. BLOOmSBURG TOUIR PLfln fe=D j \ . ::.• ...» " ,, «*•••"•••*••* ;:) ins | m v •*••>• v v •• • • •; :: :; • VJ3Bi»*. •• •••'•tit: VSKk-*""*" t*Ji,y f L d « I A MHHHMHBH MICHAEL BAKER, JR PLANNING I G* CLIFTON E. RODGERS SSOCIATES f I I BLOOMSBURG TOWN PLAN 19 4 7 A Comprehensive Plan Prepared By .t _ MICHAEL B A K E R, JR., AND CLIFTON PLANNING ASSOCIATES Baker Building, Rochester, Pa. E. ROOGERS Digitized by the Internet Archive in Lyrasis 2011 with funding from Members and Sloan Foundation http://www.archive.org/details/bloomsburgtownplOObake 1 '*8L00MSBUfo ' REGIONAL MAP BLOOMSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA TOWN OFFICIALS TOWN COUNCIL James C. Stradling, President of Council COUNCILMEN Donald G. Ohl Ho Leiby J, Harland Melick Robert W» Patterson George C, Welliver *Dareey A, Wenner Ray ] COUNCILMEN - ELECT ] John Tc Church Alfred E Eve land 0, C. Herring C. Martin Lutz ] ] SCHOOL DIRECTORS ] Paul C. Webb, President of Board ] MEMBERS G. Edward Elwell, ] Jr« Walter W Goodman Norman W„ Hoffman Jesse E 4 Shuman William B. Sutlif Roy D, Snyder ] J STEERING COMMITTEE J James G. Law, Committee Chairman j COMMITTEE MEMBERS John Paul Barger Robert C e Barton Arthur S« Clay Paul R, Eyerly, Jr. W. Clair Hidlay j J 'Deceased u \ 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTORY Foreword Historical Influences 1 3 BASIC STUDIES Population General Background Existing Land Use 5 8 10 PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS Highways Off-Street Parking Public Schools Parks and Recreation Sewers and Sewage Disposal Future Residential Development Ultimate Land Use 14 16 20 26 30 32 34 PLANNING IMPLEMENTS Town Finances Organization and Administration Zoning Program for Action 37 41 45 47 STREET MAP OF BLOOMSBURG PENNSYLVANIA 1948 PREPARED BY MICHAEL BAKER, JR., a CLIFTON E. RODGERS, Planning ROCHESTER, PENNSYLVANIA SCALE IN FEET STREET A 5-10 7-10 F, C, B BERWICK ROAD G-H, 9-10 H, 10 E-F, € ST. BLACKBERRY AVE BLOOM ST BRIDGE INDEX p ANTHONY AVE ARBUTUS PARK ROAD BIRCH Associates . .".... G F,4 F, ST. BRUGLEH AVE PARK ST. PEACH AVE PEAR AVE PEARL ST. PENN ARGYLE AVE PENN G, 9 G.7-8 H.IO G, 8 E, 8 E-F, B ST. PINE AVE PINE ST POPLAR ST F, 4-10 E-7 G, PURSELL AVE B 0,8 6-10 F, R C CATHERINE ST F-l, CENTER ST. CHERRY ST CHESTNUT AVE. CHESTNUT ST. CHRISMAN AVE E-l, B 7 G,B E-G, 8 E-F, 9 E, 7 CLINTON AVE COLONIAL ST COLUMBIA AVE CREASY AVE railroad st reservoir st ridge ave reichart ave river road river terrace rose ave F-G, 7 H-l, 6 G, 6-7 H, S-6 D DEWEY ST 5 G, EAST ST F-G, 7 G, 4-10 EIGHTH ST. 8-1/2 ST 5-6 6-B F-G, 8 G, H, ELEVENTH ST ELM ST EYER ST b G.4 E-F, 6 F, 4-10 G.5-9 G, 6 ST. G.5-9 E-6,9 F-G,9 G.6-8 STRAWBERRY AVE SUMMIT AVE F-G, 7-8 C-D,7 T THIRD ST 7-8 E, e-f, SPRUCE ST. STERLING ST. STERNER AVE TENTH ST FAIR ST FAIRVIEW AVE f-1,2-6 SCHLEY ST SCOTT AVE SECOND ST SEVENTH ST SHORT AVE E, 7 F e.5-7 6,5-6 S SIXTH E e-i, d-e, 7 THORNTON AVE TWELFTH ST H.6-8 F, H, 5-10 G, 8 6-8 H, 10 FERRY ROAD FETTERMAN AVE FIFTEENTH ST H-l, 8 E, 8 6-8 I, FIFTH FIRST ST. ST. FOURTH ST. 5-10 F, E.5-9 6-10 D-E, B E, 8 G, 6 F, FRANKLIN AVE FRANKLIN ST. FRONT AVE 6 GIGER G-5 E.7-8 ST. GLEN AVE GRAPE AVE GREEN AVE H, 10 F, GUNDON AVE F, 8 6 H HARRIET H-1, ST. HARTMAN AVE HAZEL ST. HIGHLAND TERRACE 8 7-8 F, G, 10 D, 7-B I IRON E-l, 7 ST. J JAMES AVE JEFFERSON F, 5 E-H, 6 ST. K KNAPP AVE E,7 L LAURA AVE LEONARD ST LIGHT STREET ROAD LINCOLN AVE LOCKARD AVE LOCUST ST E,7 E-G, 5 8-10 E, D-E.B E, '. . . B F-G, 9 M MAGEE AVE MAPLE ST MARKET ST. MARY AVE G, 5 G, 10 E-l, 7 F, MIDDLE AVE MILLER AVE MILLVILLE ROAD MURRAY AVE G, 5 6-7 E-G, 7 A-E, 7 E"G, 7 N NINTH ST NORTH E-G, 5-8 E.8 ST. OAK ST OLD ORE ROAD OLIVE ST. ORCHARD ST OXFORD AVE OYER AVE F-G, 9-10 . . . G-IO G, 9 F, 5 7-8 E-6,6 D, . FOREWORD The purpose of this report is to determine the forces operating within the Town of Bloomsburg - public and private, internal and external, beneficial and harmful; to determine the problems created by these forces; to determine and recommend solutions to these problems, means of accelerating Since no individual, the desirable trends and deterring those undesirable. community, or region is static, the analyses submitted herein, based upon sound and scientific methods, are to be viewed not as an attempt to change Bloomsburg into something it is not, nor cares to be, but rather a means of retaining for Bloomsburg all its beneficial aspects in a changing environment. The attached report, consisting of considerable detail of background data, analyses and description of methods of reasoning, resulting conclusions, and recommendations has been compiled by the Planning Consultant Staff of the firm of Michael Baker, Jr. and Clifton E. Rodgers, Planning Associates. All matters contained in the report have been discussed a number of times with the members of Town Council, the Steering Committee on Town Planning, the School Board, and many other members of the community and .-. .* local organizations. The subjects given special treatment include; Land Use, Population, Residential Development, Schools, Recreation, Highways, Off-Street Parking, Finance, Administration, Zoning and Subdivision Control. An effort has been made to portray the important conditions, trends, and recommendations through maps, sketches, charts and narrative discussion. Numerous talks on the Town Plan have been given to civic groups by the Planning Staff to develop an understanding of the program. In addition a public exhibit of the proposals has been prepared to demonstrate the many phases of the plan. It is interesting to note that the proposed plan for Bloomsburg is not revolutionary to past trends of development, but merely is an evolutionary result of changing conditions brought about by modern living and working habits in our society. This plan recognizes the responsibilities of a community to the youth, the adults, and the family as a unit, and in turn recognizes the individual's responsibility to the community. On a scientific and economic basis recommendations are made to improve education, recreation, business, health and welfare phases of community life. Any course of action charted at this time must be fluid, subject to adjustments and dictated by changing conditions. Planning must be a Continuing Function. Therefore, a Citizens Planning Association is recommended as the living organ to foster the plan. The immediate problem in considering the successful results to be derived from the plan is Leadership. one The Town Planning Consultants were able to illustrate the advantage of the planning approach to municipal problems while engaged in preparation of the attached plan. The State Highway Department's original proposal for the relocation of Route 11, submitted in August, was analyzed by the Planning Staff, The resulting modification of the proposal prevented the deterioration of a well established residential area, the splitting of the Town by a major thoroughfare, the intensification of traffic congestion, etc. The route proposed by the Planning Staff after due analysis was approved by Council and the Steering Committee, After numerous conferences both here and in Harrisburg, the proposal was approved by the State, This will result in the provision of $44,000 of additional pavement at no cost to the Town; the opening for development of a vacant area in Town; and the provision of excellent access into Town, This one project illustrates that sound planning pays dividends. Acknowledgement of appreciation is hereby expressed for the excellent cooperation given the Planning Staff by the Town and School District officials, commercial and civic bodies, and individuals all too numerous to mention by name. Special appreciation is given to the members of the Steering Committee on Town Planning who have contributed so well of their time, assistance and suggestions. As a guide the Town Plan should aid the people of Bloomsburg in continuing to develop their community in an orderly, attractive, and sound economic manner. Clifton \B, Rodgers Planning Consultant two »» » » »W i ] . . . Mai n Street 1 J ] • . . Town Hall HISTORICAL INFLUENCES Probably the citizens of Bloomsburg have at some time or other asked Why is Bloomsburg? Bow did it come to be? How themselves these questions: did it happen to grow where it did, and why is it like it is? The answers to these questions can be found in examining the Town's historical growth. For it is in its origin that a community assumes a cause for existence and begins to provide a common basis for people to live and work together. It is in the process of growth that it begins to take shape, to establish certain customs, habits and traditions, to form a life and culture of its own, ORIGIN The original settlement of Bloomsburg and the surrounding area is. typical American Story: a saga of restless settlers, primarily Quakers, Dutch and Germans, seeking a spot in a young and vigorous country where they could establish a new life, free from hardship, fear and interference. Originally Bloom Township, a subdivision of first Northumberland and then Columbia County, it was not until 1870 that Bloomsburg was incorporated as a "Town"- a distinction which it has maintained in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to this date, ECONOMIC BASIS OF GROWTH The original Township of Bloom quickly made an enterprising change from an agricultural district to a commercial and industrial center. With the advent of the canal, the Town's location made it a natural trading center for the surrounding area Crafts, the tanning of hides, and the manufacture of wagons and carriages were among its first enterprises. The early discovery of iron ore formed a solid nucleus about which the Town's economy was organized for nearly three-fourths of a century. The incorporation of Bloomsburg as a Town marked its transition from an iron economy to a textile-manufacturing center. As early as 1882 textile mills began to establish themselves in Town, and the economy thus formed has since been strengthened and solidified. Today Bloomsburg is a textile manufacturing center, with the production and processing of woolen and silk goods and the manufacture of carpets among its principal industries, Bloomsburg has also maintained its dominance as a commercial center. Although the canal and its advantages as a trade route have long since ceased to function, the Town's position as county seat has made it a natural shopping center for the entire region. Today it performs 42 percent of the retail sales in Columbia County, COMMUNITY GROWTH With the establishment and development of a sound economic base, the Town has also grown and developed. The population has steadily mounted since the Town's settlement, expanding from 3,341 persons in 1870 to nearly 11,000 today. New homes have been built, streets have been laid and utilities installed, stores and shops have been developed, and facilities have three ^s$^ ^%^ COMMUNITY GROWTH 1802- 1947 BLOOMSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA OH] AS LAID OUT IN 1802 AS DEVELOPED BY I860 AS DEVELOPED BY 1876 AS DEVELOPED BY 1947 J ! t~- j Ik y~. \\ £ . '<L f J 'A /' _ u expanded to serve amusement, educational, health, religious and cultural From a small gridiron settlement developed around eight interpurposes. secting streets laid out in 1802, Bloomsburg has expanded into a thriving community with a total developed area of more than 1200 acres, ELEMENTS ] J ] OF DISTINCTION Besides being an industrial and commercial center, the Town of Bloomsburg has developed other distinctions which set it in a class beyond its neighbor-communities. The Town has adapted itself to the air age in stride and now owns a class two airport. It is a high-grade floriculture center, Spectators travel shipping its floral products to all parts of the Nation, from miles around to witness the annual Bloomsburg Fair, unexcelled throughout the State, The Town is also a health center, with the Bloomsburg Hospital and a seat of education, as home for the Bloomsburg State Teachers' College These are reflections of a high-calibre growth and status, elements of community distinction,, ] ] ] 1 ] ] ] ] ] i 3 four J ] "1 State Teachers' J J J ] ] , . . Pa i r-Ti me Colle : POPULATION An accurate analysis of the population is a primary necessity in preparation of a sound Town Plan, Trends in population growth will have an effect upon future economic growth and stability, and in turn will determine future requirements for economic development and civic improvement. Likewise, geographic distribution of the population will have a decisive bearing upon location of proposed improvements, TOTAL POPULATION The attached chart illustrates the chronological growth of Bloomsburg's population from 1870 to the present, compared with that of the County, State and Nation, Compared with the County, Bloomsburg has steadily gained in population. In the last 37 years, the County has increased only six percent in population while the Town has gained over 44 percent. This is further illustrated by the fact that the Town has steadily increased from 11,6$ of the County population to over 20 percent in the last 77 years. The County has ceased growing - in fact, between 1910 and 1947 the County outside Bloomsburg has lost population. This must be kept in mind - the reservoir of population adjoining the Town, although not drying up, is no longer increasing. This reservoir in the past has been an important source of in-migrants to Bloomsburg as well as constituting the shopping public utilizing the Bloomsburg Commercial Area, The competitive situation of the several municipalities in this retail market area may be intensified in the future and, therefore, far greater thought must be given to the development of forces to attract people to Bloomsburg, CHARACTERISTICS OF POPULATION AGE OF POPULATION J ] ] ] The attached chart on "Composition of Population" compares the percentage of the Town's population in each five year age group with similar groups of the State's population. As compared with the State, Bloomsburg has a deficiency of younger people and an excess of the very old. The median age of the Town residents was 32 years while that of the State was only 29. This differential from the more normal age pattern of the State indicates several things i. ] In-migration of adults: an influx of persons of productive ages from the adjoining areas. ] 3 five g o o o ; o O 3 o n o M 2 w «> * i» « * . c, 1 1 a Ul t- 1 4 1 c 1 o z ; u. o *" tfl 11 1 u 1 < in o z J Ul z Id ! ! \ (L IT z z ] ] < o <r o < <3 o < V > (- Z t " 1 : i^ . > >- 1 tf) Z z w e a > - cd 1 I ' o o : j LU ] ] > .