highly specialized sports with spectator emphasis. The size may range from 10 to 30 acres, and the facility is often located adjacent to secondary schools. The service radius is 1/2 to mile with a design criteria of one acre for each 800 population. Typical features include a children's playground and tot- lot, playfleld and older children and adults, tennis courts, lawn and court games, shelter, pool, picnic area, parking facilities, and landscaped areas for passive recreation. I COMMUNITY PARK This facility services the entire community and Is located within or near the urban limits to give the urban dweller an opportunity to get away from the rush or urbanization. These parks service all ages and are designed for yeai round use with particular emphasis on family use. The size ranges from 50 to 100 acres. Typical design features are not standard except to effectively utilize natural features; for example: woodland, meadows, streams and ponds. Road development should be kept to a minimum, but ample parking should be provided. Typical activities include picnicking, swimming, day camping, and walking for pleasure. If topography permits, playfields may be established. — SPECIALIZED RECREATION AREAS Golf courses, swimming pools, athletic fields, amphitheaters, tennis courts and community centers are often included in this category. OPEN SPACE Underdeveloped and typically unusable land (for example: ravines and hillOpen spaces sides) is used for conservation control and beautl fi cation. also may be small landscaped squares, triangles, or plazas providing breathing spaces in bui It-up urban areas. LARGE-SCALE PARKS OR REGIONAL PARKS These parks serve the residents of a relatively large region, usually those The size and location of these parks located within an hour travel time. vary, but recommended sizes range from 250 acres and upward depending on the types of activities provided and the area to be served. In many instances, such parks are left entirely in their natural state while others contain both natural areas and active recreational development. 9-2 Recognizing the fact that not all of these types of facilities are applicable to Bloomsburg, they must be kept in mind to evaluate the existing recreational facilities in terms of needs and potential development. INVENTORY AND RECOMMENDATIONS Facilities which fall into the classification of large-scale or regional parks should be addressed at this point in relation to their drawing power In the Bloomsburg Area. These facilities would logically include the fol lowing: Ricketts Glen State Park - Luzerne County Worlds End State Park - Sullivan County Raymond B. Winter State Park - Union County Snyder-Middleswarth State Park - Snyder County State Park facilities in the Columbia-Montour-Northumberland Counties Area are non-existent. Potential for development of this type of park facility within a reasonable travel distance from Bloomsburg (25-40 miles) should be investigated and encouraged. Memorial Park Memorial Park is one of the Town's finest assets as well as one of the best recreational facilities in the upper Susquehanna River Valley. The plan proposes that the park be further expanded to include the area In the block between Catharine Street and Ferry Road Including Kinney Run. The expanded land area would prevent any further encroachment of nonrecreational uses around the periphery and create a land reserve to accommodate development of a diversity of facilities. This expansion program is given credence in terms of flood plain development controls which would substantially restrict all but recreational type development. Waterfront Parks Bloomsburg's location along the Susquehanna River provides an excellent opportunity for the development of a riverfront park. The plan proposes that the entire river frontage be reserved for recreational use and that a variety of features be provided to take advantage of this invaluable community asset. The frontage consists of a relatively narrow undeveloped Elevations vary from 20 strip of land along the river and Fishing Creek. to 40 feet above the water surface. The strip Is subject to periodic flooding in the Spring and should, therefore, not be developed Intensively. The riverfront offers an excellent opportunity for the development of both active and passive recreational features. The strip along the Susquehanna River is too narrow for intensive development and should be generally left in its natural state except for the provision of walkways and bicycle trails. Investigation of the use of the river for row boats, canoes and sail boats should be undertaken, and if feasible development should be initiated at once. 9-3 The frontage along Fishing Creek in the vicinity of the covered bridge provides an excellent site for the development of a picnic and fishing facility. The proposed site is large enough for the development of a substantial facility for both local residents and persons residing outside the area. Aside from the recreational benefits to the Town, the riverfront park development would provide an exceptional attraction for the increasing number of tourists that visit the Bloomsburg Area. Park visitors would patronize local stores and services and thereby contribute to the general economy. An area of this type, well developed, could be a major plus factor for Bloomsburg in times of public assembly, eg. the Fair; College homecoming and alumni weekends, and for the everyday enjoyment of the Townfol k. Fishing Creek Nature Park The plan proposes that a section of the Fishing Creek flood plain be reserved for limited recreational use. The site is generally low lying, poorly drained, subject to flooding and not suitable for intensive development. It is presently undeveloped except for a stone quarry. The proposed park is to serve as a natural area, with emphasis on the development of a wild life refuge, bird sanctuary, nature walks, camp grounds and limited recreation facilities. Athletic Park The existing athletic park on 7th Street, currently utilized by the School District for football purposes, could be further developed as a year-round playground to serve the residential sections in the center of Town; pending, of course, successful resolution of a recommended program for cooperative use of the Bloomsburg State College athletic field for football games. The playground would provide recreational space and facilities for a large number of children that live within a convenient walking distance until During supplemented by other facilities in better geographic distribution. would continue assumed that the site to provide for spring and fall it is units. football practice for both of the educational Public School Playgrounds Playground facilities for the Junior High School on First Street are grossly Acquisition and development of adjacent properties is recominadequate. mended to provide much needed additional space and facilities. Memorial Elementary School Site is also recommended for expansion of playground fad ities. I The abandoned 5th Street School Site should be developed as an interim recreation site until the time it is utilized for municipal functions. Blocmsbura State Col leae Recreational facilities on the upper and lower campuses supplement the pubOf course, all local use of these facilities is lic facilities in Town. based on availability when not in use for college functions. 9-4 Increased cooperation between the college administration and local citizens highly encouraged to obtain maximum usage of these recreational opportunities. is Greenbelt Recreation As referenced in the land use chapter, areas designated for conservation offer potential sites for various forms of passive or informal recreation uses. Nature study areas, picnicking, wildlife refuge and hiking trails would be appropriate uses in this type of area. The abandoned railroad right-of-way starting at Railroad Street near the bridge across Fishing Creek and continuing around the outskirts of the development area in the northern sector of the Town, as shown on the Comprehensive Plan Proposals Map, is recommended for transformation into a hiking and bicycle trail. Play Space Playspace for small children of pre-school age is needed throughout the particularly in the more densely populated sections. In some cases, facilities can be provided at existing parks and playgrounds; in others, a single vacant parcel could readily be developed as a play lot. A small area of 2,500-5,000 square feet is generally adequate for the provision of a sand box, swings, slides, and open space for general tot play. It may be feasible and even desirable to encourage the cooperation of neighborhood groups and local service clubs to provide supervision and necessary improvements and maintenance. Because of size and the many other factors which determine location, these areas are not shown on the Tov/n, Plan. Neighborhood Playgrounds Neighborhood Playgrounds are primarily for children 5 to 15 years of age The ideal loand to a limited extent for informal play by young adults. cation is near the center of a neighborhood, preferably adjoining a school site reflecting joint use. Space is generally provided for athletics, court games, roller skating, a shelter house, wading pool and game play. The lack of vacant land in existing residential areas is the primary obstacle to the realization of a playground of adequate size within easy reach Existing facilities are, of every residential neighborhood in the Town. for the most part, inadequate for total recreation need and expansion because of site and financial limitations is highly questionable. The recreation plan recommends that existing facilities be used to the greatest advantage by increasing the variety of facilities offered and that every opportunity to expand the sites be implemented. It is also recommended that fully developed playground facilities be provided at all new schools. This is a practical method for implementation of playground objectives and should be fully explored. Additionally, every subdivision and land development plan must include recreation areas to the satisfaction of the Planning Commission and Town Council as a prerequisite to approvals. 9-5 SUMMARY A well-balanced community recreation program requires well-defined areas and facilities located in close proximity to the homes of the present and future populations that will use these facilities. The type of facility and the age group to be served are other important considerations. For example, facilities that are to be used primarily by children should be located as close as possible to the center of the residential neighborhood served. Recreation facilities normally should not be located along heavily travelled streets or a railroad; commercial and industrial areas are also negative influences. However, recreation can be and often is a part of commercial and industrial programs. To wit: industrial leagues for baseball, Softball, bowling, etc.; and tot- lot areas in shopping centers for child care while the parent is shopping. The Town's total area allocated to parks and playgrounds, exclusive of school properties, is approximately 45 acres. This is considerably less than the desirable standard of 10 acres of recreation space for every 1,000 persons as recommended by the National Recreation Association. This would require approximately 100 acres to serve the present population of about 10,600 persons, exclusive of the institutional populations. The estimated 1990 population would require from 100 to 120 acres on the same basis. Total acreage alone does not indicate the adequacy of a community's recreational area because it does not always afford a measure of the quality of service that is desirable. Shape, location, distribution and type are equally important. The objectives of the recreation plan are oriented toward the development of a system of publicly owned recreation sites that would provide a diversity of facilities easily accessible to the Town's present and future population and at the same time would enhance the general attractiveness of the community. This can be accomplished by improvements to, existing facilities wherever possible and the acquisition of new sites in locations where they will be needed. The proposals of any plan are essentially a compromise between the desirable and the practical. The desirable has The been expressed in general terms by standards of space and location. practical unit must necessarily be expressed in terms of the lack of undeveloped land where most needed and the limitations of public funds. The solution to the recreation problem of any community lies between the two extremes. Although compromises must be made, they must be recognized as such. The goal of providing adequate opportunities for all the age groups in the community should always be the guiding factor. 