- < i Id o T o : j i 1 < ' I \ 1 V Q. O o o z" o 1- 1 11 t\ CO liJ - 1- v> < 1- 2 1 ; 1 LJ z \ or 2 ~ 1 \ | 5 \ \ O 1 O i L i T 1 \\ 'l Alt \ X 2* Low birth-rate: this implies growth of the Toum is dependent upon the above in-migration rather than upon natural increase (difference between births and deaths). SEX COMPOSITION The chart referred to above also indicates the sex composition of the Town by age groups. The startling degree to which women out-number men in certain age groups indicates an influence of Bloomsburg's dominant industry - the textile industry. This industry, employing females to a great extent, has attracted female in-migrants of adult age. It may also imply an outmigration of Town-born males due to a lack of desirable employment. Note that this excess of women starts at the post-school age and continues only until about 35 years of age Within the child-bearing ages of 15 through 49, there were 2,868 females in 1940 as compared with 2,495 males - an excess of 369 females, or In other words, 13 per13 percent of the women in the child-bearing ages. cent of the potential mothers in the Town cannot, quantitatively, find mates unless they migrate elsewhere. Thus the birth rate of Bloomsburg will continue to remain low as compared with that of a normal population, LEVEL OF EDUCATION The level of education of adults in Bloomsburg is far higher than many areas of the State, Statistics compiled in the U» S, Census of 1940 indicates the median number of school years completed by persons 25 years of age or over in Bloomsburg was 9,7 years, compared with 8,2 years for Columbia County, and 8,5 years for the State, TYPES OF EMPLOYMENT The manner in which the people of a community make their livelihood is frequently a reflection of the basic community characteristics - economic, educational and cultural. The attached chart indicates how the people of Bloomsburg make their livings POPULATION DISTRIBUTION The Population Distribution Map, showing where the people live in 1947, indicates a high degree of concentration of population within a sharply defined built-up area of the Town, This suggests a higher than normal "density" of population, with resultant impact upon healthful housing standards, adequate open space, and increased traffic congestion, The center of population of the Town was found to be a little south of East Third Street at Miller Avenue, This factor has an important bearing upon location of future public improvements within reasonable distance of the majority of the population. six ] COMPOSITION OF BLOOMSBURG, COMPARISON BY SEX NUMBER 400 500 3C0 200 PA. POPULATION - AGE GROUP 1940 COMPARISON WITH STATE PERCENTAGE 100 2 5 4 6 YEARS 8 OVER 74 70 TO !5 TO 69 SO TO 55 TO 59 45 TO 49 64 40 TO 44 MM J77 30 TO 34 2 5 TO 2 9 20 TO 24 j IS UNDER i TO 5 >« 19 YEARS PENNSYLVANIA BLOOMSBURG 6 , ESTIMATED FUTURE POPULATION It is estimated that the 1947 population of Bloomsburg is approximateAs indicated on the attached chart, the estimated populy 10,700 persons. lation for 1960 is 12,000 persons. This constitutes, roughly, a gain of one percent, or 100 persons per year. The low birth rate of 14.2 per 1000 population is expected to continue because of the population characteristics and type of employment available. Due to the older population, the death rate will be in the vicinity of 11.2, leaving a potential natural increase in population of only 3 Per thousand population, or an annual natural increase of about 30 persons. The remainder of the expected annual increase or 70 persons must come from inmigration. In-migration is dependent upon expansion of employment - i.e. expansion The amount of employof existing industries and entry of new industries. ment possible through expansion of retail facilities is limited. Therefore in order to attract 70 in-mi grants per year, sustained additional industrial employment will be required. j J J ] ] ] seven j GENERAL BACKGROUND The Town of Blootnsburg serves a variety of functions: it is an industrial Town and yet is a college Town; it is the County seat and also is It is not without cause that th,e retail and wholesale center of its area. the Town is referred to as the "Parlor City" of the Susquehanna River Valley, a surprising nomination for a community in which approximately three-fourths of the employment is industrial, THE ECONOMY The Town of Eloomsburg has a unique economy which possesses some sound basic characteristics of diversification and yet reflects a few contradictory tendencies. The economy is sound in that it is based heavily both on commerce and industry. Yet, within the industrial structure, the predominant industry is textiles, and a single plant provides approximately one-half of all industrial employment. On the other hand, there is a wide diversification in the local textile industries themselves, ranging from the processing of fiber and yarns to the manufacture of articles of clothing and carpets. The above characteristics indicate alternate capacities for stability and instability, with the resultant of forces apparently providing a stable economic base. The local retail and wholesale activity services a wide area. It is indicated by available statistics that a population of 2S , 000 consumers is fully served, with approximately 35,000 partially served, ; EMPLOYMENT The Columbia County Committee for Economic Development made a survey in 1945 coordinated with a national survey. This survey of existing employment and future potential employment reprted that 36 industries in the Bloomsburg area employed 2,400 persons, A recent survey of the 11 major industries in Bloomsburg proper indicated an employment of S803, of which 40,5 percent were females. Of these 2803 employees almost 94 percent were employed in the textile industries. The non-textile industries, making up only 6 percent of the total, employed females in a ratio of only 1 female to 9 males. It is immediately apparent that there exists serious need to attract to Town male employing industries. It is safe to assume that with the relatively large number of females employed, a sizeable market for male labor can be developed through introduction of male employing industries. This remedy can also serve to neutralize the aforementioned capacity for instability due to non-diversification of types of industry. Based upon the C,E,D, Survey, for every 2,2 industrial workers there These acservice or wholesale establishments. tivities will reflect any changes in industrial employment. is one employee in retail, eight A survey of existing industries indicated that several soncerns contemplate expansion of facilities which will increase industrial employment by over 20 percent. This is of importance to Bloomsburg, for it indicates an expanding community for which planning is an essential. 1 J J ] ] "1 J ] ] ] Ji - ] J J ] 1 nine OCCUPATIONAL TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG TYPE OF EMPLOYMENT PROFESSIONAL AND SEMI PROFESSIONAL PROPRIETORS, MANAGERS, FARMERS AND OFFICIALS CLERICAL, SALES WORKERS, ETC. SERVICE WORKERS CRAFTSMEN, FOREMEN, ETC. OPERATIVES AND SIMILAR WORKERS LABORERS (FARM AND NON-FARM) DOMESTIC SERVICE WORKERS ALL CLASSIFICATIONS • DISTRIBUTION COLUMBIA COUNTY • PENNSYLVANIA PERCENT OF EMPLOYED POPULATION EXISTING LAND USE The Existing Land Use. Study presents a picture of all the land in Town - how it is being used, and how much is being used for each of various, purposes* Through analysis, inspection, comparison with accepted standards, and reference to past experience in this and other communities, certain implications can be seen from the existing land-use pattern. Further conclusions can also be drawn regarding preparation of the future land development plan, STUDY AREAS The intensity of land use in Bloomsburg varies from relatively extensive farm land to three story apartment houses. Therefore, for a proper analysis of land use, it has been necessary to define distinctive areas of the Town, l. The Developed Area extends outward from the Town center to the rural fringe-land. This area has been further divided into two categories: a. The Inner Developed Area contains all the facilities used by the community in its normal everyday life. b. The Outer Developed Area consists of the college, hospital airport, fairgrounds, water company and tracts of vacant land surrounding the Inner Developed Area, , s, The Outlying Area consists of the remaining land within the Town boundaries predominantly of an agricultural , nature. The table "Summary of Land Use" presents a summary of the acreage of land devoted to each type of land use in each of the study areas defined above. An analysis of these areas Will reveal an interesting story of the Town's development, its physical condition-,, and its efficiency in functioning as a community, INNER DEVE4 OPE AREA RESIDENTIAL USE J J Almost one-half (47.5$) of the "Inner Developed Area" is devoted to residential use. This indicates a very compact residential area, with an average density of about 33 persons per acre. J Evidently several factors have been contributory in creating this high density of development. The Town's growth has always been limited by flood J ] ten Consequently, resi- .x conditions and the presence of the surrounding hills. dential areas have been laid out in compact units, with many houses built on In many cases, homes have been built on both ends lots of substandard size. of such lots. The entire density situation thus created is indicative of unhealthy conditions in several respects. Homes built so closely together cannot permit adequate entry of needed light and air, nor can they provide the yard space so necessary to privacy of family life* Lack of garage or driveway space intensifies the on-street parking problem. Heavily developed areas place an additional burden on the adjoining street system, often rendering inadequate a street layout that would have Finally, it has been found that overcrowded been quite sufficient otherwise. residential neighborhoods tend to depreciate more quickly than well laid-out, low density areas. The condition of most of the existing housing in Bloomsburg is fairly There are no well-defined "blighted" or "slums" areas as are found in most communities. From a very rapid visual inspection of exteriors, approximately 100 dwellings were counted that appeared to be in the final stages of deterioration. These homes are scattered over the Town in little clusters and do not constitute a very great threat to the community if properly handled. good. The age-characteristics of housing in Bloomsburg present some severe implications. With over one-half of existing dwellings 40 or more years old, an increasing number of houses will be falling into the category of "inadequate". Unless preventive measures are taken this situation can move beyond control very quickly, leading to a snow-balling degeneration of the entire residential area, MIXED USE There is a large percentage of land (9.6% acres) in the Town devoted to mixed use. This is particularly evident along the Main Street shopping area where the second and third floors are used for living quarters, A glance at the Population Map will reveal that these areas are among the most densely populated in Town, Here the dwelling units are greatly overcrowded and provide little or nothing in the way of yard space. -J It is very important that the harmful conditions found in mixed use areas be rectified. It is possible that provision of off-street parking lots in the main shopping area will attract some of the commercial facilities that are scattered throughout the community. Some of these facilities, such as professional offices, personal service shops, etc, could very well be located in the upper stories of existing stores. This would accomplish a dual purpose, eliminating mixed use as well as removing commercial features from residential areas. J J J eleven ~ EXISTING Li BLOOMSBURG BLOOMSBU.RG TOWN PL 1947 COMMERCIAL USE The bulk of the Town's commercial facilities is centered on Main Street, between East and Market Streets. However, there is a tendency for commercial establishments to spread out along that portion of existing highways lying within the developed area. In addition, commercial facilities of various sorts are scattered throughout the main residential area, in no particularly indicative pattern. Should there be a marked persistence in the spreading out of Bloomsburg's commercial facilities, the forthcoming results might well be of a drastic nature. Some facilities would undoubtedly locate themselves just outside of the Town boundary, escaping local taxation. All types of facilities would not be within a reasonable distance of each other, necessitating several moves and stops for the consumer to complete his shopping. Certain facilities would probably be duplicated unnecessarily, increasing the number of marginal shops and business failures, detrimental to the merchant, the consumer, and the local government. One of the main active controls available for retaining the bulk of commercial facilities within a defined area lies in the provision of adequate off-street parking lots. This topic is discussed more thoroughly under the section on "Off-Street Parking", Realization of the solution offered therein will do much to retain existing facilities within the main shopping center, INDUSTRIAL USE The main industrial area is located along the D, L, & W, Railroad, stretching across the lower end of Town from Locust Street to the Fairgrounds Location of the industrial area has the effect of cutting the Town into two parts. Although this has some disadvantages, they are not so great as it would seem at first. The residential area located south of the industrial belt is very small, and residential expansion is not likely to take place to a great extent in this portion of Town, Traffic along the railroad is very light and permits smooth movement between the two areas. Future industrial growth and expansion should be confined to the existNot only will rail facilities be readily available, but industrial facilities will be kept from encroaching upon residential areas, ing area as much as possible. PARKS AND PLAYGROUNDS The area of Land devoted to parks and playgrounds is very low ($.3 acres) when compared with other communities or with established recreational standards. A study of 2qq American cities with population 5,000 - 10,000 indicates an average of 430 persons per acre of park" compared with Bloomsburg's 2,000 persons per acre. U.S. Dept. of Interior, National Park Service twelve I L [ I L t L t It may be safely assumed that a lack of adequate recreation facilities can be highly contributory in fostering discontentment among young people. Such lack of interest in local activity may well find expression in tendencies toward out-migration. If Sloomsburg is to provide a well-integrated community growth program, the function of recreation must not be neglected. PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND PROPERTY Though there are more than 11 acres o? land within the "Inner Developed Area" occupied by public buildings, including schools, less than one-half of Bloomsburg is the County this acreage is utilized for local public purposes* seat of Columbia County and must administer County functions, resulting in location of the court-house and County jail in Town, There are also some State operated facilities such as the highway garage and Federal buildings such as the post office. These additional public facilities tend to raise the amount of land normally required for public use« An improvement program for local schools and recreational areas will raise this percentage even more. VACANT LAND There exists a very small percentage (S.Ofc) of vacant land in the "Inner Developed Area". Additional areas, as indicated by the school report, will be needed for expansion of school and recreational facilities. Only a portion of the remaining vacant land lies above flood line and is therefore suitable for residential development THE OUTER DEVELOPED AREA Immediately outside of the "Inner Developed Area" lies another large area of land containing approximately 596 acres. This is the second study area, referred to in the opening paragraphs as the "Outer Developed Area", It contains such features as the fairgrounds, the airport, the hospital, the college, the. water company, and vacant tracts, in the quantities indicated in the table, "Summary of Land Use", THE OUTLYING AREA The remaining study area, termed the "Outlying Area", comprises the remainder of land within the Town boundaries. As can be seen from the "Land Use Summary", the greatest portion of this area is devoted to agricultural use. Normally it would be expected that spme of this land could be used for Town expansion. However, flood conditions, as shown by the 1936 flood line on the Land-Use Map, render approximately 500 acres, or 27% of the area useless for development. thirteen c > o rH CO +» HH S. mi ? t* o g r-i • o• "tf CO co cn rH • CO cm » W ••••• o if) C^ [O to cn • • o> oo to to cm CO <# rri o> ,H lO in CM CM CO to • otoeoio m CO t> CO • • CM O r-\ r-t CO • m CO CM CO 8 io a> CO • • CO O in o • cO co CO rH £> 9 CO • •1 o> ^-^ CM »»-* o CO to • • • CM CO -^ lO in a> CO in rH rH (30 c •ri ce >> (0 CD ih i-l ct h c <t CO • 00 CM <# Oi • o tJ <D O. CB CO ^ CD CD o o• o CD CD (4 cOO-CMtO • CntOlOlO rH i-H iHCVJlOC-- ••« • 9? CM ^ CO » • CM • to in rH • • ocototo CM «H rH CM C\J eg to CM <* CM r-i o E O d v 43 CJ UJ CO a 10 3 4> v> C.) O cd t! T, O a CD c 0-— ©-M rH O — o r- ec CO 3 — X CD CO 2 o u. o O -I UJ i> 0) Q cd CD (0 CD 3 a» • CO CO • • 9 CO CO • CM CO rH c s •rt CO r-t CM •a 4) o C! CD lO m t> CO « • H• <0«O« to • 0) O rt — iH m• o• rH CM in • • « CM rH Cft • ^K p.