9-6 CHAPTER TEN PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM CHAPTER TEN PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM INTRODUCTION The purpose of the "Public Improvement Program" for the Town of Bloomsburg is to provide a summary of improvement projects and to demonstrate methods by which projects necessitating local level fiscal consideration can be scheduled in accordance with, annual budgeting procedures, fiscal capabilities and an overal design for community improvement. All of the proposed improvements identified in the Comprehensive Plan do not fall under local jurisdiction; however, those which do will require financial outlays in order to be implemented. In addition, many other projects will arise for consideration from time to time, through continuation of planning efforts, and they must, of necessity, be incorporated into the public improvement program. I In order to approach these projects from a realistic standpoint, it is important that they be programmed in terms of priority and financial capability. Such programming should be undertaken with an in-depth view of both the functional and financial aspects of proposed projects in order that financial limitations are not exceeded either through initial implementation costs or excessive operation costs at a later date. Efforts in this realm should include the preparation of cost estimates and, in some instances, feasibility studies to assure a sound basis for decision making processes relating to the undertaking of specific projects. It should be noted that the intent of this chapter is not to provide an exact dollar and cents program, but rather to set forth a general procedural framework and to illustrate the manner in which this framework should This be utilized in the programming and budgeting of improvement projects. will permit the evolvement of a flexible program which can be modified through time to incorporate changing aspirations and conditions. In this sense, it is important that the procedural framework identified herein be utilized to arrive at a definitive public improvement program. This program should be reviewed and updated on a periodic basis in order The that a current picture of programmed improvements will be available. updating as a most logical approach for such action would be to establish part of the annual budgeting procedure at the end of each year. DEFINITIONS To better understand the terms used hereinafter, the following definitions are presented: I. General Fund - Utilized for transactions involving the following types of revenues and expenditures: lO-l a. b. Revenue Receipts - All general revenues including taxes, departmental earnings and grants excepting those specified by lav/ or contracted for designated funds. Non-Revenue Receipts - These include receipts from such sources loans, refunds, the sale of investments, transfers from other funds, and other receipts which do not increase the net worth (assets minus liabilities) of the municipality. as temporary 2. c. Governmental Expenditures - Expenses incurred for such purposes as administration, the protection of persons and property, health and sanitation, and highways. d. Non-Governmental Expenditures - Funds to repay indebtedness, refunds, transfers to other funds, and similar expenditures which do not decrease the net worth of the municipality. Highway Aid Fund - Monies are distributed annually to Pennsylvania municipalities in the form of State Motor License Fund Grants. The grants are for the construction and maintenance of local roads, and the amount of such monies received by each municipality is determined by the number of miles of public roads which are maintained and the population of the municipality in relation to the other municipalities in the State. The State Motor License Fund Grants must be deposited in a special Highway Aid Fund, and specific guidelines must be adhered to by the municipalities in respect to the manner in which such monies are expended. Expenditures from the Fund must be made solely for the construction and maintenance of roads, bridges and associated drainage facilities; and a specified percentage of expenditures must be utilized for construction and improvement projects until the roads are classified as improved in accordance with standards set forth by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation. 3. Special Revenue Fund - Special Revenue Funds are used to account for revenues derived from special taxes or other specific revenue sources. The use of such Funds is mandatory when a municipality levies special taxes with which to provide revenues to finance specific functions within the municipality such as recreation, street lighting or solid waste disposal. The financing of the specific functions through the use of Special Revenue Funds provides several distinct advantages. When monies are deposited in a Fund designated for a specific function, a greater degree of coordination between the financial and the This, physical aspects of the function or activity is obtainable. in turn, facilitates the planning and budgeting procedures which should be carried out. Finally, the use of a Special Revenue Fund aids in assuring that sufficient financing will be available since the monies deposited therein may be used only for the purpose for which the Fund was created. 10-2 4. Capital Reserve Fund - A Capital Reserve Fund is used to accrue funds for anticipated capital expenditures for specific projects. The monies accumulated in the Fund should not be used for any purpose other than that for which the Fund was originally created. The advantages to be derived from the use of Capital Reserve Funds are numerous and similar to those discussed previously in relation to Special Revenue Funds. 5. Revenue Sharing Trust Fund Under the "State and Local Fiscal Assistance Act of 1972" (Public Law 92-512), eligible governments will receive revenue sharing payments over a five-year period. These payments will represent a permanent source of revenue for the Town during the five years, and consequently, should be taken into consideration for fiscal planning purposes. In order to administer revenue sharing payments, local governments are required to create a trust fund in which the payments must be deposited. The Tov/n will also be required to use the amounts in this trust fund within whatever reasonable time period is prescribed by the regulations of the U. S. Treasury Department. The revenue sharing payments must be used for "ordinary and necessary" expenses. In the area of maintenance and operating expenses, the payments may be used for any of the following purposes: (I) public safety including law enforcement, fire protection, and building code enforcement; (2) environmental protection - including sewage disposal, sanitation, and pollution abatement; (3) public transportation - including transit systems and streets; (4) health; (5) recreation; (6) social services for the poor and aged; (7) financial administration - including budgeting, auditing, and tax collecting; and (8) libraries. There are no limitations for use of the payments for capital expendiPayments may not be expended for maintenance and operating tures. expenses in the areas of general government, welfare or education; however, capital expenditures may be made for these purposes. In addition, municipalities may not use revenue sharing payments as They may, matching funds to obtain federal grant-in-aid assistance. however, be used as matching funds under State programs. 6. O£eration and Maintenance - These are funds expended annually to operate the municipality and to maintain physical improvements erected and/or purchased in prior years. 7. Capital Outlay - These are funds which are expended to add physical improvements and equipment to the inventory of the municipality. 8. Uti ity Funds - These are funds established to account for the financing of a specific utility such as sewer or water. I 10-3 SCHEDULING OF PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS The initial step to be taken in the preparation of the public improvement program involves an identification of projects to be undertaken, the estimation of project costs, the assignment of relative project priorities and the determination of responsibility for implementation. It is essential that a schedule reflecting these considerations be evolved before any financial or administrative programming takes place. PROJECT IDENTIFICATION The identification of project needs should not be an arbitrary process but rather should be derived as a result of an overall planning process for the community. V/hile specific deficiencies in the community are often easily identifiable, their relative importance to the total community may be distorted v/hen all of the applicable factors are not considered. Improvement projects affecting the Town will come under various levels and combinations of governmental jurisdiction. Some of the projects will be the sole responsibility of the local government, while others will require cooperative action with other municipalities. Still others will not come under local municipal jurisdiction but rather wi be the responsibility of County, State or Federal agencies. I I In instances when proposed improvements do not fall under local jurisdiction; for example, highway improvements by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation - it is not necessary that the projects be considered for Such projects the purposes of priority rating and financial budgeting. should be listed, however, to maintain an awareness of their need; and the applicable governmental agencies involved should be made aware of the lo- cal desires relevant to implementation. PROJECT COST ESTIMATES An estimate of the cost of each proposed project falling under the jurisdiction of the local municipality is an essential aspect of the preparation of a realistic Public Improvement Program. The importance of realistic cost estimates comes from their use as input for financial budgeting purposes. Consequently, they should be given careful consideration based on the best information available at the time of preparation. In some instances - for example, improvements to Town streets - applicable Other proposed improvements, cost data may be drawn from past experience. however, may be relatively undefined and will necessitate feasibility studies to determine the exact work to be undertaken and the cost involved. Such feasibility studies oftentimes represent relatively large costs in themselves, and they should, therefore, be scheduled accordingly as a part of the Public Improvement Program. In instances when a proposed project will necessitate cooperative action with other munici pal ities, it will be necessary to proportionately distribute the cost. This can be done according to population, assessed value 10-4 of real estate, or any method which is mutually agreeable to the municipalities involved. The distribution of the estimated cost should be determined as early as possible, however, in order that each municipality can schedule the project based on as realistic a cost factor as possible. PROJECT PRIORITIES The assignment of a priority for each project indicates its relative need or importance in relation to the others. It should be noted, however, that a priority rating does not preclude the possibility that one or more of the proposed projects with a relatively low priority may be implemented prior to those scheduled prior to it. Since the priorities are assigned based on considerations as they appear at a given point in time, they may be subject to change as conditions change or additional influencing factors are unvei led. Projects necessitating cooperative action on the part of other municipalities in the Area should be coordinated in terms of scheduling. This does not necessarily mean that a particular project will have the same priority It is important, however, that for each of the applicable municipalities. the actual timing for cooperative projects be coordinated in order that each municipality will be prepared financially at the time of implementation. IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES Town Council will be responsible for the implementation of many of the Improvement projects which come under municipal jurisdiction; however, in the case of projects involving more than one community, many options are available for the delegation of responsibilities to joint agencies. These potentials should be considered carefully In relation to the financial and administrative aspects of the various projects. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT BUDGET An Integral element of the Public Improvement Program is the Capital Improvement Budget which outlines the financing of the various projects for future years. The Budget usually relates primarily to the General Fund since this is the principal fiscal tool of local government; however, other funds may also be included - although considered separately - as may be app icab le. I order to prepare as realistic a Capital Improvement Budget as possible, the financial transactions of the Town during the past several years should Unless unusual circumstances have occurred, these be reviewed and analyzed. These transactions will, in most cases, reflect general trends over time. trends, coupled with as detailed a knowledge as possible of factors which may affect financing in the future, should serve as the basis for the estimating of future levels of financing. In The intent of this discussion Is to provide a general indication of the purpose and intended use of the General Fund and other funds which may be applicable to the Town, as well as to review the financial operations of the muni- 10-5 cipality during the past three years. A summary of such operations involving the General Fund in the years 1969 through 1973 is provided in Table lO-l. Table 10-2 provides information on the tax structure of the Town for the same period.