^— O CO CO C\2 CD o• 8 rH u >> > Q c (-4 CD C a M CO CD w < • lO CD -o c o o •Ph 4) O J3 « CD CD CO «l +» | CO si CO CO <£j O CJ a> CN H U O -w X tO CO CD M o < o« o r-\ to tO CM lO • • • CM cO O to H rri • 8 ^ • to v Ol <H ^• O i-t CO o- CM to • • o • in «* CM 00 CM in • • • to CO to m o> to CO "# • • CO «# s r-t ' r-i ^ • CO <# CO o c o •H o • rH -p H •H 09 C5 • T) <h co o W >i Cd •n CD CO & Tj a cd J p «H r-t s "2 (0 «m i CD CO CO a O S CO <m 1 CjHfl»4 CD IK) +* d C Sri •H t-l co co S K O 3 m 6 cq CD i-H CO p m CD E e o O •»* *O rH *H p CO •»< O rH CD cd CO M bOrH rH rHrHP-51-t-rt -r-i 3 +» rttHlHCQt) rH 3 O rH J3 +> J3 3 1 3 co <0 CO MfnPu, +3+> 1 Tj CO CO CO •H Tl 03 >) 00 U 3 3 +-> M<DSrHC!0 oOQ).CCL,3CD*H +i -rl -H O O CD M ^ d^iriri H) h«4H u «T3tJ(hX>X>B3Sm«)C0 •hcch)33©^om 1 t) SH M. PhPl,CmOOCO< c, CO CO > +» >» S ja > o «) cd +» ih tJ +* CO C « > fi D O CO cd -* O i-l fH a <W += CO rH r-i rH TJ H C3 to G K O *H >J H m +* r> >a C CD CO u o CO $ O Eh E-4 •r5 CD O I [ r c c c [ [ I L r L L [ HIGHWAYS The function of a highway is to provide for ment of vehicles. It must be recognized that the property, commercial development of the roadside, of vehicles are all the function of local streets function of highways. the safe and rapid moveprovision of access to the parking and loading and not the primary This function of rapid and safe movement of vehicles has a two-fold purpose. One is to provide movement through town for traffic destined elsewhere and the other is to provide access to the centers of activity of the Town. T Through-traffic is of negligible economic value to the built-up area of Town, Outside of an insignificant amount of food and gasoline purchased by such through-traffic a type of purchase the average driver prefers to there is practically no make at some out-of-town roadside development economic gain from such traffic. On the other hand, this type of traffic causes economic loss through serious interference with local traffic as well Every as constituting a serious hazard to the safety of the inhabitants. effort should be made to discourage such traffic providing that proper and direct access to and from Town is provided, — — EXISTING SITUATION The relative volumes of traffic on the various highways leading into Bloomsburg and their relation to the street system of the Town are shown in detail on the Highway Map, All the highways utilize Main Street as a route through the Town, This causes serious congestion, especially on Saturday afternoons and evenings when shopping activity - the basic function of the Main Street properties is at its height, U. S. R U T E I I INADEQUACIES OF EXISTING ROUTE There is no need to discuss the inadequacies of the existing highway, in the eastern part of Town, The inadequate width, the poor intersections, the uncontrolled development of the abutting properties, the high percentage of vehicular accidents have all forced the State Department of Highways to plan the relocation of this section of Route 11, INTERSTATE HIGHWAY SYSTEM Route 11 has been designated as part of the National System of Interstate Highways, One of the recommendations of the National Inter- regional Highway Committee is the by-passing or skirting of all smaller cities and towns: "these small cities and towns »«»« may be adequately served by a fourteen : r r L C c [ L [ C .: r C skirting location of the main route", (l) Therefore, an ultimate by-pass for all through traffic is recommended. Although the construction of this by-pass is not feasible at the present time, the increased vehicular traffic and the increased expenditures for highways will make such construction economically feasible in the not-toodistant future. The proposed ultimate by-pass route is shown clearly on the Highway Map. Sixth Street - Railroad Street Truck By-Pass Since the ultimate by-pass will not be constructed for at least several years, it is essential that provision be made for trucks to by-pass congested Main Street and avoid the dangerous hill west of West Street. As is shown on the attached map, a logical route from the terminus of the State proposal for the relocation of Route 11, would be along Sixth Street from the highway terminus to the Reading Railroad and then along Railroad Street to Main Street. This proposed truck by-pass will serve a two-fold purpose. It will permanently provide good direct access from the east or west to the industrial area of the Town. Heavy trucking will no longer interfere with traffic in the central commercial area. In addition, this route will also serve as a by-pass for trucks until such time that the ultimate highway bypass will be constructed. OTHER ROUTES The volumes of traffic carried on the other highway routes leading into Town are not great enough to provide economic justification for extensive relocation as on the above route. It is recommended that the problem of congestion encountered on route 42 to the north be alleviated by widening the right of way in the built up area and correction of the very sharp curves. This will require demolition of a number of ancient residences which have outlived their useful existence. It is also recommended that parking and loading be restricted to one side of the street on route 339. No recommendations are made on the remainder of the highway routes. (1) Report of National Inter-regional Highway Committee - 1944 Washington, D. C. fifteen PROPOSED HIG BLOOMSBUR P E N N S TOWN BLOOMSBURG PL, TOWN MICHAEL BAKER, OR CONSULTING ENGINEER ROCHEST ULTIMATE BY-P/ PROPOSED IMME rararan RECOMMENDED •••••• RECOMMENDED AUXILIARY ACCf IB PROPOSED HIGHWAY RELOCATION. BLOOMSBURG & VICINITY PENNSYLVANIA TOWN PLANNING PLANNING TOWN BLOOMSBURG SURVEY COMMISSION 1947 PHPMED VICHAEL BAKER, I Br CLIFTON JR. E. RODOERS TOWH PL*HH£f EHBIHEE* ROCHESTER. PENNSYLVANIA ^-^~ ULTIMATE BY-PASS zzzzzzz PROPOSED IMMEDIATE STATE PROGRAM raraaza RECOMMENDED • ••••• RECOMMENDED IMMEDIATE TRUCK BY-PASS ^=^ AUXILIARY ACCESS STREET MODIFICATION OF IMMEDIATE STATE PROGRAM I -'*l„ .LpagQDD aaannt DDpi dcud quijuljuulju uLJuut^u" OFF-STREET PARKING Everyone recognizes that Bloomsburg dominates the retail market of Columbia County, but how tenuous the justification for this dominance is not so. apparent. The estimated value of retail sales in 1946 in Bloomsburg was $11,490,000, which was 42 percent of the total for the County. Yet Bloomsburg has only 22 percent of the $47,700,000 estimated gross effective buying Berwick, with income of the County and only 21 percent of the population. its larger population and larger effective buying income, accounted for only one-third of the County's retail trade. These figures are cited to demonstrate that very important forces exist that can operate to remove Bloomsburg' s dominating position over retail trade in this area. The commercial area exists today located where it is only through inertia of investment custom, and habit. As the County Seat, Bloomsburg was the natural center for the shopping center of this area. Generation after generation developed shopping habits centered on Main Street, Bloomsburg. In response to this demand, merchants invested heavily in fitting out stores and shops which resulted in Main Street as it is today. , However, in recent years this "purchasing power" has mounted itself on rapidly revolving wheels that clock-off the miles in a matter of minutes. This "mobility" can radically change long-established shopping habits. Some positive action is necessary to fix permanently Bloomsburg as the shopping center of this region. Recognition of this mobility of purchasers is important, for with the new proposed highway between the Town and Berwick, it will take less time to drive to Berwick than to drive down one side of Main Street, back on the other, and down the side streets in the usual Saturday evening search for a parking space. Bloomsburg must provide parking space if its commercial area is to grow and prosper. As mentioned in the section on "Population" the reservoir of po pulation living in the areas surrounding the Town is no longer increasing. Therefore the competition of the various towns for the privilege of serving this po pulation will become more severe. This competition must be met, and it can only be successfully met and out-distanced by the provision of adequate parking space. Since all existing street facilities are already taxed to th* maximum, such new facilities must be off-street parking. , , Bloomsburg can provide excel lent parking facilities for an additional 238 vehicles at no expense to the Town, to the property owners, or to the merchants under the plan proposed herein. sixteen r i: [ 1 i. L . c Ll! r - V < i < o U~ i i ^» -* o On."> -Jo" < z "" ; M 1 i UJ * X 3 3 a 1 * a: h- s z o JH 4 ST. 1 Ti < h- O 111 o IE a: < i a. © £ - 2E x * i \l ,!« 3 i a i s » i tl N 3 o •^ jM _J UJ > UJ a W o o _- !*#•» :f i 3 3 z z y i s x 3 x a . v « l t UJ a: . " s o r : _ L L C L c SURVEYS OF EXISTING CONDITIONS MAXIMUM DEMAND Surveys of parking in and near the main business area at times of peak load, Saturday afternoon and evenings, indicated that 425 cars were parked in an "improper" manner, on one or both sides of heavily travelled sidestreets, in narrow alleys, or in a dangerous, disorganized manner in the rear of commercial buildings. NORMAL DAILY DEMAND Based upon surveys of parking conditions at various time of the day on normal week days, it was found that during morning and afternoons 65 to 90 cars were parked in an "improper manner" within or in the immediate vicinity of the commercial area. Of these, 20 to 45 were parked in the vicinity of Pine Avenue (Between Main and Third Streets), During the evening hours there were only 8 to 12 vehicles parked in the alleys. PARKING FACILITIES REQUIRED Based on the above surveys, -estimating that 80% of the cars "improperly" parked on the periphery of the commercial area were there for shopping purposes, and allowing a 5% increase for "generated" parking demand due to provision of new parking space it is estimated that parking facilities for 482 vehicles are required at time of peak demand, — PROPOSED PARKING PLAN It is proposed that a Municipal Authority be established as authorized by State law to sell bonds, acquire property, improve and operate a parking area on property adjoining Pine Street in the rear of the south side of Main Street. This parking area will accommodate 238 cars, or 57 percent of the number of cars now "improperly"' parked on a normal Saturday evening. This "Minimum Plan" has attempted to minimize property damage. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF PROPOSED PLAN ACQUISITION AND CONSTRUCTION COST The assessed valuation of property required has been estimated at $117 per parked car. The cost of improvements, including installation of parking meters and paving, is estimated at $120 per parking space. seventeen r r [ ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY It is proposed that parking meters be installed in the parking area, the income to be used in defraying the costs of acquisition and improvement, to place the project on a self-supporting financial basis. On the basis of the foregoing surveys of Normal and Peak demands for parking facilities, it is estimated that each parking space will be used a "minimum" of 18*6 hours per week. With installation of parking meters this will net a weekly average income of $0,93 per meter. The attached chart entitled "Economic Feasibility" indicates that with this income, an acquisition cost for the required land up to 7.6 times the assessed valuation can be paid, and the project constructed and operated on a self -liquidating basis. EXPECTED RESULTS OF VROffOSAl This project will have far more valuable effects upon the Town, the merchants and the property owners - effects which in themselves justify adoption of the plan, EFFECT UPON COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY AND PROPERTY VALUES 1. Ease and convenience of parking will attract to Bloomsburg a far greater percentage of the "mobile purchasing pooter" mentioned above. 2. Commercial structures abutting pn parking area can utilize the rear of buildings as additional frontage Thus, existing waste area is transformed to valuable frontage. . 3. Additional property can be developed for expansion of existing concerns and attraction of new concerns - all convenient to the large reservoir of purchasers in the parking area. 4. Convenient loading facilities will be provided. 5. The concentration of the commercial area about the parking lot will make it possible for purchasers to go from store to store and complete their intended purchases with a single parking. 6. All of the foregoing will increase property values and commercial activity, thereby benefitting property owners, merchants and the Town as a whole, EFFECT UPON SAFETY AND ATTRACTIVENESS OF COMMERCIAL AREA 1. Removal of uns ightly structures would increase value of adjoining property. The removal of serious danger from fire that is present in these old tmder-dry frame structures is important. eighteen ; : j : ] i L OFF-STREET PARKING PROGRAM BLOOMSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY REQUIRED USE OF PARKING AREA ( \ HOURS PER SPACE PER WEEK AT FIVE CENTS PER HOUR j AMORTIZATION CURVES INCLUDE INITIAL IMPROVEMENT COST OF $120 PER PARKING SLOT. : [ - . I 2. There is a serious safety hazard present in the disorganized, unauthorized parking of vehicles in alleys and back yards. This would all be removed or controlled. EFFECT UPON TRAFFIC CIRCULATION 2. 