* PREPARING THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT BUDGET The Capital Improvement Budget is an integral element of the public improvement program since it outlines the financial aspects of implementation. The budget may be prepared for any number of years; however, it is important to recognize that the first year or two considered will usually be the most accurate in terms of financial operations as they may be expected to actually occur. On the other hand, it is also important to consider subsequent years. While the accuracy of the estimates decreases as the number of years considered increases, the estimates can provide a general indication of future financial status. This is particularly important in relation to projects which will necessitate monetary accruals over time. The recommended time period for the capital improvement budget is five years. Improvement Program for the years 1974-1978, as well as the tax structure for the same period and relative discussion is provided. It should be noted that the budget relates only to the general fund; and although other funds may be applicable, they are only referenced in the discussion. A Capital MUNICIPAL FINANCES The implementation of a Comprehensive Plan is often highly dependent on the provision of the necessary funds. To better ascertain the source of and need for these funds, it is necessary to examine the overall financial position of the Town. By establishing and evaluating the financial foundation of the Town, the extent, type and timing of programs and facilities can be evolved. This financial analysis will center on general fund expenditures and receipts; the Town's borrowing capacity; how these figures have changed since 1970 and how they will likely change by 1978; the sources of the Town's revenues; and recommendations concerning improvement of the Town's financial structure. General Fund Expenditures Because of increasing costs and the rising demand for municipal services, general fund expenditures have risen since 1970 with the exception of 1972 That year (1972) was an exception because of Huras shown on Table 10- 1. *The Governing Body of each municipality is required to submit a copy of an Annual Budget to the Department of Community Affairs within fifteen days of adoption. The structure of Tables 0-1 and 10-2 reflects the general format of the forms which are provided for this purpose by the Department. 1 10-6 ricane Agnes and the need to recover from the flood damages. Total general fund expenditures were $638,531 in 1970; $703,244 in 1971; $1,354,455 in 1972; and $773,854 in 1973. These figures represent an approximate ten percent (10^) increase from 1970 to 1973. The 1974 budget calls for a large increase in expenditure to expand and improve (I) general government services, (2) police department services through the hiring of two more patrolmen, (3) fire protection through the purchase of a $35,000 fire truck, (4) the storm sewer system, and (5) the continued flood recovery program of the Town. With these increases, the 1974 budget amounts to $1,023,500. It is estimated that the ever increasing need for municipal services will continue to grow through 1978. Consequently, by 1978 the Town budget is expected to be about $1,182,000. Capital improvements will be covered later in this chapter. However, it should be pointed out now that a large portion, approximately twenty-three percent (23^), of the money spent from 1975 through 1978 will be directed towards capital improvements. Tax Structure Bloomsburg will raise $524,500 in taxes in 1974 as shown in Table 10-2. The distribution of tax receipts is as follows: (I) real estate - 38.5^, (2) per capita 1.9^, (4) earned income 4.9^, (3) real estate transfer 38.1^, (5) occupation privilege - 8.6'^, and (6) amusement - 8.0^. While this tax structure appears to be broadly based, there is a problem. The five dollar per capita tax is not a good one. It is difficult to collect, does not yield that much revenue in relation to the cost of collection, and is not based on a person's ability to pay. It is the Consultant's opinion that this tax be eliminated. To compensate for the loss by the elimination of the per capita tax, it is recommended that other taxes be increased. The Town of Bloomsburg, in 1974 had an assessed valuation of real estate of about $14 million. An increase of only two (2) mills would provide an addition of $28,000 to the tax receipts, enough to compensate for the elimination of the per capita tax. Legislature is under consideration which would permit an increase in the An increase to 1.3^ would more than replace the per \% earned income tax. capita tax. Consideration could also be given to property transfer and/or mercantile taxes as better alternates. 1973 tax receipts accounted for only half of Bloomsburg's income, as (I) county, state and shown in Table 10-3. The other sources were: federal grants 28.3^, (2) departmental earnings - 15.3^, (3) bonds - 5.9^, and (4) other miscel laneous sources - 1.5^. While departmental earnings and miscellaneous income can be counted on in the future, the level of inBonds should only come derived from grants cannot always be counted on. be used in the case of big capital improvement programs such as sewers, streets, etc. Since they will have to be paid back, bonds are also not a good annual source of income. In 10-7 Borrowing Capacity The borrowing capacity of a community is based on the arithmetic average of applicable revenue receipts for three full fiscal years preceding the date of incurring such debt. The Town may incur a debt not to exceed 250^ of the average revenue receipts including any outstanding debts. For example, a community which has an average revenue receipt of $500,000 per year and an outstanding debt of $100,000 could still borrow $1,150,000 without a public referendum. However, there is no borrowing limit providing any proposal is voted favorably by the electorate in a public referendum. Table 10-4 illustrates Bloomsburg's borrowing capacity based on a non-referendum situation. General Fund Income Table 10-5 shows the incomes and balances of Bloomsburg's general fund from 1970 through 1973, the 1974 projected budget, and estimates from 1975 through 1978. From 1970 to 1973 the Town's income (receipts and balance) grew by $152,328 or 22.5^. Correspondingly, the Town's total expenditures grew by $135,323 or 21.2^. In the future Bloomsburg will have to increase its income to keep pace with the growing demand for new services, new facilities, and the maintenance of existing facilities. In response to these large needs, sound budgeting will be required. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM The long-range Capital Improvement Program and the short-range Capital Budget are extremely useful tools in carrying out the proposals of the Comprehensive Planning Program. They provide the means for maintaining a steady pace of much needed improvements and at the same time for introducing efficiencies and economies that are to be gained from the proper scheduling of capital improvements. The sooner a community turns its back on making public Improvements on an unplanned, sporadic, hlt-or-miss basis and begins to plan its public works and budgets properly, the better off it wi be. I f Capital outlays were very irregular during the recent past ranging from almost nothing in 1972 to about $73,000 In 1970. Admittedly, 1972 was an unusual year due to Hurricane Agnes, since most of the Town's financial efforts had to be directed towards flood recovery rather than new enterprises. This flood recovery process went on through 1973, is still occurring in 1974; and is likely to keep on for several more years. Future capital improvements may be financed by: (I) continued reliance on current revenues, (2) borrowing, or (3) a combination of both methods. Either method can be utilized without placing a heavy burden on the tax payers. Additional revenue can be raised for capital expenditures by (I) Increasing real estate rates, (2) increasing the ratio of assessed valuation to market value, and (3) utilizing Act 511, "The Local Tax Enabling Act," as amended, more extensively. 10-8 Borrowing can be carried out satisfactorily without straining the community's financial resources. The Town, as already explained, has a total borrowing capacity of $1.42 million in 1974. This source is adequate for the proposals of the Capital Improvement Program and should be coordinated with pay-as-you-go proposals. Proposals for Capital Improvements The list of capital improvements has been derived from the proposals of the Comprehensive Planning Program. The list is made of two parts; a short-term and a long-range improvements schedule. Short-Te.rm Proposals (For Completion by 1. 1978) Stomi Sewers. As most of the citizens of Bloomsburg already know, one of the most pressing of the Town's immediate problems is the inadequacy of the existing storm sewer system. A Storm Sewer Feasibility Study is currently being prepared to determine needs and associated costs. Recommendations will be forthcoming after the completion of this report. It can be stated, however, that the Town's share of the cost of immediate storm sewer system improvements would be at least $500,000. This directly refers to the urgent need for improvement to Snyders Run. This figure is predicated on the assumptions that grants-in-aid will be forthcoming to help finance the project and the availability of a half-million dollar loan through the Farmer's Home Association of the Department of Housing and Urban Development of the Federal Government will be conf rmed. i 2. .Streets and Highways. In order to carry out the recommendations of the Comprehensive Plan, many street improvements will be necessary. In terms of priorities they are: a. The three (3) intersections surrounding the Town Hall - Lightstreet Road and Penn Street, East Second Street and Lightstreet Al of these street Road, and East Second and Penn Streets. intersections will require widening, resurfacing, new traffic While the exact needs controls, and possibly other improvements. and costs should be determined by a traffic study, a preliminary cost of $13,000 to $15,000 could be the Town's share of this project. I b. Railroad Street and its intersections with West Second and West Fifth Streets. Railroad Street should be improved and widened It should so as to lighten the traffic load on Second Street. be widened from Second Street down to the industrial areas so as to increase the accessibility to truck traffic. The two (2) intersections should be changed to facilitate the proposed one-way traffic circulation. Again, the exact requirements and associated costs should be determined by detailed engineering studies. A preliminary cost to this project would be around $50,000. 10-9 3. c. Intersection of Millville Road and Arbutus development that is beginning in this area tersection should be improved to allow the fic in the area. A preliminary cost would d. Intersections of East Sixth and East Fifth Streets with East To facilitate the proposed one-way circulation pattern, Street. approximately $10,000 will have to be spent at these IntersecTraffic signal Improvement currently slated to facilitions. tate existing traffic patterns will be readily adaptable to the proposed circulation pattern. e. Expansion of municipal parking facilities in appropriate areas Financial allocations for this should be an ongoing process. purpose could vary from $1,000 to $10,000 depending on existing site conditions and design criteria. Park Road. With the of the Town, this Insafe movement of trafbe $4,000. Town Hall. As an Imrrediate expediency, the existing Town Hall Is to be renovated. This project could require from $30,000 to $150,000. For this budget $30,000 will be reflected. Long-Term Proposals 1. Reconstruction and re-alignment of sections of River Road. 2. Extension of East Tenth Street to Old Berwick Road. 3. Reconstruction of existing East Tenth Street. 4. Reconstruction of 5. A severe "S" shaped segment of Arbutus Park Road should be realigned to facilitate anticipated increased use. 6. Demolition of the Fifth Street School for recreational development. 7. Expansion of the municipal airport. 8. Acquisition of potential recreation areas with a high priority to approximately thirty (30) acres next to the municipal airport bounded by Catherine Street and Ferry Road. 9. Continued expansion and improvement of the public sewer system to meet growing demand. 10. a section of West Eleventh Street. (Industrial Access) Expansion and improvements to the storm water system as deemed necessary as a result of the Comprehensive Storm Sewer Study. 10-10 o o o o oo O in 04 in in 00 in CM in M *f> v» in rK1 Kl CO CM 5 CO CN CN V) «« tft v» v> « w 'S- •^ CO CM o^ in CM in CM "J- CM CO W *<» «« *» in in Ov CM r~ C3^ b^ b<> b<> in in in in K1 c^ CM CO — v^ — in in in r^ in — r~ CN CM vo CM — CM w t^ b^ «/) in to CM CO CM in in in CM CM CO CM (3^ w bS v> b^ *<» tA v^ in in CT\ in CM — t^ *^ f^ N-l Vi bO in CM be — — be CO in ^n b^ 4rt — CM — b^ in Kl be be be be be be be in be be CO in in CM be CM be in -^ CN CM be be ro to CO in to CM in 0^ ejN 00 CM r~ CO as be be be be be be be be be in in in ro ro tr\ to CN CM in CM be be C\ in be in CM be be — — in CN ro H t f^ n ^ en CJ\ CM K\ •<3- a- 00 CO in ID CM to CO rn CN be be be be "J- "a- •^ Os to 00 0) r^ CO 0 m — CO rn in CM CM be be be be be be UD ^ K\ a- — T CM %r in — N-l u-v -J be — Z CO Lu rO D— — XO LU CO r^ CM CO CJv be be be I in in C!