2. Main Street would serve its primary purpose - the free movement of vehicles - more adequately. (a) Removal of a large amount of unnecessary cruising traffic in search of parking space during periods of maximum congestion. (b) Removal of loading trucks from south side of Main Street. Provision of loading space in parking lot will remove onehalf of a serious traffic hazard as well as providing more convenient parallel loading faciliti es. (c) Concentration of pedestrians upon walkways from parking area to Main Street will permit a more efficient and safe This concontrol of p edestrian crossing of Main Street. stitutes a major source of traffic interference during intensive shopping periods. Permit more rigid restriction of parking on narrow streets to assure their use for the movement of vehicles. GENERAL REMARKS PIECEMEAL ACTION IS IMPOSSIBLE This plan is economically feasible and can be quickly accomplished. However, it cannot be accomplished in any piecemeal fashion, for improvement of one part of the area will immediately cause a rapid increase in This would make the later property value of all adjoining properties. acquisition of these adjoining properties for expansion of the parking area prohibitive. It must be done all at once or else it cannot be done. A BROADER PLAN IS POSSIBLE The plan discussed above concerns a minimum area selected to minimize property damage but does not fill all the needs for parking and redevelopment of the commercial area. This plan can be expanded to include redevelopment of the entire central commercial area. Such a plan is illustrated in attached, plan and persp ective views of a Redeveloped Commercial Area. nineteen am - - _ 1; I ; r L < O UJ cc UJ ? Ld > s S o o UJ > t- o UJ Q. if) It LU 0. < or 1- z LU o o LU a. o -J LU > LU O LU or z _l < > O < li- > CS to _J H z UJ $ o I to x: a: < a. «• hLU UJ cc tn i U. u. o 3 m <0 o o CD THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS Today we consider the community not alone responsible for providing instruction in the basic elements of reading and writing but many other aspects of education as well. Our form of living has become so complex that for the protection of the individual and for the protection and preservation of the community, the Commonwealth and the Nation, the responsibilities of the community for the provision of education have increased many fold. It is important that we be prepared for the future, which will bring even greater expansion of those elements which we today readily accept as part of the public education system* Bloomsburg has three outstanding needs that must be met by the School District The two ancient elementary school buildings must be replaced with modem structures on sites that meet the educational and recreational The second outstanding needs of children of the elementary school ages. need is the extension of public educat ion to pre-grade school children. The kindergarten is generally accepted as the responsibility of the public Pennsylvania and yet, due to inadequate facilities, school system The third need is for suppleBloomsburg fails to provide such service. menting the indoor and outdoor recreational facilities of the existing high school. . m ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS EXISTING SCHOOLS Ben jamin Franklin Elementary School Over 20 percent of the children of elementary school age of Bloomsburg are being educated at the Benjamin Franklin Elementary School of Bloomsburg State Teachers College, at no cost to the taxpayers of Bloomsburg, This school provides for kindergarten and grades 1 to 6 with 30 students per class, as well as a special class of 20, The facilities provided for education and recreation are modern and complete. Existing Town Elementary Schools Bloomsburg is served by two ancient structures, constructed in 1870 and 1875, - the Third Street and the Fifth Street Schools, A better realization of what the age of these structures implies in relation to public education, lies in the fact that the two buildings were constructed 20 and 25 years prior to the passage of the first compulsory school attendance law in Pennsylvania, These two 12 room school houses provide space only for purely instructional classrooms. The toilet facilities are located in dark, dank, poorly lighted and poorly ventilated basements. As structures, they cannot be considered, by any standard, adequately serving as elementary schools. Let us examine some of the other characteristics of these schools: twenty [ 1 ] 1 : i i •j i i i I i i ] 3 i L i. Location: They are very well-located with respect to the residences of the school population as is indicated on the However, the sites are map titled "Proposed School Plan". subject to criticism in that a large number of children must cross main traffic arteries and railroads in traveling to and from school. 2. Site Area: The Third Street School site is 1.25 acres of which only 0.85 acres are available for out-door recreational facilities. The Fifth Street School has a site area of only 0.77 acres of which only 0.37 acres are available for play space. It is generally accepted that the minimum site area for an elementary school is five acres. There is no need to analyze any structural aspects of these buildings that are older than 95 percent of the residents of the Town. It is surprising that the parents have tolerated suck poor facilities for the education of their children. The State Department of Education has, on numerous occasions, informally protested against the continued use of these ancient structures. These buildings must be replaced almost immediately by structures and sites that not alone meet today's minimum requirements, but schools that will not be outdated for many years to come. ESTIMATE OF FUTURE NEEDS On the basis of the population estimates and school census statistics indicated that Bloomsburg will have a need for accommodating 784 elementary school students by 1960. In addition, facilities will be required for 69 kindergarten students. This is recommended as the design capacity for new schools, it is RECOMMENDATIONS Two sites for elementary schools are recommended to replace the two ancient and seriously inadequate existing schools. The geographic distribution of the population of Bloomsburg indicates that two schools cannot serve the entire Town and be within one-half mile walking distance of all students. On the other hand, the total number of elementary school children does not warrant any more than two schools. Thus, there must always be some children who walk more than one-half mile to school. School Site No. I This recommended site is the vacant block bounded by Market, Fifth Jefferson and Sixth Streets. It comprises 3.8 acres of well graded land. Although this area is less than the minimum of five acres that would be desired for an elementary school, it is the only sizeable tract of vacant land located within the built-up area of the Town, The site area might be considered as being supplemented by the establishment of a play area in the site of the existing Third Street School - a matter of 1.25 acres. twenty-one [ : ; : i i i i i i i : PROPOSED SCHOOL PLAN BLOOMSBURG & VICINITY PI \ N Y -S 1. TOWN PLANNING TOWN BLOOMSBURG A V SURVEY PLANNING mich*el ai'EB, jn eohSULflhG I : : t : " ROCHESTER. PENNSYLVAN N 1 COMMISSION \* This site, it must be recognized, is the only large block of vacant land above flood level that is at all centrally located. It is the only possible site for an elementary school in the western part of Town. On the other hand, the value of this site makes it economically unfeasible for it is to be acquired by purchase or condemnation. Even if the School Board were to ignore the unsound economics of the extremely high site cost per student served, the limited borrowing power of the School Board would necessarily delay for a number of years, the carrying out of this badly needed program of replacement of ancient school buildings. Therefore, it is recommended that the School Board immediately consult with the owners of this property and with civic associations to develop some plan whereby the School Board may acquire this site by means other than purchase or condemnation. School Site No. 2 This site is the vacant rolling land located between Anthony Avenue and Brugler Street and between Oak Street and a point 120 feet east of -jtU'Locust Street. It will be noted that the school population thins out near this site. But it is in this direction that much of the growth of the Town is taking and will take place. This site will serve the new homes being constructed on Lightstreet Road, College Hill, Fifth Street, and Berwick Road, These areas of growth represent a major portion of the total growth of the Town This site comprises 8.14 acres in all, of which approximately six are suitable for development with school building and playground. The remainder must be acquired partly to provide better access to the lower area near Fifth Street and partly because it would become wasteland for, without the upper area, it is worthless. This wooded area on a steep slope could be developed as a natural park - a desirable adjunct to a school site. School Structures It is recommended that the Market Street site contain an elementary school of 16 classrooms to serve grades 1 to 6; a multi-purpose room to serve as gymnasium and auditorium for indoor active and passive recreation and entertainment as well as group educational activities; and kindergarten facilities for one class. The kindergarten should have its own outdoor play space, entrance and washroom facilities all separated from those of the older children. For the children in the grades there should be provided a grassy area for softball, soccer and similar games as well as a paved area for volley ball, roller skating, etc. Estimated construction cost is $400,000, Site No, 2 is proposed as a ten classroom school so designed as to permit future expansion if needed This school will also contain the indoor recreational facilities recommended for the above school as well as similar kindergarten facilities, However, this site will permit the out- tuenty-two A "*^ 4\ <* n nst .- £i*tiah I&3SES — I ~1, — r J_4^ J-i* i i J f- »* ' »' ' — & i y _L1_ .!__ j J j ** » &*. 4L___^L__i I JL FIFTH _>^ STREET PLAN PERSPECT I VE PROPOSED MARKET STREET SCHOOL BLOOMSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA door play space to be much more extensive than that of the Market Street Construction cost is estimated at $325,000. site. Existing High School It is estimated that the existing high school will be adequate to accommodate future enrollment insofar as class-room facilities are concerned. (l) It However, the high school building has two outstanding deficiencies: is located on the edge of the main business area, requiring that students intermingle with the commercial traffic congestion and (2) It is seriouslylimited with respect to provision of both indoor and outdoor recreational facilities. Due to the heavy investment already in the school building, built in 1925, and due to the inability to transfer the building to another use, it The realiis impossible to alleviate these disadvantages by relocation. zation of a Community Center Building on an adjoining site as discussed in the section on "Recreation" will supplement the recreation facilities and do much to alleviate that deficiency. However, the disadvantages in location are at present insurmountable. RECOMMENDED PROGRAM The program recommended to the School Board is a minimum program providing two new elementary schools. Due to the limited borrowing power of the School District, ($234,000 as of 1948) the two schools can only be constructed in 1952 and 1960, despite the need for immediate replacement of the existing elementary school buildings. The new buildings will permit the provision of kindergarten facilities for only one-half of the estimated demand. It is hoped that the School District will find some method to expand its program by additional income to permit provision of two additional kindergarten classes. In order to minimize the walking distance of these very young children, such facilities will have to be located in other than the elementary schools. The existing school sites could very well serve this purpose after construction of the new school buildings. On the basis of an estimated $45,000 available each year under current tax rate and income, and existing indebtedness, the following program is recommended* 2948 - Acquisition of Elementary School Site No. 2 for future struction and minor improvement of the site for use as play field until construction of this school in ig6o. improvements can be designed and located to serve also the ultimate use of this site for school purposes. cona All for twenty-three 1949 ~ Architects fees to be paid for the preparation of necessary plans and specifications for the construction of the Market This will permit of construction starting as Street School. The architects fee has been soon as bond issue is approved. computed as 8 percent of the estimated cost of construction of $425,000 of whtck 75 percent of this fee is for preparation of designs and specifications tg$i - Redemption of 2926 bond issue of $125,000 from reserve fund as set up under this program. 2952 - Immediate issuance of a $400,000 bond issue for construction of Market Street School, interest rate estimated at 2%. 2952 - Capital outlay of $10,000 for supplementary equipment for neto school, 2959 - $20,000 capital expenditure for current revenue to pay legal and architectural fees for the preparation of designs and specif icat ions for new elementary school No. 2 to be constructed in 2960, 2960 - Bond issue of $325^000 at estimated 2% for construction of Borrowing power estimated to have increased School .\'o. 2, to $507 ,000 by increase in assessed valuation. 2972 - Final bonds redeemed. SUMMARY The above recommended program provides for replacement of the two inadequate elementary schools with modern structures and facilities that will meet present day educational requirements. The program as set forth can be realized within the financial limitations of the local school board and with no increase in the school tax rate. Completion of the building program can be effected within the next twllve years, the Market Street School being built in 2952 and the Fourth Street School in i960. existing, twenty-four SCHOOL REORGANIZATION Act 361, of the 1947 General Assembly provides for consolidation of schools and reorganization of School Attendance Areas and Administrative The provisions of this Act as carried out Districts throughout the State, in Columbia County will have a definite influence upon the above school program and presents a challenging opportunity for coordination of local and County school planning efforts. The Columbia County School Plan prepared in accordance with directions embodied in the act incorporates Bloomsburg in an Elementary School Attendance Area with Montour and Hemlock Townships, For the purpose of high school attendance, Mount Pleasant Township is also included in the Attendance Area, The entire Attendance Area centers on both elementary and For the purposes secondary school facilities tp be provided in Bloomsburg, of school administration the Bloomsburg Attendance Area is incorporated in a larger Administrative District with Scott, Orange, Centre and Mifflin Townships, Ultimate realization of this program will require expansion of the proposed Fourth Street School to contain 18 class-rooms. This can be easily accomplished on the recommended site and with the proposed flexible type of school construction. The present high school facilities in Bloomsburg will be adequate to service the entire Attendance Area with no additions required, except in provision of the additional recreation facilities recommended. It should be noted that while the additional borrowing power of townships in the Attendance Area or Administrative District can be used to supplement the required building program, the added fiscal capacity is not so great as would first appear. Bringing in these township areas requires an additional $165,000 to be spent in the school improvement program while adding only $67,800 to the Bloomsburg School Board's total borrowing capacity. On the basis of the entire Administrative District financial requirements for school improvements are increased by $650,000 while the additional Potential borrowing capacity is only about $220,000. , It is apparent that on a reorganized, larger will require State aid. assist municipalities in accomplishment of much needed school improvements area basis, and in a reasonable length of time, The State School Authority already appointed to financing school improvements will no doubt be effective for this purpose. However, State funds will likely not be available unless the proposed improvements are in accordance with a consolidation and reorganization plan specified in Act 361. Constant cooperative action will be required with adjoining townships as well as the County in carrying out this program. twenty- five : : i PARKS AND RECREATION Every adult in Bloomsburg should ask himself the following questions; "Where did I play when I was six years old, where when twelve, and where when eighteen!" Most of us will discover that what was then play area is We But let us go further. no longer available to the children of today. A recreationcannot consider that recreation is purely a child's affair. both active and al program involving both indoor and outdoor facilities passive recreation must serve all age groups of the community. , , The complex conditions encountered in modern everyday life serve to intensify the need for mental relief and physical exercise and relaxation* With increasing specialization of work and training activities, additional leisure time has of necessity been made available. The 40-hour week has placed upon the community the additional responsibility of providing means for a proper utilization of leisure time - a utilization that will provide relaxation from the intensified activity of earning a livelihood and utilization of those capabilities not used in production. EXISTING FACILITIES .As discussed in the section of this report entitled "Existing Land Use", the Town of Bloomsburg has very limited recreational facilities of any kind. There are two existing recreational facilities which bear mention and which can be used as part of a larger proposed program. One is the high Bchool athletic field, (3,5 acres), which, though poorly located, can be used as an athletic area for school teams and other organized athletic There are several shortcomings concerned with this facility: (1) groups. it is the only large athletic area available and is not supplemented by a regular practice field; (2) being in use for organized athletic teams, it does not offer the opportunity for participation in sports by unofficial unorganized groups; and (3) there is no organized off-street parking area A proposed recreation program should rectify for the use of spectators these shortcomings. . The other existing facility referred to is a small park (1,8 acres), located along Main Street on the west end of Town. This area is far too small and poorly located for extensive use. If supplemented by similar areas located throughout the Town, it could serve a strictly neighborhood recreational function. There are several other small play areas located as adjuncts to the existing elementary schools and the high school. These areas are considered as inadequate and in fact will be revised as part of the proposals on schools and the community center War Memorial. The vacant area at the referred to as "park" commonly and the Town owned by foot of Market Street nor mainimproved neither present is at such. It is not considered as distance great and at line flood the below Location tained as park area. except use for unfeasible area this render population from the center of as reservation. twenty-six RECREATIONAL NEEDS WES OF RECREATIONAL AREAS 1. Play Lots: - small local play areas for pre-school-aged children equipped for the use of the children and with benches, etc. for mothers in supervising' play, located within 40 units required. 1/8 mile of all Town residents. 2. Playgrounds - Active play areas for children ages 5 to 14 during Such playgrounds school and after school hours. should also include a small area reserved for use as Thus two play a play lot for the younger children. facilities can be combined in one area. Maximum walking distance to playground should be 1/4 to 1/2 Tvo units required. 3-5 acres each. mile. 3. Play field - large active play area should be available to high school students and grown-ups for active sports such The Play field can very as baseball football, etc. well have adjacent to it a Playground and a Play lot, thereby providing facilities for the entire family. A community recreation One unit required, 20 acres. buildings should be included as part of the Play field. , 4. Park Lands and Reservations - should be provided for both active and passive outdoor recreation. These facilities should take advantage of natural topographic features such as vcods, streams, hills, etc. and should offer hiking trails, picnic areas, bridle paths, etc. The provision of all the features necessary to meet the above standards would not be at all feasible for the Town of Bloomsburg. Not that such facilities are unnecessary, but due to the compact nature of the development of the Town, inadequate open space is available to provide facilities where necessary. Therefore, the above standards have been applied in limited manner to permit adaptation to existing resources, RECOMMENDATIONS COMMUNITY RECREATION CENTER BUILDING AS BLOOMSBURG WAR MEMORIAL There is no better form of memorial in honor of those citizens of the Town that gave their lives in the last war than a Community Center, They served Nation , Commonwealth and Town to the maximum, and it is indeed fitting that the people of the Town memorialize their service by providing a means of continuous, perpetual service to the community. They gave their lives for all of us - adults, children and our children's children - and we can best show our gratitude by continuing this service to the community. twenty-seven It is recommended that a community recreation building be constructed with funds raised by popular subscription on the inadequate "play space" west of the high school building. This structure will provide an indoor swimming pool, gymnasium with balcony, bowling alleys, children's play The rooms, several rooms for meetings, reading, talks and discussions. gymnasium can also be used as a dance floor. With adjacent lounges and kitchens it can be utilized for community banquets or as a snack bar for participants in games and dances. The facilities contained within the Community Center can be used to supplement the inadequate gymnasium facilities of the high school during In addition, the auditorium and vocational facilities of the school hours. high school can be used to supplement the Community Center after school The Community Center Building hours, for all members of the community. therefore performs a two-fold function. COMMUNITY PLAYFIELD Here again a dual-purpose proposal is made. It is recommended that the Town and the Fair Association co-operate in developing a community playFor 50 weeks a year the Town field on the eastern end of the Fairgrounds, will have a highly desirable outdoor recreation area, and during Fair Week all facilities will be available to the Fair Association, An additional week will be available for transformation to and from Fairground purposes. It is proposed that the Town arrange with the Fair Association for lease and improvement of the entire east end of the Fair Grounds - an area of approximately 20 acres. Development of this area can include provision of all the facilities needed for the large scale type of athletic activity, i,e, baseball, football, soccer, etc, for all groups of participants. This will include a full-sized official football field and running track centered on the grandstand, as well as a separate practice field and a field for use by non-organized participants. Another important feature of this area will be an outdoor swimming pool designed for full-scale public use, as well as for Fair-time use in aquatic entertainment. Included also can be ample tennis courts, adequate space for lawn games, play facilities for smaller children", and a large organized parking area* EXISTING ATHLETIC FIELD During the period of development of the Fairground area, the existing athletic field will continue to be used in its present capacity. Should this prove to be an extended period of time, measures should be taken to provide relief for the parking problem encountered at this site, as well as to provide additional area for a suitable practice field. There exists an area of vacant land south of the athletic field which is suitable for both these purposes. This vacant area, north of Ninth Street and west of Iron Street, comprises almost 6,5 acres, A temporary practice field and parking area could be established in this location with a minimum of clearing and grading. twenty-eight When the larger recreational project at the Fairgrounds is completed and placed in operation it is recommended that the entire recreation system be revaluated on the basis of experience and a use be proposed for It is probable that it will still be needed as a the athletic field. supplement to playfield activities, while it may prove more expedient to develop it as a different type of recreation area, PLAYGROUNDS Playground facilities will be developed as a part of the proposed new elementary school sites. It is estimated that approximately 2.5 acres of land will be available for playground development in the Fifth Street site, while about 4,0 acres will be available on the other site. The total area is slightly less than that desired, but here the scarcity of vacant land, especially on the Fifth Street site, modified the solution. On the other hand, these facilities will be well located within reasonable walking distance of nearly the entire population, as discussed more fully in the school report. It is recommended that a Playlot area also be incorporated in the Fourth Street site, in order to avoid acquisition of another site in this general vicinity for this purpose, PLAYLOTS As indicated above Playlots are recommended to be developed on the Fourth Street Elementary School site and on the Fairgrounds Playfield proposal. Other Playlots are recommended for development as shown on the Recreat ion Map, WOODED AREAS AND RESERVATIONS There exists one remaining recreational need to be satisfied. This need is concerned with, provision of wooded reservation areas, with picnic and camping facilities, scenic spots, hiking trails, bridle paths, etc. There are numerous wooded areas within the Town limits which can satisfy these conditions, and it is recommended that these areas be acquired and reserved for public recreational use. Very little cost will be encountered in development of these areas, A minimum of underbrush removal and provision of a few picnic tables, shelters and outdoor camp-fires should suffice. The areas recommended can be seen on the Recreation Map, Additional areas that are or would become virtually waste land are recommended in the section on Ultimate Land Use to be acquired for reforestation. This also .will make available additional woodland suitable for recreation. twenty-nine r i 'j 'i 'I j J PROPC SED RECREATION PLAN BLOOMSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA . r - L SUMMARY OF RECREATION PROGRAM Bloomsburg, Pa, Acreage Facilities Provided Type Area Location Community Center Present High school site and adjoining property Community Athletic Center East end of fair grounds Athletic Park Iron St. between 7th and 8th Sts. 3*5 Athletic field and grandstands (temporary practice field and parking area to be provided) Playground New 5th St. 2.5 Large game court, swings, slides 3.8 Recreation bldg., swimming pool, gymnasium, arts and crafts, outdoor play space 20.1 Official athletic field and grandstand practice field, field for unorganized participants, swimming pool, tennis courts, parking area School site Playground New 4th St. 4.0 School site Playlot In athletic area at fairgrounds 2.5* Playlot In new 4th St. School site 0.5* Playlot In old 5th St. School site 1.2 Playlot In old 3rd St. School site 1.4 Playlot Intersection of Glen Ave. & Millville Eoad 0.8 Acreage is included in larger area indicated. Swings, sand-boxes, slides, see-saws, benches and park area n 11 11 11 n 11 11 it SUMMARY OF RECREATION PROGRAM Bloomsburg, Pa, Type Area; Location Playlot In block between Fair Ave. and 1st Street 0.8 Playlot 9th St. and Bailroad Avenue 1.1 Playlot 9th St. and Poplar Street l.k Playlot West end of Main Street Strip along river and Fishing Creek South and west boundaries. Includes riverfront 2.3 Wooded Recreation Area "park". Acreage 79-5 Facilities Provided Swings, sand-boxes slides, eee-saws, benches, & park area ii ii H ti ii ii Benches., tables, fireplaces, bridle path, hiking trails, picnic shelters ] Wooded Recreation Area Between raceway and Fishing Creek northeast to Arbutus Park Wooded Recreation Area North of Light -Street Road, below hospital Wooded Recreation Area Areas between proposed highway by-pass and built-up area 90. k 2.9 180.3 Benches and tables Benches, tables, fireplaces, hiking trails, picnic shelters , SEWERS AND SEWAGE DISPOSAL SEWAGE DISPOSAL A plan has already been adopted by the Town Council for a sewage disposal plant and a site has been acquired. This is in accordance with a directive of the State in carrying out its stream purification program. The financing, construction and operation of this sewage disposal plant, and perhaps garbage disposal, is to be accomplished by a Municipal Authority set up in accordance with recent State legislation, SEWAGE COLLECTION SYSTEM EXISTING SITUATION Despite the tremendous investments the Town has made in its sewer system, no complete record is available of the system and no attempt is made to maintain a record of new construction. This is one of the deficiences resulting from the absence of a full-time administrator in the Town government. The absence of a sewer plan for the entire Town prevents maximum utilization of all sewers constructed. Each new sewer extension must be treated as a separate unit to serve immediate demand, instead of a part of a larger plan for the drainage area which will meet tomorrow's needs as well as today* s. The growth of the Town northward and eastward will require considerable revamping of all sewer trunk lines in the relatively near future, RECOMMENDATIONS It is recommended that when the Municipal Authority is established to undertake the construction and operation of the Sewage Disposal System, the entire sanitary sewer system of the Town be operated by the Authority, A condition may be imposed that the Authority have prepared a comprehensive plan for a sewer system for all the area in Town that has potential for development. It is not recommended that this design include the area classified as agricultural use on the Ultimate Land Use Map, With the Municipal Authority operating the Sewage Disposal System and the Sewage Collection System, all activities concerning sanitary sewers can be consolidated into one agency. thirty AVAILABL BLOOMSBUR p i; x \ S '«»( ^i TOWN L»JM P L A H , 'T~- TOWN BL00MSBUR6 T: MiCMAEL BflKtR. GONSVLtttiG f •:• \f l JR s ROCHESTtR ET # AREA SERVED AREA SERVED AREA SERVED \ \ ./ AVAILABLE UTILITIES BLOOM.SBURG & VKINTH ! \ \ TOWN BLOOMSBURG Y S J. PLANNING TOWN Y SURVE PLANNING 1947 \ COMMISSION \.