\ I LU -J CD Q r~ zO < ID O U- — H I lO CM r>- r- CD K\ CO in '^ c^ en be be be be be be (N CM — CO r^ CM lu — lO CJ> — a\ to to to to CM 'a- be be r^ so 1^ \o r^ in i~- be ^ en Ki rCM CM be be K-l to 5f in T ^ — CO to 10 be be be be be be be be to a\ 10 in as T-^ in "a- in in r- CO CO 00 c^ -0 CO c^ be be be be be as en — — —~ _ — as in ON in be •a- in CO 10 as >! as be be be be be — VD to to c^ 10 CO CO to in CO to be be — to be ^ — as ^ •a- '^r CM in — be be be CJN as to in in CN be to — — so be be be be be o o o o o o o o o as — t^ CO m to be be •^ "3- T ^ r^ CM CM to 10 CM as to be be be — to rID as CM oo so in in 00 in o as as be 2 —c Z Ct LU > <s> (D > -J <<3 3 HI < 0: <D CL LU 0. HI CD ra c: (D ro ^ c C) ro -(L- z. c ID S — t- c C) — (0 +- H ( ) LU 1- y- (D ^ ID ID +- D ^ 4- ro nj -H « CO i (D CL CL tD ^- H- - C —H 1- C < \E y < a U1 Q c c >H) 'S +- C 0) c ID C ••- 1lU >- a> (1) (- be *rt j^ T \_J <. LU I 1- (D I) r ID S 10 3 c co +- ID -(ID I 0) Q. CL ID -H H V T ^ -r c: in c +- J, J, c r >- # ID •a +- 4- c^ 1- -1- ID c: 1- c >- c ni (!) +- ID CO VD as as CO ID CN c ID C be •a 3 r ID V ID -1(D 1 ID 0. CL ID +\- X rr ^ ni _i 10-11 >- 10 S ID HT f> X in ID l_ -H .« n t- n ID ID CJ I) —c ID 1- «a +- +- <H +- >- 1- h- < n c 3 4- 10 ID (- 1 ce — ID +CL ID H 2 < —I t- > P- "a c5 LU 1 C _J O-Z 1- ID UJ III u LU to =D c (C -^ ir LU < > R —C ^ ¥- — Ol 2- Q- 1- E ( _J LU l0) ID +- I- 1 1 i; 1r 1 ^ ^ o > _3 o a. O" o n +- 0) I. o s o c c O +c > E 8 o 1- 1 in a> o O o oc 1. +(D <D a Q. J£ o 1. O 3 E O) t_ X- u c o t- 1 o — 1. O) »*- •*- a> £ o o o ok 3 I- E £ ?^ m £ +- *« I H- 1- cu L. H 01 ^4- o in 0) 1- TJ o o o* in ro\ £ (1) ID «> o3 •o 4- c in — 1 03 ID e ID > 8 OE in o u c +• D) ID o3 ^ C z O 0) 1- c »-' ;5H 1— § c o (0 £ O "> o 4- ID L_ ID 4- o C o £ in *^ ID C c ID E ID U c c o o M4- O D) XI XI ID 3 C o •(- o o u (0 1- 3 > u ID m <s> c >~ ID t. » ID in 1- — "q. o O II D) L. Q. > ID 1- 0) £ u c *~ ID ID 1- ID ID in ID ID ID L O ~c "Z. m C Q) en 0) L. ID E cn u +- ID l_ ID ^ Ot- O IN 0) <D 0) >-UJ c ir in o — Q. ID 0) E LU cr u 4- X O o o o" o in Q) fao o 0) c: ID Q- L. o in 1ID ID CD ID N M- X) o 4- U £ Li_ ID > o c in c ID L 4- _J SL 4- l_ ID 1- < UJ t- 3 E < O in ID L. ID 1- O 1ID O 4- L 3 cr g Q. ID 1_ ID in ID 1_ 3 1ID a) 3 O o o — c XI O) lO ID *^ •4_ u ID U in S ID ID x; f- £1 Vin c o lO r^ cn K1 r^ ON r~- XI c cn 1 c o c CSI X© 1co ID 1- l_ 0) cn 1ID «y«» ID C > O ^ o\ c c 4- 4- o o in X L E c ID ID o o 0) ID in X V) in ID i_ (D o 4- E H- 4- 0) CL. 0) ID O C in x: 4- C C 3 — x: ID 3 X 1- 4- Q. c ID Q- c 3 •+- X? — ID XJ 4- ID C tSI r^ Ov t— 4- 3 3 — >* ID 3 Dl L 3 ID in ID XI ID X) c —— SL 4— 5^ (D D) cn 1ID o 4- in x> E 8 c L o in >- 4- x: 4- 3 3 0) ID 1- ID O) -Q in l_ ^ XJ UJ >- X ID XJ S — Q. ID ID 4- O o in 1_ 1- u a> O- 4- ID 4- c o c x: XI ID M~ 0) ID ID SI O \- Htr\ 4- >4- 4- 1- C ID L D o o c x: 4- in 4- a) >~IM ID 0) 0) ID s x: cn X3 in 0) O lID ID in in 3 4in ID o ID in 4- II O —o ID — E >~ +- l- lO LJ (- ID in in o ^ +oc u u — CL l_ E O- m ID ID 1ID o c ro c X •— 0) in ID ID U 3 CL ID C o L ID c 4- xr H- o in 4- c in 1- -H ID in ID o in II cn p l_ c a. o ID 11 ID in ID O 4- o »*- j: 1- X) in ID 4- O- +- u u ID p '4- o N-1 0) X) E ID l_ fee -C +_ 0) ID o te O O O E o C 1- 1- > c; x; 1- in 1- o o ^ ^ "J f-s 4- D c a. U HO •*- IB oO O in in oo o o CN in 1^ o CM 1 XJ 0) ID o J= £r Q) 1- O- ID 1. u ID ID •D +^ o 4- (- C 1- c O. 3 J- in in in m o u 3 Q UJ 1- £ o (D in ID ID -i in (D O D UJ U o. o c o T5 1 Q (D •- —s c <-> in ro o O +- > c O ID 1 in C 4O c C 0) «i cn u 1_ ID — 0) > o cn X X 41O o O <s> 'I- Cft 10-12 00 o oooo o (N O O O O o. o. o.o• ^T O — *^ CN OO fO m o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o est *»«» o —o oo o o o in in o CN O**/> o o o r^ — o o o — o o o o in o o o o in V* (N o o o» VO m V* v» o o o o\ o to o o o o o o o o o o o o o m o o o o o o o o o o o o» o o o• o o in CTi r~ */» o o o CN ^ (N */ in oo o —o in in o r^ o « r^^ o o« O CN CO O in in — po r^ \o •K r-- ON r-> CN *rt •Kb^ CM b«> oo —o oo o o in in o oK o * « « O —^ fO O T CN o o o r~ in r0^ «£> in (N ««» ww (SI o —o oo o oo o o« o o o ^ « K in o o (N ro — in o o o oo oo o vD o in in in CO (sj in (N <« CM (SI o bt v> o o o ro r^ o oo lO O VO m o ^ </» (SI fe^ CSI ^o —o o oo VO ^ o mm— oo iO CM in crv fc^ •.*»9 ^ o ^ in in CO CM in CM t/» CM in o\ — o o o o Vi Vi r^ — «A *i^ m in — f^ CM p^ — VD — 00 c> tA — CO p^ CO K1 (3% in IE —O in — CM r O CM o CO CJv — -w o in '^ r^ CM CO W « m to CM CM •a- a^ t^ cr> b^ b^ — CO VO ^ vt o in ^ be 00 in to o o o (Jv CM CM (N 00 o CM ro <^ in M^ w— CJ^ •<r (N o in o o o o CM rsi (j\ in in in a\ ^ ^ 00 o r^ m —o CO o— in r^ CO CT» CM CM v=» CO CD csi O r- M- I--- CM CM >. in b^ vj- CM CO 0^ VO CM ^ «» (SI « K1 m —o in o o o o o CM *0 «rt CM 10 H (D in X a: <u 10 O +- j3 H LjJ + ID X -1- ID — 3 E> ^ ID ID LU h- a) X) < 1- •(- 0) ID crt cr U) in LU -J < LJ 01 X ID 1- X C o 0) 1/1 in ^ > m d) _i J3 in ID UJ s- +- O O © »c — o o g c ID =3 H +ID L a) < O (!) Z -1 J3 o O U Q_ Ct cc UJ CL ID -*- 0) H- M- -H <D (S> +- r© — ID < 1- a: rj << ID H c O. O LU cn _l z 2 1- ID O LU 1- <U L — 0) < h- Q- t/1 3 O X E Q O ID 3 C fc XI +0) H Z < 32 1X1 L. > LU Q •^ LU LU _J < LU cn of < LU ce Q. 2 O H < CL Z3 CJ o o 10-13 < ID < O TABLE 10-3 BLOOMSBURG - 1973 INCOME SOURCES ALL FUNDS $ TAXES Percent 496,223 49.0 26,661 2.6 154,853 15.3 86,814 8.6 172,460 17.1 BONDS 60,000 5.9 MISCELLANEOUS 15,227 1.5 $1,012,238 100.0 $ COUNTY GRANTS DEPARTMENTAL EARNINGS PENNSYLVANIA GRANTS FEDERAL GRANTS (Revenue Sharing) TOTAL 10-14 00 0^ o o in t^ K\ CO CM o r- a\ r~ r^ in CM CTi '3- «< ro 00 O o o o •k •V to 00 o •^ +- CM in in CM <D O o o vO CO in CM CM in CO ay 00 00 o o o o in 00 VO VD CD tn >;J- O o CM CM r0^ >— O K> tn r-~ VO ON ^ c^ rCO O O O vO ON in 00 ON VO rON ON •>* tn CO o CM 00 in ON o CM 00 o o o •i to C^ vO in 00 in 00 o CM o CM tn VO CM tn E c: u © > O in CO <o JQ CM CJN to r^ o in CJN 00 CJN ^— a\ in — •V r^ in VD •^ ro Ov CJ\ in CO ON in CTv CM CM CO r- o VD CO VO ON o\ ^ in VO VO aVO VD •k in CM VO CJN in — «* to o o o o o in CO VVO % •k tn o I m — CD < s: O o _I CD CD UJ Q T3 © U) c ro o CD cc o uj ON •fc o o o o> C3N ON ON ON o o o in in CJN r-- VO en ro CTv ON CM rin 00 ON ON in r~ in ^ ON in "^ cr> tn CO CM ..c— ^ — CO VO in •^ 1 fO in CM in 00 a. 1 1 1 i tn -» CO «w CO CM in CvJ •v •k CM 5 in © + ^— ro a. 