*Vy SURFACE DRAINAGE The storm water drainage system is inadequately designed and maintained. A comprehensive design is necessary. The damage to pavements and private property in a short time would pay for the design of a comprehensive system of storm water drainage. One of the difficulties of storm water drainage in Bloomsburg is the unsound layout of existing streets. The steep slopes of some streets act as stream beds, concentrating the water to an extent that prevents interception by drains and basins. The control over the development of new sub-divisions that the Town Planning Commission will have will prevent the recurrence of this error, TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY Before any sewer system, either sanitary or storm water, can be designed, or properly designed extensions made to the existing system, a topographic survey of the Town should be made. This survey should show all street: grades, curbs, general topography, location of all sewers and drains as well as elevations, etc. This survey can provide information that will result in great savings in the design and location of public improvements. Co-operative effort between the Town Council and the Municipal Authority upon this project will result to the mutual advantage of both. thirty-one FUTURE RESIDENTIAL EXPANSION In order to anticipate the outcome of future expansion, it is necessary to understand some of the factors that are likely to influence residential growth. An analysis of expansion tendencies includes study of the following features: z. Family needs for housing, due to population growth. 2. Availability of sites suitable for residential development because of desirable topographic features, location, etc. From the above information, estimates can be made as to housing units likely to be produced in future years, together cation of area and location of sites likely to be developed. mation will be invaluable in providing a basis for the zoning undeveloped areas, the number of with an indiThis inforof presently HOUSING NEEDS On the basis of anticipated population growth, and allowing for the provision of new dwelling units already accomplished during the war years by "conversion" and "doubling up" it is estimated that Bloomsburg will have developed a total need for new housing by 1960 of 531 dwelling units. This will require a construction rate of 44 dwelling units per year. — During the construction boom years - 1920-29 - there was a total of 391 dwelling units constructed in Bloomsburg, or a yearly construction rate of 39 In the latter half of this period, homes were built at the rate of 43 units. units per year. These facts indicate a capacity for local absorption of a subtained construction period of the magnitude estimated above. Inasmuch as most of the. existing housing is of the single family detached and semi-detached type, new construction will probably continue to be of that variety with an increasing preference shown for the detached house. However, due to the large number of working couples in Bloomsburg, a sizeable market may be found for the garden type apartment - the two- story, walk-up with adjoining yard space. It is generally designed to accommodate small, low-rent apartments, placed one above the other and each containing kitchen, bath, living room and one to three bedrooms. As nearly as can be determined, most of the families seeking this type of housing can afford no more than $40 per month rental. Rental housing today, or within the foreseeable future, is not available at this figure. If housing is to be made available, some form of assistance is necessary. Whether it takes the form of to year tax abatement, utilization of Town acquired land, or any other form of assistance from the municipality, or even a modern form of insurance company, will depend upon local attitudes. It is merely the function of this survey to indicate whether or not land is available for the housing that is required. How the existing demand can be rendered an effective demand (able to pay) and whether or not it should be, is for local thirty-two determination. It must be recognized that Bloomsburg has never had dwelling units produced within the full income range of its residents. AREAS FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT A study of open areas within the Town limits indicated that ample space exists to accommodate 808 new dwelling units in the following probable price categories: Moderate priced dwel lings Intermediate priced dwellings High priced dwellings Total 408 Units 200 Units 200 Units 808 Dwelling Units TRENDS AND IMPLICATIONS Although the above analysis indicates that a foreseeable residential construction boom can be absorbed on existing sites within the Town limits, some further implications will bear analysis. The natural tendency is for new construction to take place along existing transportation routes, while the bulk of sites discussed above is on totally raw land, A suddenly released and unplanned-for construction boom might follow the high ground along Lightstreet Road or in the open areas along Berwick Road, quickly stretching out into the neighboring township. This would involve a number of complications, including a loss to the Town of taxable property. It is evident that, for the community's welfare, every effort should be made to encourage development of those suitable sites located within the Town limits. It is unlikely, however, that the suitable raw areas lying on the fringes of the developed area will be built upon by individuals seeking new building lots. On the other hand, well planned, larger scale developments on these sites might well prove attractive to prospective buyers, neutralizing the trend to out-of-town ribbon development. Attractively laid-out developments in these areas may also have the effect of encouraging additional development by those potential buyers who are on the border-line This factor is important in offsetting the naturally of indifference. lagging features of the market, bringing actual construction up to meet the developed need. From a longer range viewpoint, the competition of out-of-town sites is bound to be partially successful in finding a market among Bloomsburg residents* This possibility is evidence of the need for a wider planning area than that contained within present political boundaries. Its potential disadvantages can bs offset only through cooperative planning action with the adjoining township. thirty-throe '33 DESIRABLE INDUSTRIAL AREAS AND RESIDENTIAL SITES TOWN OF COLUMBIA TOWN BLOOMSBURG COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLANNING SURVEY 1947 K* AREA SUITABLE FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT $K AREA SUITABLE FOR INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT MICHAEL BAKER. JR ROCHESTER . ULTIMATE LAND USE The trends and implications indicated by the existing land-use analysis, together with the proposals contained in the studies on schools, highways, parking and recreation, have resulted in the formulation of an over-all ultimate land-use plan, which is presented on the Ultimate LandUse Map, Used in conjunction with projected public works, the zoning ordinance, and the regulation of new subdivisions, the ultimate land-use plan can act as an aid in guiding future Town development. In addition to the changes indicated in other sections of the report, some further recommendations have been made in the ultimate land-use proposals* THE FLOOD PLAN The Ultimate Land-Use Plan endeavors to deter any building in areas Such development would below the 1936 flood line as shown on the map. prove costly to the Town, to the property owner, and to the entire community. Through zoning control an attempt is made to deter the installation of municipal services such as streets and sewers in this area, A more forceful recommendation to prevent Buch undesirable, uneconomic, and unnecessary development along the proposed Highway By-Pass is made in the section on "Ee forest rat ion", flood control in Bloomsburg is not economically feasible, A minimum plan for flood control in Bloomsburg investigated by the U. S. Army Engineers stated "The annual charges for flood protection works investigated for Bloomsburg greatly exceeded the annual benefits which would be ob- tained— "(1) RESIDENTIAL USE In the foregoing section on "Future Residential Expansion" it has bean indicated that Bloomsburg can accommodate foreseeable residential development on sites located within the Town limits. Development of large desirable vacant areas, such as the hillside lying on country club and hospital property, can be accomplished if future residential areas are designed in advance, as integral wholes. Street patterns can be designed so as to encourage only local residential traffic while at the same time take advantage of natural topographic features. As needs for additional housing become apparent, portions of the area can be developed in accordance with the over-all plan and layout. Used in combination with subdivision regulations specifying minimum sized lots, the process can result in well laid out, attractive and healthful residential neighborhoods, a boon to the entire community. (1) Letter of August 27, 1947, Baltimore District Engineer thirty four COMMERCIAL USE Commercial facilities have been consolidated in various centers throughout the town and have been classified according to the type and level of service performed: 1. Central Business Area - As a result of the off-street parking lot, it is estimated that the Central Business Area will beThis will involve furcome consolidated in the area above. ther commercial development southward to Third Street to take This full advantage of frontage on the proposed parking area. commercial, high level business, central area will offer a of and entertainment features to the surrounding regional population. 2. !fei ghborhood Shopping Centers - Specific centers have been proposed for use in servicing residential neighborhoods with The areas indicated are already everyday shopping facilities. partly developed with such facilities and with zoning enforcement, further development can be kept within the prescribed , centers, 3. Decentralized Automotive - Commercial Areas - Specific commercial areas have been proposed on the fringes of the developed area, along main highways and at important highway intersections. Existing development of this tyPe has been considered, and the impact of the new highway has also been evaluated. Commercial development in these areas will likely be of a speeial type, including service stations, used car lots, roadside stands, and farm machinery show rooms. INDUSTRIAL USE The entire strip along the B, L, & W, Railroad has been proposed for industrial use. The areas included are all at least partially developed with industrial facilities now, and it is anticipated that the trend will continue, forcing out the few spots of isolated housing. Scattered industrial facilities and those which constitute intrusions into residential areas have been declared non-conforming uses. Allowance has been made for their eventual relocation in the proposed industrial area, SEMI-PUBLIC USE In order to open up some of the above areas for residential development, reorganization of the present country club and hospital areas has been recommended. In the case of the country club, reorientation on the crest of the hill is now contemplated, and recommendations are in conformity with the contemplated plans. In the case of the hospital, ample room has been allowed for any future expansion needs. thirty-fiv« AGRICULTURAL USE It is proposed that agricultural land also be permitted to develop with low density residential. facilities. Such development would include suburban residential estates. The only implication carried in the term "agricultural" is that Town facilities - sewers and roads - not be extended to these developemnts to the same degree as in the other areas. The peculiarity of the Town's tax system gives justification for this action especially in areas subject to flood, REFORESTRATION UROGRAM With development of the proposed highway by-pass, some problem areas of wasteland will develop. These will be between the fringe of the already built-up area and the proposed highway. These areas, totalling approximately 180 acres, all of which are below the level of the 1936 flood line, will be cut off from the agricultural area by the proposed new highway by-pass. They will be too small for agricultural use, and residential development will be unsafe if done improperly, and uneconomical if done with the proper land fill. It is proposed that these problem areas be reforestrated as a municipal woods and green-belt, with the added provision that a 100 foot strip be acquired on the south side of the highway and developed in the same manner. Accomplishment of this program will have three main disadvantages: 1. The green-belt will act as a physical barrier; preventing undesirable unsafe, residential development below the flood line. , 2. The combination woods and strip on the south side of the highway will serve as a control over location of roadside commercial stands and bill-boards. In addition, the highway by-pass will become a scenic drive. 3. Biking, camping, and picnic facilities can be provided right on the fringe of the built-up area. SUMMARY Various land uses have been discussed throughly in otber sections of this report. The inter-relation of physical improvements and the land uses cannot be stressed too greatly. The proposed parking area will provide additional commercial area which in turn will attract some existing commercial enterprises out of residential sections. The proposed highway results in the establishment of additional recreational areas. Each facility and service has implications that effect all other aspects of the Town physical and economic activities* thirty-six L I TOWN FINANCES The Town of Bloomsburg has been operating under a deficit-financing Expenditures have consistently exceeded insystem for the past 15 years. come, with the difference being made up by temporary Loans at 2-% percent interest. After receipt of go percent of its tax income for 1947 the Town still had $42,000 of temporary notes outstanding and three months Bloomsburg is two years behind on later this was increased to $75,000. , its income. INADEQUATE INCOME The continuing deficit is the resultant of an inadequate income rather than excessive expenditures. The total revenue of Bloomsburg in 1946 was $12.73 per capita, whereas 10 boroughs in the same population class had an average per capita revenue of $15,05. An analysis of sources of income indicates that the tax on real property provided almost 64 percent of all revenue in 1946 and almost 60 percent in 1947. The average for the ten communities mentioned above was only 44.4 percent. This indicates that although Bloomsburg has inadequate income, we cannot expect much of an increase from the tax on real property. EXPENDITURES An analysis of expenditures in 1946 indicates that more than half went to "Streets and Parks", This title is misleading, for the amount of expenditure for recreation was only $100 of the $76,159. Bloansburg has been putting its money into streets - a very important function of local government. There is no doubt that this expenditure is swollen by the back-log of needed paving maintenace delayed until 1946 by the war. However, actual expenditures for recreation should vary from $1,00 to $3.00 Per capita, whereas Bloomsburg has been spending less than 1 cent per cap ita. TEMPORARY LOANS That the existing revenue is inadequate to carry-out the necessary functions of the Town is further indicated in the continuous program of temporary financing from 1931 to 1947. For years the Town of Bloomsburg has not maintained a balance between Deficiencies in income have consistently been made-up by short term borrowing from local banks (notes payable) • In the last 15 years there never has been a month in which all "notes payable" have been paid. These temporary loans are not used, as intended, for emergency situations, but instead are used as a means of increasing income to meet expenditures. Upon receipt of taxes in July, each year outstanding "notes payable" are redeemed. However, the accumulation of such temporary loans has now reached the point where they exceed a year's tax income. Only part can be redeemed on August 1st and immediately thereafter additional loans must be made for 12 month's normal operating expenditures, its income and expenditures. thirty-seven ^i o a < < j &B*» rCO H 3 O to h- Q. . 