'o * tn CO to 00 CM ^ •k •^ CM tn VO o CM tn o CM in tn in •« «a"d- o VD in tn i^ o o o tn i^ Cs| c 3 E L O s- tn •» •w in c O +^ ID «n ffi +(0 +V) «. •^ 3 o o c 3 > 0) u LU 4^ >- tn 3 o > u o CL Q. (S M- ro Q) o q: »+- o .. — in 0) c; 4- (D ^3 > ro XI 0) l/l in 0) c O rj :z < V u o +u ro Q) >+- s— C7) c •— +• E _J b«. in o c: (D o C •^ C tin ro 4- e o Q) 3 UJ O -t- CH 'i <u Q) CC 3 L c ro 0) (D > >- Li &^ o Q) d: 10-15 © z < in M- O ro < CD +- en u © > L ro u © © >> O) oi © ro u O »4in © O C 3 O L. L o in j: H- 'ffi o© M- D) V) +Q- Q) CD 10 tn v-* 4- ID 1_ 4- Q. ro (S l/l vt ^-^ tn ^--v — o •— in *i •^ +- •teC. O in CM c CJ) •o c: ro 4in 4- 3 o C c •— •— ro E © d; O c O 4ro 3 O — ro _ "• 4- <u o © 4jd JZ 1- Q * © ) o o o O O o o CD o o o o o o o o o CO CM o o o ok c^ o VO o o o* o (N O O O o o o «> ll^ vr> Ov CVJ CN o o o in o o o o o o o tn « ^ in o •o CT> p^ in (SI o o o o o o o o •T in in r-j f 1 c-> in vn CM o o t in IT) r^ o 1 c I- in 10 ^ H < <J in <D •k O in o t> c £ *+- u o o o m in CJ\ C 10 O O O O 0^ O O O O •a- r0^ o o CN fn CM CM lO CM in VO a^ CT> — 00 CM On ID tn in in CD rfn CN in r^ (N I^ in •• CO fT> 00 'd- On in CO « in CM CO •d- in tn CO o o rn r^ r- CM in in in in o -I CQ -J 1^ a) (D fn m in lO in CO tn (N CO a- CO ^ m o -a- m — w ID vO ^ 't in f^ i^ — v> > 0) ID I- c o CN CO *« E in in CM (SI CJN 1^ r^ rr~ o i^ CN CO in m lO m 'a- CM in n\ tn r^ r^ 1^ lO CM r- ^ IN tn tn tn CM •<i- o r- v9 fe^ in tn t- c en m CN m CM w m ^ in in CM in <^ ^ r^ m o CO •^ u tin (0 o. in E c (D o <D o3 to^ in in tn in >o tn r^ en in ID ^ o _ in a> UJ ID o o o in in V* 0) O C O +- CL 0) o c u •D 3 > X 10 1+- c Q O c (0 (0 m in 3 o > D L D. o 1. L D in I (0 d) >- L o 1o. — in +a. O l_ (U Q- tr E 5 u "4- O E 0) L. 3 C •4- (D in Ul <D 4Q- ta. CE > (D Q) a) <r cr o O c "a o <D a (D o 0) O c L. 0) ^ +- o Q) 13 C © > 0) 1 c o in ii ID 0) > l<u o T3 l- (D in O +- o t- d) o" c o z ID ID -- x: 0) E m w c m c o oo o o o o• o o in in — in — VD f^ — ^ </» b=t — D o c 0> Q> o c ID E 10-16 in s — CN ID •> M 1 o— O -1- tn 1 CN 1^ r^ 1^ c^ CT\ c^ (0 L < _J < _s — CD s in <3- in r- r^ r^ ,, Ul o o o* o O in i_ (D <o tn a> (D o o o 1 o o 3 c g <D o > c -o. a: c o c 0) C a: zo tn +CL 10 m o o 0) (D 10 +^ 2 o CTi c ^ (D O o o T3 C mO o o o t/) 2: t o _j o" o in b^ tn — CHAPTER ELEVEN CONTINUING PLANNING CHAPTER ELEVEN CONTINUING PLANNING Community development is a continuously evolving process. Therefore, planning must also be a continuing process in order to be an effective and appropriate guide under changing needs, technology and social patterns. However, such responsiveness must be carried out within the limits of fundamental ecological and sound community development objectives and practices. All elements of the Bloomsburg Plan as presented herein, should be reviewed in depth at regular intervals, depending on the rate of development but in no case at intervals of longer than three years. Furthermore, no changes should be made to the Plan without careful study and professional advice. The principal concern of a Planning Commission and other applicable agencies and individuals should be to maintain the Comprehensive Plan in an up to date status and to move towards implementation of the various elements thereof. A portion of the Plan which is particularly subject to change is the existing land use analysis. The most practical procedure for maintaining the existing land use record in a current status is through the use of building and zoning permit data as input. In this manner, applicable information concerning the addition and deletion of buildings and changes in use can be identified and necessary changes can be made on the "Existing Land Use" map. This will enable a continuing evaluation of the land use pattern with a view towards expanding zoning districts and modifying the other elements of the Plan as necessary. Along these same lines, the Subdivision and Land Development Ordinance and Zoning Ordinance of the municipality should be reviewed periodically and adjusted as necessary to ensure the incorporation of innovations and flexibility in development. This procedure should include recognition of changes in enabling legislation and the evolvement of new development techniques. A continuing appraisal of the activities of the Zoning Hearing Board will aid in an overall review process, since requests for special exceptions and variances oftentimes serve as indicators of the appropriateness of the regulations as related to desired and reasonable development. element of the Plan which will require continuing attention that pertaining to major thoroughfares. As existing highway plans are modified and new plans evolve relevant to regional highway transportation, it may be necessary to revise the Comprehensive Plan in order to achieve greater overal compatabi ity. An additional is I I Periodic reviews of the community facility and utility elements are also imperative. Existing levels of service should be reviewed as to their adequacy, and programs for the improvement and expansion of service should ll-l be adjusted in accordance with changing conditions and needs. The general categories to which attention should be directed are public schools, police protection, fire protection, municipal buildings, recreation, water, sanitary sewers, and storm water drainage. Since public improvement programs identify the timing and financial means of providing municipal capital improvements, such should be reviewed and The financial budgeting and reporting procedures of updated annually. the municipality should be included as part of this review, thereby enabling necessary adjustments to be made to projected revenues and expenditures. In addition, the procedural guidelines for implementation should be evaluated in light of changes in enabling legislation and available financial aids. Finally, the various projects programmed should be reviewed in terms of what has been achieved and what remains to be accomplished as well as in respect to new projects which should be added. The Columbia County Planning Commission, Soil and Water Conservation District, and the Columbia County Redevelopment Authority are invaluable resources to municipal planning commissions of the County. Continuous liaison should be maintained with these agencies and their services utilized whenever appropriate. Technical assistance is also available from the Bureau of Planning, Department of Community Affairs, but, as is generally the case with the other agencies mentioned, their services must be requested. In conclusion, the plan elements set forth within this report, the responsibllity of keeping them current, as well as general planning administration functions, should be supplemented by further planning and planning related activity. Some have been previously mentioned such as the recreation study. Other appropriate areas of responsibility are public education including the promotion of citizen participation in the planning process and the coordination of planning activities; while other areas of concern may be storm water drainage, programming the upgrading of collector roads under municipal jurisdiction, water resource planning, housing, and inter-governmental cooperation. I 1-2 BLOOMSBURG UNIVERSITY 3 54D^ DDD1SES3 4 NA 9127 .B5 R6 RODGERS ASSOC (CLIFTON E,) Comprehensive plan town of Bloomsbiirg \ NA 9127 .B5 R6