1 ro O 1 CO z < o -J < q: o Q. 2 UJ H > z z> o o </> < _l SO O 1>_l >a: z z X 12 O 2 2 _J o cs £T CD en o o m U. o z =5 o 1- I s a v i i o a d 6 SQNVSnOHl The chart entitled "Temporary Loana Outstanding" indicates this process month by month from 1931 to date with very conservative estimates until tax§s are due in 1948. Note that after repayment of Temporary Loans in August, there still remains some debt outstanding^ This "residual debt" remains - tending to increase each year and constitutes a perpetual debt burden to the community at 2 to 2-1/2 percent interest. This "residual debt" is more clearly illustrated in the chart of that title. It can be seen by comparison with the equivalent millage scale that for most years the residual debt is so large that the leaal maximum tax income of 15 mills could not repay all the "notes payable". TAXES, RATES, AND VALUATIONS The main source of the Town revenue is through the Tax on real property. In 1946 this provided almost 64$ of the total revenue while the •arae millage on occupations increased the tax revenue to slightly more than The accompanying chart "Tax-Rate Analysis" compares the assessed 6Q%» valuation of real property and occupations, the tax rate, and the resulting tax from 1936 to date. To render annual changes comparable, each item has been expressed in terms of percentage of its 12 year average. This chart indicates that although the tax-rate has been steadily increasing, the resultant tax in dollars has not. In fact, the Town is imposing less dollars of tax today than in 293$, 1939, 2941 and 1942, when the tax rates were lower. This is due, of course, to the rapidly declining Assessed Valuation of real property. It is obvious that the Assessed Valuation of Property has been reduced to escape paying a disproportionate share of taxes to the County. However, the process has necessitated raising the tax-rate to within only 3 points of the maximum legal limit and has seriously impaired the Town's borrowing capacity. RECOMMENDATIONS INTRODUCTION Town Council must break away from the customs inherited from previous administrations and put its financial house in order. This will involve three phases of activity: (1) (2) (3) Rigid control of expenditures. Eliminate use of "Temporary Loans" except for unforseeable emergencies. Increase income to meet necessary expenditures. These three factors are inter-acting, for unless the Town has an adequate income, it cannot avoid temporary loans. As long as "notes payable" are issued, there can be no incentive to sound budgeting of expenditures. thirty-e i ght 39VTHW 1VN0I1IQQV r* to m <J- 1 1 1 ±N3~IVAin03 to CO CM | 1 en 1 en GO O >- < cc o CL UJ h- < z < > >- z UJ Q. < 3 a CO UJ cr tfc <T £ 3 O m ^^^1 10 o a: -> _l •"N CD C/> 5 o o 0) ^ ^^^^^^ 0. «s UJ U. O Ul cc to X 2 ^ s~" _J CD m to CD 1 1 2, o o m o o IO / / o CM suv~noa jo saNVsnom - i83a ivnais3d to en o - O o O o o in 0> en • • • oo CO 00 \ • • • • \ - \ 1 1 • • • 1 • 1 • • • 1 • • • 1 1 • • • 1 • 1 ".. en 1 on -•••-... 5 z o 1< 1 1 -# J ••J*" . —* < ^ < VALl ***** CO z • EVY ATE UJ Q- SED R L ASSES LfJ < < I- TAX TAX • • e> or 3 o o CD \\ ,<; ^ : i : 1 : l O en u • • / / • • • • • • / / m O o o 10 ro m O m cn O — on en ao oo (001 = 39VU3AV) X 3 Q N I INCREASING REVENUE Sources Tax on "privilege, transactions, subjects, occupations", etc, as authorised by Act 481 of the 1947 Legislature, By this act the State recognized the plight of municipalities during a period of rising costs. Probably the fairest tax authorized under this legislation as it applies to Bloomsburg is one on amusements. This would permit a sizeable source of revenue through levies on admissions to theatres, games, and the Fairgrounds and amusements therein. Re-evaluation of Fees and Permits for Town utilities Fees and permits must be re-examined to bring them in line with present day costs. Local Assessment for Benefit The cost of improvements of a local nature not directly benefitting the entire Town should be made the financial responsibility of the property-owners benefitted. It is common practice in many communities to assess the adjoining property owners for one-third, one-half, or all the costs for the installation of permanent paving. Increased Millage There is a question whether increased millage is justified, with real property paying almost two-thirds of the income of the Town, With additional revenue coming from other sources, and if these sources should be inadequate, a slight increase might be in order, CONTROL OF EXPENDITURES A rigid budgeting system must be adhered to - a system that will not utilize temporary financing for any purpose other than strict emergencies, A full time administrator as recommended in the section on "Organization and Administration" will be an excellent aid to Council in preparing and administering such a budget, EQUALIZATION OF ASSESSMENTS Bloomsburg must take the lead in urging a county-wide reassessment of real property. As to whether or not the recently adopted State legislation regarding County Equalization Boards is the best vehicle for such activity is a matter for local determination. However, all communities must feel that their property is assessed at the same percentage of true value as that of all other communities in the County, thirty-nine ui 3 O < H > oc a: in UJ to I- O 3 UJ UJ t- 2 H- O Q H x < o OD EC CL UJ 0- X < > ) UJ V) z z UJ a. o Z _> O o a- X I.I < UJ o «> * 5 S <_' at CO z c o -I CD la. O o o o z o o d w ui to _1 O to I- a 2- < > <e en < to u > Z a: z w UJ £E Q- UJ CO co tJ > o o O z < o i- z UI ? z ui ui o < « c UI o CO o a. s ui Bloomsburg must also improve its assessment procedure within its own boundaries. It is recommended that assessment maps be prepared to serve as the basis for assessment of real property. Unassessed and inequitably assessed properties have been found during routine investigations of other matters. LONG RANGE IMPROVEMENTS As can be seen from the accompanying chart entitled "Bonded Debt" the Town is in good financial shape with regard to borrowing capacity. The present bonded debt is at a level of approximately 30% of the debt limit and can be amortized with present expectations, by January of 1964. Additional bonded debt for public improvements can be taken on safely, provided suitable arrangements can be made to amortize such debt through the Town's taxation and budgetary program. An analysis of the impact the improvement program recommended in this report will have upon the bonded debt of the Town is considered in the section entitled "Program for Action", forty BONDED BLOOMSBURG, (AS OF JANUARY CO DEBT PENNSYLVANIA /, EACH YEAR) 175 175 150 150 125 125 100 100 75 75 50 50 25 25 < O o I*. o co Q z < CO o X (O *r cn co <r o> o IO IO * io cn cn cn CM (D IO 0> CO IO cn O u> cn CM (O cn * (0 cn ORGANIZATION! AND ADMINISTRATION In reviewing the various aspects of community needs, the function of Town administration cannot be ignored. Just as the Town's- financial condition determines the limits of improvements which can be made, so its organization determines the manner in which policies and procedures are carried out. In contemplation of an extensive community planning program, it becomes necessary to adjust the Town's administrative structure so as to implement the realization of that program, EXISTING ORGANIZATION The existing Town administrative organization is very simple. The Town Council and the School Board are the two official bodies selected by the electorate, the latter being concerned with administration of education programs, while the council is concerned with community problems of a broader nature. The Town Council performs executive and legislative functions, determining policy and administering the resultant procedures. It has two chief aids in performance of these tasks; a staff agency, made up of the tax collector, auditors, assessors and constables; and five operating agencies, utilized in administration of programs concerning health, public works, police protection, etc, DEFICIENCIES There are several outstanding deficiencies in the present organizational set-up - deficiencies caused by the historical background of the old unchanged form of Town Government, LACK OF FULL TIME ADMINISTRATOR There is a need of vertical integration, or drawing together of the various governmental activities under a full-time operating head. At present, there is no full-time employee concerned with coordination and management of all the Town's official activities. As a result, the council is obliged to assume a management function on a part-time basis and spends a large portion of its monthly meetings in discussion of purely adminstrative and technical details. This results not only in inadequate management - but the council loses its primary function, that of formulating policy. .• LACK OF COMMUNITY PLANNING ORGANIZATION There exists no broadly representative citizens organization which can maintain liaison between the Town officials and *he electorate^ The electorate naturally exercises voting control over council. However, citizens' viewpoints on policy can be represented only through individuals and special groups or organizations. As a result, the majority of the citizenry is not closely informed on Town policy and has no medium of expression. forty-one OTHER ADMINISTRATIVE NEEDS The above cited deficiencies concern organization per se, and can be remedied with a minimum of readjustment. In addition, certain other aids will be required in administration of the contemplated planning and zoning Into this category will fall the municipal authorities, zoning procedures. board of appeals, building commission, etc, RECOMMENDATIONS TOWN PLANNING COMMISSION The Town Planning Commission authorized by local ordinance has not yet been appointed. Potential candidates have been serving as a steering committee and have had an excellent opportunity to work with the Planning Consultants as the Town plan was being made. It will be its job to analyze the proposals made herein, recommending approval or disapproval to council. It will then have to establish procedures and regulations necessary for development of these proposals. In addition, members of the Planning Commission will be faced with the problem of meeting with proponents of various plans, etc. On the whole it will assume a permanent advisory role to council in establishment of public policy and to the school board in formulation of school improvement programs, PLANNING ENGINEER It is recommended that a full-time Planning Engineer be hired by the Planning Commission with the approval of Town Council, This Planning Engineer will serve as technical advisor to the Commission, make the necessary investigations and analyses and report to the Commission for policy determination. In addition, Town Council should utilize the Planning Engineer as its full-time administrator to co-ordinate and execute the policies established by Council, The Planning Engineer will be in direct contact with the operating agencies on a day-to-day basis and will be able to make administrative decisions as questions arise. He will be in a position to supervise financial procedures, eliminating wasteful practices and unnecessary expenditures, resulting in greater value received per Town dollar expended. He will relieve Council of its present administrative burdens and prove an excellent advisory aid to the official Planning Commission on planning problems and their administration, CITIZENS' PLANNING ASSOCIATION The Citizens' Planning Association can be an excellent means of encouraging citizen participation in planning on a broad and comprehensive scale. Functioning properly, it will act as an intermediary between its membership and the official Planning Commission, Acting in this capacity it will bring citizens' attitudes and proposals to the attention of Town officials, as well as explain the importance and meaning of official proposals to the members. Such an organization might well provide a quarterly public cation for its membership, discussing various planning proposals and stimulating planning consciousness in general. forty-two In order to secure the broadest possible representation, this Citizens* Association can be organized on an individual as ?;ell as organizational membership basis. This will involve individual membership at a nominal fee, and organization membership at an appropriate fee. A Board of Directors could be elected part by vote of the general membership and part by vote of the various organizations. The Board of Directors can carry out the memberships decisions and perform the necessary administration required. The Board could very easily be broken down into committees on various subjects and thereby efficiently handle all matters relating to its function, ADMINISTRATION OF ZONING ORDINANCE The Building Inspector At the present time a building permit is required for all construction within the Town limits although there is no Building Code» It is recommended that a Building Code be adopted to protect the safety and welfare of the people. The Zoning Ordinance would be administered and enforced by the Building Inspector, Proper administration requires that definite penalties be established that would deter non-compliance with the requirements of building permits for all construction. The applicant for a permit must be required to submit plans and necessary detailed information to determine whether or not the proposed structure conforms to zoning and building code requirements. Zoning Board of Appeals A review board will be necessitated with the institution of zoning in the Town, A Board of Appeals is an administrative body with quasi-judicial powers whose function is to apply the zoning ordinance and map, as adopted by the legislative body of the Town, in special and exceptional cases. In performing this function, the Board is given authority to grant exceptions and variances from the strict letter of the Zoning Ordinance, but all such exceptions and variances must be consistent with the zoning plan regulations as mapped and prescribed by the zoning ordinance, and in harmony with its general purpose and intent, MUNICIPAL AUTHORITY The term "Municipal Authority" has been mentioned in reference to offstreet parking facilities and a sewage disposal system. Under State laws, Town Council may establish an "Authority" as a special corporation to acquire, construct and operate facilities devoted wholly or partially to public and revenue producing purposes. An "Authority" is governed by a board of five members appointed by Town Council for a period of five years - (staggered terms). The "Authority" forty-three cannot pledge the credit of the Town in any way nor may it have recourse It must depend solely on its revenueto taxes or special assessments. producing projects to meet its obligations. The "Authority" has the power of eminent domain, may issue bonds, establish and manage revenue producing facilities. The business of the "Authority" must be self-liquidating and the life of the corporation is limited to 50 years, at which time the property or projects shall revert to the Town. Such property may be conveyed to the Town at an earlier date but only after all bonds issued for the project have been discharged. The following is a partial list of the facilities an "Authority" may acquire, construct or maintain: Parking Space Shopping Marketing Terminals Transportation Sewers ewage Treatment Works Incinerators Water Supply System Airports Recreation grounds and faci lities Swimming pools Playgrounds Parks Schools forty- four ZONING Zoning is the legal control for giving effect to that part of the comprehensive Town Plan that is concerned with the private use of privately owned land - as distinguished from that part that is concerned with public uses and facilities. Zoning regulates the use of land and buildings as well as the character of buildings for the general welfare of the community. Zoning is not to be construed as an end in itself, but only a means to the end of furthering and bringing about the desirable development of the community in an orderly and beneficial manner. Used properly, zoning will lessen congestion in the streets, secure safety from fire, panic, and other dangers, promote health and general welfare, provide light and air, avoid undue concentration of population, facilitate the adequate provision of municipal services, schools, parks, and other public requirements. Zoning divides the Town into various districts and establishes requirements for each district covering the following subjects: 2. 2. 3. 4. 5. Use of land and buildings Amount and location of open space surrounding new buildings to be constructed. Height of buildings Off-street parking facilities Density of population Zoning prescribes, within limitations the desirable and appropriate use and the manner of utilization for various areas or districts of the Town. In the preparation of a zoning ordinance and map, the following conditions are recognized: existing conditions peculiarities of locathe tion and topography needs of the community the rights of the property owner both as an individual and as a group, expected growth and expansion, the requirements of the various types of uses for facilities and services as well as their availability the protection and welfare The end result of all these conof the individual and the community'. siderations is the zoning ordinance which limits the use of an indi-vidual's property but, more so, protects him and his property from the effects of improper uses of his neighbor s property. , , , , , , ' TOWN ZONING PLAN Based upon the Ultimate Land Use Plan, a Zoning Ordinance and Map have been prepared and are included as a separate section of this report. This zoning plan divides Bloomsburg into six types of districts varying The least degree of restriction is imposed in degrees of regulation. upon those areas suitable for industrial development and the highest degree of control on agricultural districts on the fringes of the developing area of Town, These six types of districts consist of one Agricultural District, three Residential, a Commercial and an Industrial District, forty- five ZONING MAP TOWN OF BLOOMSBURG COLUMBIA COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA BLOOMSBURG TOWN PLANNING 1947 PREPARED MICHAEL BAKER. JR COHSULTtltO EHOIMCCR ROCHESTER, XX BY CLIFTON E ROOGERS TOWN PLAHHE* PENNSYLVANIA ULTIMATE LAND USE AND ZONING The Zoning Plan and the Ultimate Land Use Plan differ to some extent in that the latter anticipates changes further into the future than does the zoning plan. As mentioned before zoning is one of several tools to effectuate the Land Use Plan, The several blocks east of the County jail illustrate this difference. Surrounded by the jail, railroad on two sides and industry on the other two, it is natural for this area to become industrial. It contains residences in fair condition. But ultimately the County jail site will be abandoned and a large tract of land will be available to an industry. This might be an incentive for clearing the then old residential area for an industrial site. On the other hand, if this area were to be zoned industrial now, the infiltration of small industries would lead to rapid degeneration of the residential area in advance of a sound demand for all this area for industry, SUBDIVISION CONTROL Although not a part of the zoning powers, the regulation of new subdivisions is equally important and should be applied in conjunction with the Zoning Plan and Ordinance, Subdivision control regulates the layout of new residential areas so as to conform with the overall Town Development Plan, It insures that new street layouts conform to the general Town street plan and that such streets are not planned with utter disregard for natural topographic features of the land. Effective subdivision regulation also requires adequate width of streets, adequate drainage, and adequate provision of parking areas so as to avoid future problems. In requiring minimum sized building lots this control insures that future developments do not repeat the mistakes of the past. Utilized effectively the process can prove to be profitable to the land developer, the home owner and the Town government. The Town, as controlling authority, does not hold any positive control in regulation of subdivisions. The basic device to be used is in encouragement of developments which adhere to established standards. Failing this, withholding the privilege of public record of a plot can be accomplished by refusing to approve a plan which does not conform to adopted standards, BUILDING CODE Again not a part of the Zoning Ordinance, but equally important as a supplement to zoning is enforcement of a Building Code, While the Zoning Ordinance prescribes the general use, height, area and set-back lines of buildings, the building code establishes detailed requirements concerning the construction of buildings, materials to be used, location of stairways, exits, etc. forty-six : PROGRAM FOR ACTION The foregoing analyses have resulted in a number of proposals for the Town of Bloomsburg, the sum total of which constitutes the Town Development Plan - a guide to future improvement. It is obvious that all the various proposals cannot be accomplished The timing of projects in this respect will depend upon the at once. cost estimates included in each section, upon the Town's fiscal capacity as set forth in the section on "Finance", and upon the entire community's financial resources. Neither can any one individual, group or agency be held responsible for completion of all projects. Success in achievement of all the planning goals set forth will hinge largely upon the effectiveness of Town and community organization, as discussed in the section on "Organization and Administration", Given a basic financial program and an adequate framework of organiestablishment of the project program remains largely a matter of delegating responsibility for accomplishment of the various proposals to r" different community agencies - establishing priorities according to community need when financial limitations dictate, or when one agency is held responsible for more than o\ie project. Thus, once under way, work on all parts of the Development Plan can be progress at once, and continuation will become largely a matter of coordination of efforts. zation, m The following recommended Program for Action summarizes all the previous proposals requiring community action and recommends definite delegation of responsibility for accomplishment to the various community agencies. Cost estimates and recommended means of financing are indicated, and priority ratings are reconxnended where necessary, projects under one heading being listed in order of priority. Due to the methods of finance recommended, it is not expected that debt limitations will deter accomplishment of any of the projects appreciably. In the case of the recreation program to be financed by the Town there are some debt limit problems to be considered, which may require delay in certain aspects of the proposals. It is expected that negotiations with the Fair Association will absorb an interim period of time anyhow. In the case of the Community Center, the date for starting work will depend upon the degree of success in a community drive for the required funds. forty-seven ( o i * o O R O E O . O «• o I. D tri to H-, R K B •*» to 05. *» <u e +i -a » Ett e O u R *» be Co O +» a a -a ••» •** co to -to to e • >, -o --i "U r o co O 3 -CX o K C o a r -o -to co -to -«. -W a +» a a •» v. ak 3 — SO o o o w a -to cu r e a E QD «u . —» -o -a a o KM" V-. Q-, K R to - o •*> a o •» o "a -to > cu ••» o +» • ••» M —• O -a -jSt ~> is . — -to <3 th CO IM \r, O o oj CO to to •—A •^i a W H~, -to +> • o c ho co K o c s •r* o CO a ^•rt X, R • <« -ex -o V- . -to fk -to <a to v. to o •to ^ ~» -«X -CX CO *=H w a ui o o 3E O co -r aa -J H- as co o QC o © -J oj -to — to co •to u O a K a ?S -o ho X. a v. o R 3 a -o i) -ex 3 E +o ho R <u •<X R co -to O w Jo "a -to co t-, ^ a X O <* o u. -to ho -a -a o OS . 3 o o f-> co x. <a P> •** V. .CX ho •-4 •*A Cu I ss « tu tu » Qq to -to V o % H-, to co a to a o >N to to 1 X -ex t <u & to -to <o co S r^ ^h <o o> +a • to to tu to to r* to £ a -to. i~ QJ M «, M a O0 -O \h '*-> -». lo R O 3 "a K to -to s O to X a •T* +i a • -=t •to to (o to t« c ta cu u o K 3 «» cu a V, K R •to -m O to to <y u •i) CO to a to +o V. a i- o K tu 3 tu a -a — 3 E x K t3 oj t-s -« 3 ?> to -ex -> Q fee « to tu r* +i r* >N -^i -» « +o >s +-> H-, CO V. tN a o H "*> to E a o U -v» a -« a •a -c ho DK ho a cu O tu ^ ~i *•» +i T-» CO to ~-i QJ 3 Q> •*o a V 3 O o C3- -a -^ -w v ^ s o V. -fi. '<-> "** c 3 o a o • w a *a <a o +J> V03 K Q o K V o u r* E <*> -». s; to tu K K -to T* O — v» n 2 o K JD -to f-. a a N E -U -** s~, te, « 3 ~o O — •a CO u c a c ** H-, 1 C e o -^o CO -o O f~. >, 1 V. in-o CO 0) to - co t-* tn.* s t^- ~o -a <k tu H~, -<X -CX 3 o O 3 c a W c to to a co CO «* ©. >o "a K 3 -a 1 to • aw a « o «5 V- co •*o -a O K O 3 -C o CO K -o k « ^ -to 3 — O E CO E -*j K -to -to a k ^o +» e e ho to K K ho a C 3 E •« kCO s; o o o a ~o c . -s: rt V o CO rj H R to to CA »-i >> ?> o -to *» r» *-, O -to a p -Cf =55 W -to o O 3 Vf^ t» f* cn o- 01 a fcq • ^ ^i- 3 R ^5- lO d s: R 3 •v> » w -to O to CO •r» J2 co f*> V- »* -to to to 3 o to V. a a «• K V. E « o +0 v. 3 -u o a > *+-, co -to -c ^ i ^-» ' (-» t*j 1 ES o o M ^ W «U *4-l «» w g u "a o o X •• o a a r E +o -m a is^ "a -c o -0 k ho in a 3 a 3 o -a r tj V. CO R co -R -to to +> a E . R a to »* co +i «K a to ^a ••» -to -<a; >». H-, 1 CO co >* o o UI c! r-4 O C O "H O +>+>+> a o ru ft $65,000 depende const i a. S P >t-t MM CO M» CO at o o. CO fH CO Ui o BE •« ae «> u> O o © a & o u Q (-< -P a) x> • S V ^ •5 H w c > w u 0) lo U o © CO CO 03 U a C M 3E H- «9 a) ta "H 3E O i-4 Oi 1 co CO m n a •r* •h e CO CO 3 CO fl> +o fl) cr Q) W • CO co eoK O KOZ — <9 UI ae t- a. ui o *3E CV UI >1»- O — O X — UI z « UI KlS3 oi-r UI — o ce 3 o V- -to o *^ E 2 a « V. CO • o -to CO "K a +o E a -a T-» -to CO -to CO V. to CO -to CO 'T-* «U W *9= P. *. HO -R «" O o oo• +3>> m tM O 8 o o K o a R c CO o -to •»* R to *» H a N E ^* ?-, -R -o 3 R a o +o w O -to o CO to -a O -o Vo CO 3 to -a R ^ ** CU -r* * -to O «< «J ^ CD -c ? •to 3 3 r~- ho o O ••» R O cn T* w ci 3 -R ex <D co a. OJ -** -ae v. 1 H-, o at +o -o OS O. >• ^ 3B a: C9 In CO U o & S 0) -to lo" CO cO & r >. x> ^ 1 CO <3 a o •c u a o -c <* ho-** T3 R . CI +» to*» >© V o V w V- tu w • o M » +» "O -H TJ to M <w> «0 V e «: •«• +» ** =•> +» +» ti •*• to <v a a ft r .» <» -o N V) g — O o R *» e •v* k « V. •3 *• a R o K :* - c*. •* -*i -ft. <» •** e -a -** R K O K e a « a —* R a, c R O o O o 0) V> 1 o o 3 V. •.» to «o a -« -w +3 to •«» <0 sR o '«* Cj "^ •* +i 1 1 -o 1 u Q e CO o V. 3 W o O. <n <» O K t>« e Oo w +j • c ~» o a tlo ••«>.*» -M P e K C *» K H-, <d V r K a o m — o K *^ »• e -ft. K +» • o V. TJ -*^ O «* K V- a. Co -•» O O *• ;>\ « -m a w o c o a « *» o 0Q ^ »« » t>o a CO o W t» 3 «• 6-. •T» a w o u » o P «. w o v. -c *! tj o c « -c '»• "h »+> •0 "^ u o +» *a to >v K U •«• «lo « o K ~j K u TJ '•* O »» k: ^* •^ . -o •• K o o » io a c •s: -o. «>«. c u ^a C O a <» •* S-, •» w o »^ e-i v> o*tt '^+> ft. 1 1 +i M V o 3 E R a <y CO Su ?> •« u * R W a +> a +i aV <uc •*»K u Vc L. V a 3 CO r u a *• V. o ^ -c —O _l a. <s V. u r 3 R a o * o u -c o +» R i **> •*-* O <M -O t) •c o ») +» ft tvj -•» e- •** 3 , >^-i >--i • h "*-, io -a <u a CO Uc CJ -.. V. K <u "*-, o K to R a R a E o -^ -*k i» ft. o +a •s to •* -*; bA c c "O -ft. <0 V, o -w •o •»* ^c o « a* +i K O CO CO CJ i-s <5) c a) N <•> V. •* R a • >» v> ** -^i o <u t> R a O • R R •« *K -ft. ^ >N 3 o a o *- <u -o O E-, ft — +» «. o *> •• «J ae co o— X X <c o3 O ee. <o — m cj o ui -c tw c 3 o O -^ W +i -c a •fi w -a 10 01 v fu CO o o E V, CO CO CO N *• CO o CO ^ «o o< CJ V. V3 H- vy o ft. — r* •« W R u •** o o a. '<-> tco^-, «o CO *> • •o O « to oo 3 o u R w O tco -C -w -a hOC)h <a • CO -ft. -a J3 3 a »* R ^» E U E -C 3 •ft. +» E a^a «*C tia c ;»n ~a o a ^ tj a u ua a R V- t a •* -> -t-> t»o 1 3 • to w «o •u «">i » ty o en ?> -** to tu -t-» -C 1 1 a »* a 3 o a o <u o o- « -a •* •o m u r^ <u K ? K) >> -a •«• v •* k a a -» K c 10 4) -ee w K c c w t0 -^ -»* <u - 3 k to *» a *» -c to <U •*j a K O o to O -ft. a W ^d ») o-t» -ft. O V -a *» o to •<• — Cj -n O -w <u a K -a 2 a a Hi K a o N B -o o •— <o o • e <u r» CO © <> a «* «~1 •^ k •* <y R «o k K +» O a a O <0 <u « w o k a w E r* O V «j -ft. o to v. to k O <u t« v, >> 3 O 3 a V -ft. E ^ to W i -w o tuc w CO c o «* +> ^ -^» •« tig -*e - »-» V K +» N k — Co *» <w u o fa •ft. k y V O o E -ex »a a a •a tt o •a <u a t-i K w a - K 3 © . •a cr •» <a >w +» 3 v> V. a —a k s a a V, s ?> k t» o <u "a o) V, R e 3 o o v. K a o ^\ 1 •«• to ••* ^c +» —» tvi a a 3 o "j u a <o •« -o T*' •*»- c to s k 3 a •a o -B e o to t* 3 O -w « a <u CD a o •* -tt —4 a tv a "H « o to ^ 2 aK -•* <i> • •ft. ho <0 -w tka K u &o 3 s «• c JJt ' •* co o z o o ac o s w to <« K H ^J tx* -r. o ••* c o *s O 41 -O o o «jo-a a a •»* ~« «> Q •M 4) -K. in <o <n ^> K ••• « 3 O U co Mi > & a a) u> -*i . <0 V«> U +» •M -W E K a aw •o — i CO tu * w -o ft. H-, k. E a •* 5u >s K O a cn 10 <u w ts> c f^ • V, V O "a U « "S ^5 —a a E » co ** -w a •*S a V •w -lo ** k +j +i o c V. n -*J o E w >> V. a n o 3 a k •w* 5tf *4 ?\ <i> s | o c I OS >• 01 o> — o ^) -c be a o u Vl u w <u v. o VJ tn V ©. a c <u c 10 -o <u "3 a 3 3 c 3 ** c -^» <u o o o tu C5 *» ©. « 6-, o w *0 CO a- H-, tu -m M o "** -ft. C -a -w -a a) E 3 «. o -~» ij o -c w M +» ^ ti W) 'U w -M 3 « O L S k E o « -c o -c ^ +a k -w o *S 3 k to <u K V m >-. *» t* m o »-» -ri J3 10 V) •*» -« CO o o »* +i a el oe. K v. tlo <» i> "a lie +» E U 3 k a e w O as Ul Ul O Ui CO CO